Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

which of these guys beats their counterparts? old=pre-boot

nu slade vs slade

nu bats vs bats

nu nightwing vs nightwing

nu supes vs supes

nu ww vs ww

nu gl vs gl (pick whichever gl's you'd like to compare)

nu aquaman vs aquaman

nu j'onn vs j'onn

nu flash vs flash (wally)

any others you feel like adding or commenting on, feel free. be nice to make this the definitive comparison thread if we can get some people who are actually knowledgeable to comment on some of these....

If the contest comes down to strength, nuSuperman beats pre-Flashpoint Supes.
Never seen pF Supes do anything remotely on the level of nu's Earth bench or world ship push with Manhunter save when extraordinarily sun-amped. The difference seems massive, almost on preCrisis versus postCrisis levels.

On the other hand, pF had good showings even against people who vastly overpowered him, including Superboy Prime.
If he could make the fight last a bit, nuSupes would find himself with a surprisingly hard to win battle.


Following that, the only battles that seem cut and dried are the ones with Batman and Aquaman.

The latter has superior mental power. I can see nuAqua getting the same casual treatment Arthur once gave a white Martian in new world order.

And "old" Batman has taken down multiple white Martians solo. NuBatman has nothing that can compare in today's book.

Preboots mostly win, imo.

Originally posted by leonidas
which of these guys beats their counterparts? old=pre-boot

nu slade vs slade

nu bats vs bats

nu nightwing vs nightwing

nu supes vs supes

nu ww vs ww

nu gl vs gl (pick whichever gl's you'd like to compare)

nu aquaman vs aquaman

nu j'onn vs j'onn

nu flash vs flash (wally)

any others you feel like adding or commenting on, feel free. be nice to make this the definitive comparison thread if we can get some people who are actually knowledgeable to comment on some of these....

nu slade vs slade - Nu in a straight fight. Old for prep.

nu bats vs bats - Nu in a straight fight. Old for prep.

nu nightwing vs nightwing - Nu

nu supes vs supes - Old

nu ww vs ww - Old, mainly down to that lasso.

nu gl vs gl (pick whichever gl's you'd like to compare) - I thought they were the same, if not, Old.

nu aquaman vs aquaman - Nu (unless all powers e.g. TP was on hand).

nu j'onn vs j'onn - Old

nu flash vs flash (wally) - Old.