Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

How would you rank the jedi of the CW era from most to least powerful? (considering their CURRENT skill in both the force and swordsmanship)

me for example:

1: Yoda
2: Mace Windu
3: Ki Adi Mundi?
4: Yaddle?
5: ?

Originally posted by Kurk
1: Yoda
2: Mace Windu
3: Ki Adi Mundi?
4: Yaddle?
5: ?

Sorry but are you high?

Not sure which one is worse, Ki-Adi at #3 or a dead person at #4.

You've said worse.

1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Anakin


Or possibly Anakin then Mace...

Running off 5 hours of sleep sorry. Let's do as of TPM then.

1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Mundi
4. Yaddle or Koon
5. Tiin
6. Kolar
7. IDK Luminara
8. IDK Shaak Tii
9. Idk
10. Idk

Mundi is certainly not third as of TPM or during the CW.

3 is probably Depa as of TPM (at least in the EU).

Originally posted by Kurk
Running off 5 hours of sleep sorry. Let's do as of TPM then.

1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Mundi
4. Yaddle or Koon
5. Tiin
6. Kolar
7. IDK Luminara
8. IDK Shaak Tii
9. Idk
10. Idk

Not sure what I'm laughing at more mmm

ATM, it's got to be one of the following:

- The idea that Mundi > Yaddle.
- The idea that Kolar was on the council in TPM.
- The idea that Luminara was on the council at all.
- That you can plausibly rank TPM versions of these Jedi.

Originally posted by Q99
1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Anakin


Or possibly Anakin then Mace...

Nah you were right the first time. Top 3 is

1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Anakin

no question. At least in terms of winning a majority in direct combat.

But if we include piloting ability and/or one off's like Mortis, then Anakin could be higher in the list.

1) Yoda 2)Mace 3)Ani 4)Kenobi 5)Plo Koon 6)Rots Shaak Ti 7) Kit Fisto 8)Agen Kolar 9)Saeese Tiin 10) Ki adi Mundi 11) Adi Gallia 12)i don't remember this guy

Although tbh never really counted Anakin as a Council Member.

Just off the top of my head as of ROTS

1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu
3. Anakin Skywalker
4. Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Shaak Ti
6. Plo Koon
7. Ki-Adi-Mundi
8. Kit Fisto
9. Agen Kolar
10. Saesee Tiin
11. Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

1. Yoda
2. Anakin
3. Mace
4. Shaak Ti
5. Kenobi
6. Plo Koon
7. Ki Adi Mundi
8. Kit Fisto
9. Agen Kolar
10. Saeese Tiin
11. Adi Galli / Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj

Huh, we have almost the exact same list.

*shrug*

Mace and Anakin, and ROTS Ti and Kenobi are pretty interchangeable, so it might as well be exactly the same

I personally think Mace needs to be above Anakin just based on Lucas's comments that only him and Yoda can defeat Sidious (at that point in time).

Perhaps, but given how much of a factor Vapaad is in that, I find it slightly irrelevant.

Kenobi was the only Jedi bar Yoda who'd certainly beat Grievous in a fight, according to Mace. Anakin took down Dooku where Mace couldn't gain an upper hand. You can't really judge combatants solely on their ability to perform against a singular individual.

Originally posted by Selenial
Perhaps, but given how much of a factor Vapaad is in that, I find it slightly irrelevant.

Kenobi was the only Jedi bar Yoda who'd certainly beat Grievous in a fight, according to Mace. Anakin took down Dooku where Mace couldn't gain an upper hand. You can't really judge combatants solely on their ability to perform against a singular individual.


Vapaad was a factor, but that's Mace's form, so it's part and parcel of his abilities. And it would certainly aid him in defeating Dooku or Anakin as well Imo.

And I don't believe for a second that Kenobi would fair better against Grievous than Mace or Yoda. Just their TK alone would crush him.

1. Yoda //Obvious is obvious
2. Mace Windu
3. Anakin Skywalker //Mace and Anakin is pretty marginal so could go either way
4. Obi-Wan Kenobi
5. Shaak Ti //Kenobi is a better duelist so he "wins"
6. Plo Koon //More powerful than the B-team, comparable as duelist
7. Kit Fisto //Did best against Sidious
8. Saeese Tiin //Had better TK than Mace in one comic so he's over Kolar
9. Agen Kolar
10. Ki-Adi Mundi //Doesn't have the hype of the B-team
11. Adi Galli / Stass Allie
12. Coleman Kcaj //Fodder

Below Adi but above Coleman, would be Even Piell. While not a badass like many of the others, he's at least a solid warrior.

And there's Eeth Koth, too, not exactly sure where he'd go.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
And I don't believe for a second that Kenobi would fair better against Grievous than Mace or Yoda. Just their TK alone would crush him.

Mace fought hindered Grievous and couldn't win so he had to BFR him. Kenobi beat Grievous when the later actually knew he was coming and wasn't hindered.

Legends list would go something like:

Rots

Yoda.
Mace.
Anakin.
Obi-Wan.
Shaak Ti.
KI-Adi.
Plo Koon.
Kit Fisto.
Saesee.
Agen.
Stass Allie
Coleman Kcaj

Canon lists would go something like.

Yoda
Mace
Anakin
Obi-Wan
Kit?

Everything gets hazy with new canon people tbh not even gonna continue

1. Yoda
2. Mace
3. Yaddle
4. Kenobi
5. Anakin
6. Plo Koon
7. Shaak-Ti
8. Depa Billaba
8. Kit Fisto
9. Agen Kolar
10. Eeth Koth
11. Saesee Tiin
12. Ki-Adi-Mundi
13. Even Piell
14. Adi Gallia

1. Anakin
2. Yoda
3. Mace
4. Obi-Wan
5. Plo Koon
6. Kit Fisto
7. Eeth Koth
8. Agen Kolar
9. Saesee Tinn
Etc.

1-Yoda
2-Anakin
3-Mace
4-Kenobi
5-Yaddle
6-Kit Fisto
7-Eeth Koth
8-Depa Bilaba
9-Adi Gallia
10-Plo Koon
11-Ki Adi Mundi
12-Saeese Tiin
13-Agen Kolar
14-Shaak Ti
15- Coleman Kcaj

First 4 are pretty self explanatory. Maybe someone could argue Mace>Anakin, but i prefer Anakin to Mace due to his very convincing win over Dooku. Councilors between 5 and 9 all got pretty solid feats against powerful enemies. I put Yaddle behind Kenobi due to her good performance against Dooku, whom i already consider superior to the likes of Grevious or Savage by TPM. Eeth Koth, Kit Fisto and Depa did well against Grevious, and Adi Gallia held her own against Savage, so I place them behind Yaddle. Rest are literally featless in canon, unfortunately