Superman VS Green Lantern Hal Jordan

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



ghostman
Post Crisis for round 1

new 52 for round 2

carver9
Superman stomps

ghostman
Originally posted by carver9
Superman stomps

srs carver.

carver9
No Lantern is beating Superman unless they have some type of amp.

Surtur
I suppose this comes down to just how tough one thinks the autoshields on a GL ring are. I personally do not think they could stand up to a blitz from Superman.

Prof. T.C McAbe
If Hal starts with shields up and is in his Kronabusting mood (Abstract killer mode) he takes some wins. Both at their best are pretty close.

DCnU Hal loses, except the Gauntlet Hal, he would win.

Cogito
Standard GL Ring - Superman takes both 10/10

ghostman
jesus christ guys, has the green lantern vs superman been this one sided? how have they faired in the comics? im sure its not been this one sided in the comics. has lantern ever taken a clean win against supes? are bricks really a lanterns kryptonite?

ShadowFyre
Its DC..what do you mean? Literally every single comic revolves around Superman or a clone of Superman being stronger than everybody else.. A lantern isnt beating superman.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by carver9
Superman stomps

This.

Surtur
Originally posted by ghostman
jesus christ guys, has the green lantern vs superman been this one sided? how have they faired in the comics? im sure its not been this one sided in the comics. has lantern ever taken a clean win against supes? are bricks really a lanterns kryptonite?

Come on dude, that's not what is being said. Superman isn't merely a brick, he's a brick who can blitz you at incredibly high speedst. If Superman is going all out he can blitz a GL before they can amp their shields. They have autoshields yes, but I do not think they are strong enough. Against a normal brick they'd have time to amp their shields. Superman, when he does fight GL's, tends not to be going all out. A GL can f*ck Superman up if he just stands there and takes it.

My memory is fuzzy, but there have been times when Superman has required protection from a GL. Like I think John Stewart helped shield him from a bunch of anti matter bombs. But again, that requires some thought into it. With enough time a GL could absolutely do a lot of damage. We saw Kyle contain Ultraman and others on the moon, right?

TethAdamTheRock
Originally posted by Surtur
I suppose this comes down to just how tough one thinks the autoshields on a GL ring are. I personally do not think they could stand up to a blitz from Superman. If Black Adam can bash through green lantern constructs the way he did then surley can superman

Superman>Black Adam>Green Lantern

Surtur
He broke out of Alan Scott's constructs right? Yeah..but I think a GL who puts some effort in and has time to plan could at least contain Superman. It won't be easy, but I think it can be done. At least..a GL with a strong enough will.

TethAdamTheRock
I wonder how accurate this is to DCnU

http://youtu.be/DiPocnEiS6Q
http://youtu.be/DiPocnEiS6Q

Stoic
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
I wonder how accurate this is to DCnU

http://youtu.be/DiPocnEiS6Q
http://youtu.be/DiPocnEiS6Q


Pretty accurate on average I'd say.

Rao Kal El
Supes

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
If Black Adam can bash through green lantern constructs the way he did then surley can superman

Superman>Black Adam>Green Lantern

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11/111336/3804295-4721338810-alan2.jpg

TethAdamTheRock
Those weren't really constructs though, and he wasn't trying to break through them

TethAdamTheRock
Originally posted by Stoic
Pretty accurate on average I'd say. So a Sundipped Superman>Black Adam>Green Lantern>Wonder Woman>Flash

TethAdamTheRock
and Black Adams Shazam can one shot all the latter

cdtm
Originally posted by ghostman
Post Crisis for round 1

new 52 for round 2

Been done. Concensus says Hal wins 10/10.

cdtm
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11/111336/3804295-4721338810-alan2.jpg

Alan Scott's mace ftw.

Funny how he wasn't doing jack all, until he put a construct in Carter's hands.

abhilegend
Originally posted by cdtm
Been done. Concensus says Hal wins 10/10.
Must be some imaginary consensus.

BruceSkywalker
Supes stomps

Adam Grimes
Originally posted by cdtm
Been done. Concensus says Hal wins 10/10. Kal*

EcstaticGrace
Only round I can see Hal taking is one if he does stuff like create Kryptonite. Pre-Flashpoint I could see Hal taking it though without it as well.

Round 2 is Superman. New52 Hal isn't that impressive at least compared to Superman I mean unless it's Renegade ofcourse

jrodslam
Hal should win a majority. Writers wont allow it. Even split.

abhilegend
Originally posted by jrodslam
Hal should win a majority. Writers wont allow it. Even split.
Why should he win a majority?

Mindset
Originally posted by carver9
No Lantern is beating Superman unless they have some type of amp. Kyle kills any Superman.

cdtm
Originally posted by Mindset
Kyle kills any Superman.

That'a what the concensus says.

EcstaticGrace
Originally posted by Mindset
Kyle kills any Superman.

You mean ION and White Lantern Versions which are amps? Or typical GL Kyle.

Surtur
Ion Kyle would easily own Superman. I think in a fight if Superman blitzed right away before they could do anything he could beat almost any GL. Obviously there are those weird GL's that don't actually have physical bodies that would be problematic for someone like Superman.

cdtm
Originally posted by EcstaticGrace
You mean ION and White Lantern Versions which are amps? Or typical GL Kyle.

He means Kyle.

With or without a ring, Ion, or White Lantern.

EcstaticGrace
Originally posted by cdtm
He means Kyle.

With or without a ring, Ion, or White Lantern.

I dont think Kyle with a GL ring cuts it against Superman

Ion and White Lantern would destroy Superman.

Without a ring maybe Superman would pity Kyle and stomp just a little bit

Mindset
Originally posted by cdtm
He means Kyle.

With or without a ring, Ion, or White Lantern. thumb up

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.