Vibranium vs Adamantium

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



ozz81
1.Which is more: indestructible, stronger , and durable?

Mindset
Adamantium.

riv6672
Adamantium.

Digi
Vibranium has more varied uses. But yes, to your OP, adamantium takes it.

riv6672
Fairly straightforward.
There can be no controversy here.

Genii96
Don't be so sure

Flyattractor
Isn't Vibe bout the only thing that can cut thru adman?

HulkIsHulk
Adamantium is tougher

Originally posted by Flyattractor
Isn't Vibe bout the only thing that can cut thru adman?
No. What you're talking about is Antarctic Vibranium which emits waves which breaks down and liquefies all metals including adamantium on the molecular level by simply being around it. imilar attacks on the moelcular level has wrecked adamantium. Otherwise neither metal can cut through the other. And Vibranium has been broken way more than adamantium

Inedian
Captain America shield is vibranium-adamantium and Wolverine bones adamantium, right? Wolverine bones are actually tougher than Cap shield?

DarkSaint85
Yup.

riv6672
Originally posted by Genii96
Don't be so sure

What? Gen, how can you possibly...

Originally posted by Inedian
Captain America shield is vibranium-adamantium and Wolverine bones adamantium, right? Wolverine bones are actually tougher than Cap shield?

...i stand corrected! stick out tongue

And no, Wolvie's bones (claws) arent tougher than Cap's shield.
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-4_9UJZRtjGY/UOBADCAkNuI/AAAAAAAADnI/FeTXZTKrFDs/s1600/Hero-Envy-Wolverine-vs-Captain-America.jpg
Whether the shield is proto adamantium or adamantium/vibranium mix this week, its always been the tougher.

Sin I AM
Originally posted by Inedian
Captain America shield is vibranium-adamantium and Wolverine bones adamantium, right? Wolverine bones are actually tougher than Cap shield?

Caps shield is vibranium, an iron/steel alloy and some third unknown accidental catslyst. That's why it cant be replicated. Originally it was proto-adamantium. The proto prefix indicating it was a prototype. But Marvel retconned that. True adamantium can be replicated but is supposedly extremely expensive....then u have beta adamantium which is what logan has ( adamantium molecularly bonded with bones..them secondary, uru...vibranium, carbonadium etc....the strongest alloy Iirc is adamantine. Basically adamantium thats been blessed by the gods.

Inedian
Originally posted by Sin I AM
Caps shield is vibranium, an iron/steel alloy and some third unknown accidental catslyst. That's why it cant be replicated. Originally it was proto-adamantium. The proto prefix indicating it was a prototype. But Marvel retconned that. True adamantium can be replicated but is supposedly extremely expensive....then u have beta adamantium which is what logan has ( adamantium molecularly bonded with bones..them secondary, uru...vibranium, carbonadium etc....the strongest alloy Iirc is adamantine. Basically adamantium thats been blessed by the gods.

So then Cap shield is touger than Logan bones.

riv6672
Originally posted by Sin I AM
....the strongest alloy Iirc is adamantine. Basically adamantium thats been blessed by the gods.
http://static8.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/0/7666/1133481-iherc138_0007.jpg

riv6672
Originally posted by Inedian
So then Cap shield is touger than Logan bones.
Then. Now. Always.

Sin I AM
Originally posted by Inedian
So then Cap shield is touger than Logan bones.

No. If say (insert really strong guy) tried to rip Logan in half it wouldn't happen. Because as of yet his bones cant be broken whereas Caps shield has been broken several times albeit by skys and above. Vibranium isnt really that durable. Its mystical and absorbing properties are what makes it valuable. You can punch it all you like to no avail but u can rip/break it.

Inedian
Originally posted by Sin I AM
No. If say (insert really strong guy) tried to rip Logan in half it wouldn't happen. Because as of yet his bones cant be broken whereas Caps shield has been broken several times albeit by skys and above. Vibranium isnt really that durable. Its mystical and absorbing properties are what makes it valuable. You can punch it all you like to no avail but u can rip/break it.

Ok, thanks.

riv6672
Originally posted by Sin I AM
No. If say (insert really strong guy) tried to rip Logan in half it wouldn't happen. Because as of yet his bones cant be broken whereas Caps shield has been broken several times albeit by skys and above. Vibranium isnt really that durable. Its mystical and absorbing properties are what makes it valuable. You can punch it all you like to no avail but u can rip/break it.
Interesting theory.
Though we've seen Logan ripped in half (Ultimates U) and have his hand cut off (AoA) those were instances of the skeletal support structures being compromised.
Pretty sure a Sky would be able to break bones as well as shield though. Thats last is just my theory.

Stoic
Originally posted by Inedian
Captain America shield is vibranium-adamantium and Wolverine bones adamantium, right? Wolverine bones are actually tougher than Cap shield?

Not any longer. Caps Shield may be tougher due to being fused with Uru and I suppose enchanted by Odin when he fixed it after the Serpent broke it.

Sin I AM
Originally posted by riv6672
Interesting theory.
Though we've seen Logan ripped in half (Ultimates U) and have his hand cut off (AoA) those were instances of the skeletal support structures being compromised.
Pretty sure a Sky would be able to break bones as well as shield though. Thats last is just my theory.

AoA and Ultimate versions arent as durable or something i cant remember.

Originally posted by Stoic
Not any longer. Caps Shield may be tougher due to being fused with Uru and I suppose enchanted by Odin when he fixed it after the Serpent broke it.

I forgot about the uru...was it stated it was blessed?

riv6672
Originally posted by Stoic
Not any longer. Caps Shield may be tougher due to being fused with Uru and I suppose enchanted by Odin when he fixed it after the Serpent broke it.
Is this what you meant?
http://static3.comicvine.com/uploads/square_small/3/39027/3422142-fear-itself-7-037.jpg
Wow.

riv6672
Originally posted by Sin I AM
AoA and Ultimate versions arent as durable or something i cant remember.

Ah, okay thank you!
I wasnt going to bring it (and AoA) up, as i wasnt sure of canon, but since this seems to be more of a general information thread figured i'd throw it out there.
Again thanks.

Not sure about the blessing you asked about. Hopefully Stoic fills us in.

TethAdamTheRock
1. Adamantine (Adamantium replicated by Olympion Gods)
2. Adamantium/Juggernaut
3. Caps Shield (Adamantium, Uru, Vibranium Mixture)
4. Vibranium/Uru
5. Thors Hammer
6. Osmium (Colossus)

riv6672
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
2. Adamantium/Juggernaut

6. Osmium (Colossus)
What the what? huh

TethAdamTheRock
Originally posted by riv6672
What the what? huh Juggernaut is as Durable as Adamantium

Osmium is the most durable metal in the known universe after the above(i got it from marvel website)

StiltmanFTW
Adamantium, easily.

DarkOdin
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
1. Adamantine (Adamantium replicated by Olympion Gods)
2. Adamantium/Juggernaut
3. Caps Shield (Adamantium, Uru, Vibranium Mixture)
4. Vibranium/Uru
5. Thors Hammer
6. Osmium (Colossus)

Your list is way out of order,

1. Whatever the destroyer is made of it is the most durable

2. Adamantine/ uru it is draw uru usually is stronger then adamantine because it is blessed mjolnir is stronger then blessed uru because it is backed by the odinpower

3. Caps shield/ vibranium broken only by skyfather and above

4. Admantium weakest person to harm it was Jane Thor and has been slagged by odinpower

Sin I AM
Originally posted by DarkOdin
Your list is way out of order,

1. Whatever the destroyer is made of it is the most durable

2. Adamantine/ uru it is draw uru usually is stronger then adamantine because it is blessed mjolnir is stronger then blessed uru because it is backed by the odinpower

3. Caps shield/ vibranium broken only by skyfather and above

4. Admantium weakest person to harm it was Jane Thor and has been slagged by odinpower

Has it been stated what the destroyer is made of? It durability and power comes from the 3 sky fathers who empowered it. Not the nature of its metal.

What are you gettin this info from?

True

Not all adamantly is the same

Surtur
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
Adamantium is tougher


No. What you're talking about is Antarctic Vibranium which emits waves which breaks down and liquefies all metals including adamantium on the molecular level by simply being around it. imilar attacks on the moelcular level has wrecked adamantium. Otherwise neither metal can cut through the other. And Vibranium has been broken way more than adamantium

Lol@ "antarctic vibranium" being a thing. I wonder how it compares to "Louisiana Bayou vibranium" and things of that nature.

HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by Surtur
Lol@ "antarctic vibranium" being a thing. I wonder how it compares to "Louisiana Bayou vibranium" and things of that nature.
It's also called anti-metal too. The reason its called Antarctic Vibranium because its biggest source is in Antarctica, while the vibration absorbing vibranium is called Wakandan Vibraium because its biggest source is Wakanda. Atleast it used to be

DarkOdin
Originally posted by Sin I AM
Has it been stated what the destroyer is made of? It durability and power comes from the 3 sky fathers who empowered it. Not the nature of its metal.

What are you gettin this info from?

True

Not all adamantly is the same

Happy Dance Not sure what destroyer is made of it has torn mjolnir pretty easily heck the only thing to damage destroyer was the fourth host, and the door Jane Thor open was stated to be primary admantium if I remember correctly

Magnon
Adamantium is a mixture/alloy whose properties depend on the exact ratios of its constituents and also on the preparation conditions (temperature, pressure, mixing speed, additives, catalysts etc.). Thus, no batch of adamantium is exactly the same. It is easier to prepare the lower grades (secondary adamantium), and this process is also more commonly known, but the resulting durability is inferior to that of the primary grades of adamantium. In fact, Captain America's shield is, in a sense, also a particular type of adamantium since the "primary" adamantium was just a failed attempt to reproduce the metal alloy in the shield. It is unknown whether under some spectacular preparation conditions one could prepare an adamantium alloy even better than its primary and "shield" qualities.

cdtm
Adamantium is stronger.

Not nearly as useful, though.

Nth metal beats them both applications wise. smile

Astner
Vibranium isn't renowned for its durability, but rather its ability to absorb and redirect energy. If Captain America's shield would've been solid adamantium then he would've been slammed across town every time his shield connected with a super powered-impact.

Surtur
Originally posted by Astner
Vibranium isn't renowned for its durability, but rather its ability to absorb and redirect energy. If Captain America's shield would've been solid adamantium then he would've been slammed across town every time his shield connected with a super-powered impact.

Lol it just reminds me of the scene from "Wolverine Origins" where he blocks Deadpools optic blast with his claws and isn't even really pushed back by it.

HulkIsHulk
Originally posted by Surtur
Lol it just reminds me of the scene from "Wolverine Origins" where he blocks Deadpools optic blast with his claws and isn't even really pushed back by it.
He is shown being pushed back
https://youtu.be/tzNx-QmRihM?t=186
Things like that happen. Heck, even in the comics, I've seen Cap block punches from the Destroyer armor with his original steel shield who in the same comics, and the armor in the same comic was shaking up the city with its punches. And She-Hulk struggled to block an attack from this huge extra-dimensional demon with the vibranium alloy shield, and a civilian who protected cap from a supervillains with that shield died. Cap fanboys love using those showings to say Cap is that tough

Magnificent M
Isn't The Destroyer infused with power from all the Skyfathers in the council of Godheads, not just Odin/Zeus/Vishnu?
And Adamantine is a separate metal from Adamantium if memory serves me right. -ium is named after it, though.

Surtur
Originally posted by HulkIsHulk
He is shown being pushed back
https://youtu.be/tzNx-QmRihM?t=186
Things like that happen. Heck, even in the comics, I've seen Cap block punches from the Destroyer armor with his original steel shield who in the same comics, and the armor in the same comic was shaking up the city with its punches. And She-Hulk struggled to block an attack from this huge extra-dimensional demon with the vibranium alloy shield, and a civilian who protected cap from a supervillains with that shield died. Cap fanboys love using those showings to say Cap is that tough

He got pushed back a bit, but he should of been flung off the ledge. I mean he literally only gets pushed back a few inches.

cdtm
Originally posted by Magnificent M
Isn't The Destroyer infused with power from all the Skyfathers in the council of Godheads, not just Odin/Zeus/Vishnu?
And Adamantine is a separate metal from Adamantium if memory serves me right. -ium is named after it, though.

That's right, Adamantine is what Herc's mace is made of. Basically an indestructible god metal version of adamantium.

Which I guess would make Uru more like nth metal, since both channel magic.

Surtur
You guys remember when Thor bashed on some adamantium and there was no damage and then Thor claimed there was a miniscule amount of damage? Oh Thor..

DarkOdin
Originally posted by Sin I AM
AoA and Ultimate versions arent as durable or something i cant remember.



I forgot about the uru...was it stated it was blessed?

Yes, it was enchanted at least not sure if by Odin or not check the scan on the previous page.

Sin I AM
Ok. If it is it hasn't been referenced since

leonidas
adamantium is obviously stronger than vibranium, and yes, cap's shield is stronger than primary adamantium.

cdtm
Originally posted by leonidas
adamantium is obviously stronger than vibranium, and yes, cap's shield is stronger than primary adamantium.

Never understood this argument.

To my knowledge, neither's ever been broken through physical force. Cap's shield is usually damaged through magic/matter manipulation, and those times Adamantium's been damaged has been retconned as secondary..

Can't call one more unbreakable if they "both" have a perfect record.

leonidas
i outlined why in this thread, though some scans are broken now... sad

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=556194&pagenumber=14

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by cdtm
Can't call one more unbreakable if they "both" have a perfect record.

Cap's shield has the advantage of vibranium absorbing the impact and who knows, probably that uru metal (after FI) gives it some magical resistance...?

But yeah, against purely physical force, they should be equal.

Sin I AM
Caps shield isnt vibranium though so it shouldn't be lumped in

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Sin I AM
Caps shield isnt vibranium though so it shouldn't be lumped in

It has vibranium as one of its main components.

Sin I AM

StiltmanFTW
Correct.

But we all knew that already. You're not posting on some FB fandom group uhuh

Sin I AM
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Correct.

But we all knew that already. You're not posting on some FB fandom group uhuh

I wasnt talking to you initially stilt so not understanding your damage chummmmmmmmmm












P 😉

riv6672
Originally posted by TethAdamTheRock
Juggernaut is as Durable as Adamantium

Osmium is the most durable metal in the known universe after the above(i got it from marvel website)
Ah!
You threw me off for a bit. I get it now, thanks.

riv6672
Originally posted by leonidas
adamantium is obviously stronger than vibranium, and yes, cap's shield is stronger than primary adamantium.
Thats really the important part, vibranium/proto/uru all seem to switch importance depending in the retcon. Line starts at Cap's shield.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by riv6672
Ah!
You threw me off for a bit. I get it now, thanks.

Osmium is the metal that exists in RL.

Colossus Big C means either omnium or - more likely - the metal Colossus' skin is made out of, which only resembles osmium.

Sin I AM
What's dianas bracers made of? I cant recall them ever being broken

StiltmanFTW
Uknown metal. Probably what most of Amazonian frying pans are made out of.

Sin I AM
Fight me irl

Mindset
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Uknown metal. Probably what most of Amazonian frying pans are made out of. Originally posted by Sin I AM
Fight me irl laughing out loud

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by Sin I AM
Fight me irl

Oh, I'd "fight" you all right.

http://s32.postimg.org/qz31mqbth/mww1.png

Mindset
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Oh, I'd "fight" you all right.

http://s32.postimg.org/qz31mqbth/mww1.png I'm liking where this is going.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Oh, I'd "fight" you all right.

http://s32.postimg.org/qz31mqbth/mww1.png

Why do you have my yearbook photo?

StiltmanFTW
laughing

Sin I AM
I hate u all

StiltmanFTW
Hate sex is the best, sugar **** thumb up

cdtm
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Uknown metal. Probably what most of Amazonian frying pans are made out of.

Pretty sure they're pieces of the Aegis shield.

StiltmanFTW
Aegis stock pot? Yeah, very likely.

KingD19
It did take Superman a while to get back in that room. And Diana was exhausted by then.

riv6672
laughing

riv6672
Originally posted by riv6672
Thats really the important part, vibranium/proto/uru all seem to switch importance depending in the retcon. Line starts at Cap's shield.
This post is all sorts of messed up.
What i meant is, no matter what the shield happens to be made of at any given time, it is the most indestructible (but one of a kind) material.

Surtur
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Oh, I'd "fight" you all right.

http://s32.postimg.org/qz31mqbth/mww1.png

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11118/111184648/4030444-0126741458-super.jpg

http://static9.comicvine.com/uploads/scale_super/11114/111148187/3783133-1474105423-35489.jpg

https://dreager1.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/677680-anti_superman_super.jpg

B*tches, amirite?

DarkSaint85
.....too far, mate. Too far.

:sad:

Surtur
You say it's too far, but I say it's just a good reminder as to what happens if you're late with Supermans dinner.

StiltmanFTW
C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER!

Believe me, it's Superman making dinners and keeping them warm.

http://s27.postimg.org/mhjqijwhe/image.jpg

Canon. Hopefully Snyder will include that scene in Justice League movie stick out tongue

Surtur
I don't know, I think Wonder Woman is directly responsible for why Lois Lane has never had a black eye due to "accidentally" tripping and falling and hitting her face on a doorknob.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.