Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

As the title says.

Which has the better duels, and overall fights.

I think Dooku vs Grievous is one of the most visually appealing fights in the mythos.

Besides the Palp vs Maul/Opress fight, OCW by far.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Besides the Palp vs Maul/Opress fight, OCW by far. Agreed.

Ant's on the money.

OCW, yeah.

OCW is how TCW should've stayed. Everyone in TCW was so underpowered and I feel like OCW truly shows how skilful Kenobi, Grievous, Windu and co really are.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Besides the Palp vs Maul/Opress fight, OCW by far.
I like you every day more.

Palps vs Bloodlusted Maul = Best fight in SW. I don't care if Sheev was holding back, I get goosebumps when I see that darksaber

Stylistically I can see why one might make a case for OCW, however TCW's added third dimension gives them literally more depth for me. Layer that on top of score, voice acting, emotional resonance, animation quality and backdrop, and TCW wins handedly.

Those things only excel in a small fraction of TCW fights. Most of them are pretty terrible, lol. On average, OCW is easily better.

Alone the Grievous fights, and Ventress vs Anakin are in OCW so much better than in TCW.

OCW doesn't also have a habit of ruining characters with their depictions in battle. Another point in its favor.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Those things only excel in a small fraction of TCW fights. Most of them are pretty terrible, lol. On average, OCW is easily better. I disagree, from Season 3 onwards the quality was consistent. And even the earlier duels beat OCW in terms quality of animation. Regardless, the question is which has the better duels, and it's TCW.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
I disagree, from Season 3 onwards the quality was consistent. And even the earlier duels beat OCW in terms quality of animation. Regardless, the question is which has the better duels, and it's TCW.

I'm pretty sure he means which is better on average. The OCW ones are generally more memorable. But it's up to each person.

Originally posted by SunRazer
OCW doesn't also have a habit of ruining characters with their depictions in battle. Another point in its favor.

watch?v=qMODZBD3Bic

watch?v=Xy_Po12VyZw

watch?v=WhYSP5XqFUE

watch?v=HbBKHB1Sffg

Yeah, I think OCW wins by miles.

And this is one of my favorite scenes from the mythos:

watch?v=Muvxl-ZS3bU

Originally posted by Jmanghan
watch?v=qMODZBD3Bic

watch?v=Xy_Po12VyZw

watch?v=WhYSP5XqFUE

watch?v=HbBKHB1Sffg

Yeah, I think OCW wins by miles. watch?v=yyiDDQYPUIs

watch?v=IqEtXVh8UOo

watch?v=DOZ4SpuOmH4

watch?v=eQATBFIZ13o

watch?v=nE1Cv7lM0YA

watch?v=OcXaicGvcvA

watch?v=ctN5s8z3E8E

watch?v=-7hBZNsPnyg

Hardly. hmph

OCW. No contest. Anakin vs Ventress is probably the best duel not in the films.

Out of interest, I'd like to see why people think the OCW duels are so great.

TCW.

Sidious/Maul/Opress is bae.

But even that aside, they had tons of exquisitely crafted and animated battles.

Yeah even the Maul vs Vizsla in the prior episode was great.

The Maul/Opress vs Obi-Wan/Ventress was fantastic.

Technically, TCW, no constest. More similar to the movies etc.

Anyway, it's hard to accept, that we have to see Anakin vs Dooku and Ventress and Obi-Wan vs Grievous, Ventress and Maul all the time.

There was a lot of potential in TCW, that they lost:
- Mace vs Dooku
- Mace vs Grievous
- Mace vs Maul
- Dooku vs Maul
- Anakin vs Maul
- Maul vs Grievous
- Minor Jedi like Kit or Agen or Shaak vs either Ventress, Grievous, Opress, Maul, Dooku... according to how great Fisto's and Grievous' duel was.
Perhaps some sparring matches between Mace, Anakin, Obi-Wan or Yoda.

Atmosphere.

I feel like OCW fightss have more weight to them.

Some of the scenes in OCW were ****ing incredible, like straight up masterpieces as far as cartoons go in general, or even TV.

Asajj Ventress vs Anakin was a fight that, tbh, hasn't been matched to this day.

Originally posted by The_Tempest

Sidious/Maul/Opress is bae.

Hmmm.

ps. Kenobi did it better.
yep

Originally posted by ares834
Anakin vs Ventress is probably the best duel not in the films.