Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Let me know who your top 5 are. Mine are:
1. Sidious
2.Yoda
3. Darth Vader
4 Mace Windu
5. Anakin
Count Dooku is a close 6

Originally posted by Rebel95
Let me know who your top 5 are. Mine are:
6. Count Dooku
Seems legit

If Mace legitimately went toe-to-toe with Sidious, then I don't think Vader being above him is justified.

Otherwise, your ranking is probably right.

I'm a believer that Sidious allowed him to win to manipulate Anakin, also Mace had a huge amp

If the RotS novel isn't canon, then I don't think there's a source for his amp. Whether or not Sidious played the fight is indeed up for discussion, though. And I am in favor of that, so I guess Mace's showing there doesn't really put him above the names you mentioned.

If so, however, what exactly puts Mace above the next few names? Reaching an impasse with Talzin and briefly clashing blades with Maul is hardly above Anakin and Dooku.

Talzin is likely up there as well.

In no particular order.

Sidious.
Yoda.
Talzin.
Vader.
Windu.

If we're discounting Mace's fight against Sidious, what does he have?

Doesn't he have a canon accolade of being the best battlefield warrior in the Order? Or something like that.

If that refers to/includes RotS, then it's excellent.

IIRC, a quote(s) also states that Yoda's better, though.