Do you agree, disagree, or partially agree with these statements?

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

7.) Dooku's scrotum hangs lower than his penis

8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

Ziggystardust
Originally posted by Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

7.) Dooku's scrotum hangs lower than his penis

8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

1) partially agree
2) agree
3) partially agree
4) disagree
5) don't know <-- this should be an option
6) disagree
7) disagree
8) don't know
9) Anyone can defeat Maul in their prime
10) Disagree

TenebrousWay

JKBart
Originally posted by Ziggystardust
1) partially agree
2) agree
3) partially agree
4) disagree
5) don't know <-- this should be an option
6) disagree
7) disagree
8) don't know
9) Anyone can defeat Maul in their prime
10) Disagree

chilled monkey
Originally posted by Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

7.) Dooku's scrotum hangs lower than his penis

8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

1) Disagree.

2) Don't care about so-called "canon."

3) Partially agree.

4) Agree.

5) Disagree.

6) Strongly disagree.

7) Not sure.

8) Partially agree. Dooku had serious character flaws but had things been different I think he could have stayed a Jedi.

9) Disagree. Qui-Gon's loss was mainly due to his tactical inclinations, not his physicality.

10) Disagree.

UCanShootMyNova
Originally posted by Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

7.) Dooku's scrotum hangs lower than his penis

8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

Disagree.

No idea.

Disagree.

Agree.

Agree.

Disagree.

Wut.

Partially agree.

Disagree.

Interesting theory.

MythLord
Originally posted by Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

Disagree.

Originally posted by Kurk
2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

Agree.

Originally posted by Kurk
3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

Disagree

Originally posted by Kurk
4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

Agree(Fact File confirms this).

Originally posted by Kurk
5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

Prolly agree.

Originally posted by Kurk
6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

Disagree. Anakin in-general just seems emotionally unbalanced a lot of the time. Sids could just exploit him being an orphan.

Originally posted by Kurk
8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

Probably agree.

Originally posted by Kurk
9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

Disagree.

Originally posted by Kurk
10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

It's possible, but it's never alluded to so... mmm

Ursumeles
What Myth said.

relentless1
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

Doubtful, he'd last longer than most but Mace wins 10/10

2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

No. Vader is stronger than Anakin was and that was Dookus greatest weakness stylistically.

3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

Lol. Hell no, anyone that believes that Sidious didn't take that dive in order to turn Anakin didn't watch the film close enough.

4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

Umm yeah, he basically said as much to Dooku when he ordered the hit.

5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

No. The Force created Anakin as a reaction to the Sith meddling.

6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

He still would have, his late training and arrogance and schism with the Jedi Order would have probably been enough.

7.) Dooku's scrotum hangs lower than his penis

Thats usually the case with Octogenarians

8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

Definitely possible although he'd probably still leave the order, Qui Goes death as simply the straw that broke the camels back.

9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

Doubtful, Mauls a beast in saber combat.

10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

Interesting theory and way better than she lost the will to live but theres no proof of it unfortunately.

Beniboybling
Originally posted by MythLord
Agree(Fact File confirms this). Quote?

MythLord
Originally posted by Beniboybling
Quote?

"Sidious knew that, should Asajj become any more powerful, the combined might of Dooku and Ventress could overthrow him."

-- Star Wars Fact File Relaunched #67

cs_zoltan
Gay af

Ursumeles
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Gay af
You don't even try to hide your homosexuality. I am proud of you.

Beniboybling
Originally posted by MythLord
"Sidious knew that, should Asajj become any more powerful, the combined might of Dooku and Ventress could overthrow him."

-- Star Wars Fact File Relaunched #67 Gross yeah.

Kurk
Originally posted by MythLord
"Sidious knew that, should Asajj become any more powerful, the combined might of Dooku and Ventress could overthrow him."

-- Star Wars Fact File Relaunched #67 ah hell yeah! Suck it Sidious wankers.

MythLord
Originally posted by Kurk
ah hell yeah! Suck it Sidious wankers.

More like: Suck it Dooku lowballers. smile smile smile

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Gross yeah.

I mean, Sidious is a paranoid numbskull who thinks anyone and everything can be threat to his power. mmm

relentless1
key word there is could, Sidious wasnt one for taking chances; that quote doesnt mean they could actually beat him...

Petrus
Originally posted by Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

2.) Canon Vader would lose to composite Dooku in pure sabers

3.) Mace Windu legitimately defeated Sidious in saber combat without the latter holding back

4.) Sidious ordered Ventress killed in TCW at the fear of Dooku and his apprentice rivaling him someday.

5.) Sidious and Plagueis created Anakin via midichlorian manipulation

6.) Anakin would not have fell victim to Sidious had he never met Padme or another love.

7.) Dooku's scrotum hangs lower than his penis

8.) Dooku would not have turned to the dark-side had Qui-Gon lived or had the jedi taken serious action after to find the sith master.

9.) Qui-Gon Jinn in his physical prime could have defeated TPM Maul

10.) Sidious gave Mustafar Vader life by taking it from Padme

1. Disagree.

2. Disagree.

3. Partially agree.

4. Partially agree.

5. Agree.

6. Partially agree.

7. Agree.

8. Agree.

9. Disagree.

10. Disagree.

MythLord
Originally posted by relentless1
key word there is could, Sidious wasnt one for taking chances; that quote doesnt mean they could actually beat him...

Never said it did; I'm just noting Sidious legitimately believed they might've posed a threat and overthrown him.

Petrus
Originally posted by MythLord
More like: Suck it Dooku lowballers. smile smile smile

thumb up

Yeah, and Vader lowballers, as well. Those who say Sidious could take on 2 or even 3 Vaders/Vader level opponents at the same time, there you go.

Beniboybling
Nah, Sids already proved his worth against Maul & Savage. Any version of Dooku and Ventress would get raped by him. smile

Not that any of this consists of Dooku or Vader lowballing kek.

Petrus
Let's consider Sidious was assuming Ventress would reach her full potential or at least close to it. She clearly never does, so it's moot.

2 Vaders >> Savage and Maul, tho.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by MythLord
"Sidious knew that, should Asajj become any more powerful, the combined might of Dooku and Ventress could overthrow him."

-- Star Wars Fact File Relaunched #67



Legends source then.


In any case, the potential threat is the only reason we know of for him ordering Dooku to assassinate Ventress.

TenebrousWay
Overthrowing Sidious doesn't exactly mean Dooku and Ventress are just going to storm the chancellerry by their own and defeat him in a duel.

Darth Thor
Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Overthrowing Sidious doesn't exactly mean Dooku and Ventress are just going to storm the chancellerry by their own and defeat him in a duel.



Good point. But that's usually how people take the whole "overthrowing" thing to go down.

Azronger
Originally posted by Kurk
1.) RotS Obi-Wan Kenobi could take a slight majority against Mace Windu in pure saber combat due to stylistic advantage.

Disagree



Partially agree



Partially agree



Agree



Disagree



Don't know



Disagree



Disagree



Agree



Partially agree

Beniboybling
Should have mentioned that I disagree with all the statements here. uhuh

cs_zoltan
Even 7?

Kurk
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Even 7? After googling this "issue" it appears that many older men don't see a difference between when they were younger and how it hangs now. It seems to be more dependent on whether or not you wear supportive underwear which I'm sure Dooku does being an aristocrat and all wink

Beniboybling
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Even 7? Apart from seven. smile

Originally posted by Kurk
After googling this "issue" it appears that many older men don't see a difference between when they were younger and how it hangs now. It seems to be more dependent on whether or not you wear supportive underwear which I'm sure Dooku does being an aristocrat and all wink Pls don't google those things.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.