Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Luke Skywalker

https://criticalviewblog.files.wordpress.com/2015/12/luke-rotj.png

VERSUS

Spider-Man

https://i.annihil.us/u/prod/marvel/i/mg/6/60/538cd3628a05e.jpg

If luke can get ahold of spidey before getting webbed he wins

Mostly dependent on *which* version/era of Luke we're dealing with here.

The OP pic is RotJ Luke. If that is indeed the version being used here, Spidey likely wins. If this were, say, Luke a mere 3 months after the battle of Endor(as we saw him during Marvel's recent 'Shattered Empire' mini), his chances are *much* better.

What galan said. Also, is this legends or canon Luke?

Lol, I would hope to God this is canon Luke... Legends Luke is without a doubt *the* most haxx character in the mythos.

Yeah, Legends Luke destroys Spidey. Non-Legends likely gets destroyed. Not much middle ground.

Force grip for the easy win.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Force grip for the easy win.

Sure, but again we haven't seen much from non-Legends Luke. Say it's the Luke that fought the Rancor (roughly, the one pictured in the OP). Spider-Man beats that Luke.

That Luke is perfectly capable of using Force grip.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
That Luke is perfectly capable of using Force grip.

Yeah, I don't disagree. It's just that the way he's portrayed makes me believe that Pete could get off like half a cartridge of webbing and multiple attacks before Luke does much. I'd concede that it could go either way.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Force grip for the easy win. Thing is: we don't know what type of range RotJ Luke had with his TK. His only feats in that department were done when the object/character he was grasping was a matter of a few feet away. If Spidey had to get that close before Luke tried clutching him with the Force, things probably wouldn't end well for Luke. /shrug

Any comic version of Luke that I've seen would beat Spidey's ass.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Any comic version of Luke that I've seen would beat Spidey's ass.

That would be Legends Luke. And yes, he would. This is "canon" Luke, though, which became pretty much entirely just the movies when Ep. VII came out (which made a lot of existing stuff non-canon). Galan might be able to help out if there are other canon materials outside the movies that weren't swept into the "Legends" category. I'm unaware of any for Luke atm.

This is CANON Luke.

Canon Luke shook a Star destroyer iirc while angered with the force

Pretty sure Peter loses his head here

yeah using movie luke it's hard to see him winning more than 1 or 2 here. doubly hard considering he is extremely unlikely to go for the kill against someone like spidey, which is pretty much what he would need to do in this to have any real chance.

Spiderman gets choked.

yeah that at-at feat was very solid.

Originally posted by carthage
Canon Luke shook a Star destroyer iirc while angered with the force

Pretty sure Peter loses his head here is this the one you're thinking of?
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=638137&pagenumber=1

Yeah like others have said, if this is legends luke then pete has no chance. If cannon luke then its alot closer, but id lean towards pete.

Originally posted by Digi
That would be Legends Luke. And yes, he would. This is "canon" Luke, though, which became pretty much entirely just the movies when Ep. VII came out (which made a lot of existing stuff non-canon). Galan might be able to help out if there are other canon materials outside the movies that weren't swept into the "Legends" category. I'm unaware of any for Luke atm. Mentioned this earlier, but Luke's feats in 'Shattered Empire' are canon as well... And they are quite impressive:
Originally posted by Galan007
Don't think I ever posted this here...


RotJ-era Luke was a LOT more powerful/skilled than most realize:
http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598509_6049126.jpg http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598514_6552877.jpg http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598516_7190225.jpg http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598520_1706614.jpg

http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598523_3437179.jpg http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598526_6101323.jpg http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598530_1285106.jpg http://s6d6.turboimg.net/t1/31598532_1980700.jpg


*This is set a mere 3 months after the battle of Endor/RotJ.

Judging by those scans Luke should win pretty handily, all he really has to do is avoid Spidey's webs. Up close Luke's Lightsaber and TK negate any strength edge Spidey might have, and their respective agility is probably pretty close to even.

Even with the webs, completely immobilising Luke.....does what exactly to his TK etc?

Probably nothing, maybe just disrupt his concentration momentarily.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Judging by those scans Luke should win pretty handily, all he really has to do is avoid Spidey's webs. Up close Luke's Lightsaber and TK negate any strength edge Spidey might have, and their respective agility is probably pretty close to even. Agility? Even?
Not in those scans.

Luke might win, but it won't be by keeping up physically with Spider-Man.

Not saying Spider-Man wins, not even saying he dodges Luke's TK but I could actually post a scan of Spider-Man dodging TK.

Like an internal TK attack?

Originally posted by Parmaniac
Not saying Spider-Man wins, not even saying he dodges Luke's TK but I could actually post a scan of Spider-Man dodging TK. Spidey *might* be able to dodge, say, a force-push sent his way, as that type of attack is just launched in a general direction. However, there is no real way to dodge a force-choke -- it is a FAR more precise application of the force/TK.

https://i.stack.imgur.com/SFIf7.gif
http://i.imgur.com/3CC9H8x.gif

Spiderman stomps.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Spiderman stomps. no he doesn't.

Azog sucks.

Lord of the rings sucks.

Thanos is dying.

Come at me.

Don't mind Quan. He just really hates Star Wars.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Don't mind Quan. He just really hates Star Wars. not sure why he does. It's currently a marvel property and is getting the biggest push that it's seen in decades.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
Not saying Spider-Man wins, not even saying he dodges Luke's TK but I could actually post a scan of Spider-Man dodging TK.
Please do. I'm curious.