DarthAnt66
In anticipation on The Last Jedi, I figured we should discuss and try to answer some of the core existing themes concerning the Force.
The foremost question I have is what exactly was the Chosen One prophecy? As per Lucas, the description was simplying "to destroy the Sith." How would cleansing just one-side of the Force bring it into balance though? It seems essential that both the Jedi and the Sith, the two extreme organizations of the Force, needed to be destroyed. If true, then how could Luke Skywalker live yet the prophecy be fulfilled? It would seem to me that, with the galaxy in the presence of no Sith and one Jedi, that the Force would be out-of-balance toward the light-side.
The second point of discussion is simplying on the various "sides" of the Force. The canon interpretation seems to be a spectrum, with the light on one end and the dark on the other. Some Force-users aim to be in the middle, however unless they have sufficient mastery, they generally stray toward either the dark or the light. Also, based on this perspective, the Jedi, the ultimate light-side faction, would be just as extreme and dangerous toward the balance of the Force as the Sith, again bringing into question how Luke could be alive yet the prophecy fufilled.
I've observed that Yoda and the Emperor have essentially the same extremist view of the Force. Both believe in the absolute giving of ones self toward their respective side of the Force, believing the other to be inherently corrupt or unnatural. It's the same coin, just different sides. Now with Luke and Snoke, it seems they found a new coin, but again represent each side of it. Snoke is stated to have been encouraging Kylo to find balance between the light and the dark side. I imagine Luke will do the same for Rey. The difference is that it seems Snoke puts emphasis on the struggle (or inherent chaos) of staying in the middle, and it is the pull felt toward either one side that is the key to absolute power, although that's just my theory.
What are your thoughts?
The foremost question I have is what exactly was the Chosen One prophecy? As per Lucas, the description was simplying "to destroy the Sith." How would cleansing just one-side of the Force bring it into balance though? It seems essential that both the Jedi and the Sith, the two extreme organizations of the Force, needed to be destroyed. If true, then how could Luke Skywalker live yet the prophecy be fulfilled? It would seem to me that, with the galaxy in the presence of no Sith and one Jedi, that the Force would be out-of-balance toward the light-side.
The second point of discussion is simplying on the various "sides" of the Force. The canon interpretation seems to be a spectrum, with the light on one end and the dark on the other. Some Force-users aim to be in the middle, however unless they have sufficient mastery, they generally stray toward either the dark or the light. Also, based on this perspective, the Jedi, the ultimate light-side faction, would be just as extreme and dangerous toward the balance of the Force as the Sith, again bringing into question how Luke could be alive yet the prophecy fufilled.
I've observed that Yoda and the Emperor have essentially the same extremist view of the Force. Both believe in the absolute giving of ones self toward their respective side of the Force, believing the other to be inherently corrupt or unnatural. It's the same coin, just different sides. Now with Luke and Snoke, it seems they found a new coin, but again represent each side of it. Snoke is stated to have been encouraging Kylo to find balance between the light and the dark side. I imagine Luke will do the same for Rey. The difference is that it seems Snoke puts emphasis on the struggle (or inherent chaos) of staying in the middle, and it is the pull felt toward either one side that is the key to absolute power, although that's just my theory.
What are your thoughts?