The Implications of Darth Vader Annual #2

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Underachiever59
Spoiler alert for anyone who hasn't read the comic. Don't read this if you haven't read it yet.

So, in the Darth Vader Annual #2, Vader figures out what the Death Star is. He discovers that it is a world-killer, built using kyber crystals. When he confronts Tarkin over this, Tarkin effectively mocks Vader, pointing out Vader's hypocrisy over the Death Star being a technological aberration, while Vader himself is also one. In response, Vader makes a "prediction" that the Death Star will be Tarkin's tomb.

The next page, we see a droid approach Lyra Erso, Galen Erso's wife. Vader learned of Galen and Lyra earlier in the comic. This droid warns Lyra of just what kind of monstrosity her husband is working on, then subsequently self-destructs. Which leads to Galen leaving Project Stardust.

Galen then is forced back into working on Project Stardust by Krennic. Galen engineers a deliberate design flaw into the Death Star. Vader then 'fails' to prevent the Rebels from escaping with the plans over Scariff. Vader then 'fails' to capture the plans on the Tantive IV. When he has the perfect chance to secure the plans on the Death Star, he deliberately allows the rebels to escape, "to lead back to the Rebel base." And ultimately, this chain of coincidences leads to Tarkin, Vader's greatest rival in the Empire, being killed when the Death Star, a piece of technology that would have basically made Vader obsolete, is destroyed by the Rebellion.

The implication, at least from how I see it, is that Vader deliberately engineered all of these events by warning Lyra. This comic set up Vader as a mastermind, orchestrating the downfall of the one man in the Empire who outranked him (not counting the Emperor himself), along with the destruction of a weapon of fear and power so great that Vader's role as the Emperor's enforcer would no longer have been necessary.

To me, this might be the greatest example of weaponized Force precognition I've seen. The domino effect caused by Vader warning Lyra Erso of what her husband was creating effectively wiped out all opposition within the Empire for Vader, opening up an opportunity for him to seize control of the entire Imperial military in the 2015 Vader comic.

Of course, I could be reading too much into this, but I strongly feel that this is what the story was trying to get across. We already know Vader is excellent at long-term scheming, thanks to the 2015 Vader comic run. And it makes sense for his Force precognition skills to be powerful enough for him to predict such a chain of events, given who Vader is. It almost reminds me of how the Shatterpoint ability worked in Legends. Vader just happened to find the perfect shatterpoint to bring down both Tarkin and the Death Star with a few anonymous words to the wife of a random scientist.

That's my speculation on this, anyway. What do you guys think? Was this a grand plan by Vader to wipe out his rival? Or am I reading way too much into this?

Freedon Nadd
Vader is not really that. He is a bit of a schemer, but not so complex.

Total Warrior
This is very interesting

Freedon Nadd
I bet he just wants to s**k Vader's Force balls with this post. As if it proves he is one of the strongest Sith Lords.

Zenwolf
That is pretty stupid just to allow all that to happen just to kill Tarkin, I don't see how the DS would make Vader obsolete. Destroying planets all willy nilly wouldn't be beneficial at all and aside from the superlaser, the Death Star is just a giant mobile station so Vader could still be the Emperor's enforcer and his apprentice....yeah Vader just allowing all that to happen just to get rid of the Death Star and Tarkin is dumb.

MythLord
Fascinating... but probably not.

Freedon Nadd
Sarcasm.

SIDIOUS 66
Yeah, the comic sucked. Didn't like any of it. All of it was just off, IMO. I liked the idea that Vader and Tarkin had such deep respect for one another that they almost had somewhat of a friendship (despite disagreements) not an enemy-alliance with complete disrespect for one another.

Freedon Nadd
Touche.

relentless1
this issue definitely makes it look like Vader set Tarkin up; obviously he sent the messenger droid to Erso... and I dig that, Vader has never been seen as a schemer so its nice to see him learning from his master and doing what Sidious did... one thing I dont get though is how does Vader know nothing of the Death Star when he is seen watching its development at the end of ROTS?

Freedon Nadd
Stop it.

Zenwolf
Originally posted by relentless1
this issue definitely makes it look like Vader set Tarkin up; obviously he sent the messenger droid to Erso... and I dig that, Vader has never been seen as a schemer so its nice to see him learning from his master and doing what Sidious did... one thing I dont get though is how does Vader know nothing of the Death Star when he is seen watching its development at the end of ROTS?

Could be he saw it, but didn't know what it was going to be able to do. Could be he just saw it as a station.

But it doesn't really add up he doesn't know about it either.

Galan007
^ That's exactly the case.

Vader obviously knew that Palpatine was constructing a massive space station, but he didn't know its true purpose(as a planet-killer) until he saw that kyber crystals were being harvested as a power source for its primary weapon.

That was also revealed in the recent Annual:
https://s7d1.turboimg.net/t1/38928787_Darth_Vader_2017-_002_-_Annual-025.jpg https://s7d1.turboimg.net/t1/38928788_Darth_Vader_2017-_002_-_Annual-026.jpg https://s7d1.turboimg.net/t1/38928789_Darth_Vader_2017-_002_-_Annual-027.jpg

Zenwolf
Originally posted by Galan007
^ That's exactly the case.

Vader obviously knew that Palpatine was constructing a massive space station, but he didn't know its true purpose(as a planet-killer) until he saw that kyber crystals were being harvested as a power source for its primary weapon.

That was also revealed in the recent Annual:
https://s7d1.turboimg.net/t1/38928787_Darth_Vader_2017-_002_-_Annual-025.jpg https://s7d1.turboimg.net/t1/38928788_Darth_Vader_2017-_002_-_Annual-026.jpg https://s7d1.turboimg.net/t1/38928789_Darth_Vader_2017-_002_-_Annual-027.jpg

Well I mean if they wanna go that route, then...ok? Though I necessarily don't agree with it as it seems kinda pointless, other than showing Vader throwing a fit over it. He didn't really seem to give two *** about the DS in ANH, so why he would care it would replace him when it wouldn't is beyond me.

Unless the Emperor would allow the Empire to just destroy every single planet that decided to rebel against them.

Galan007
What I didn't like is how this issue depicted Tarkin and Vader as bitter rivals... Yet in pretty much all other canon prior to this they have a mutual respect toward one another.

Zenwolf
Originally posted by Galan007
What I didn't like is how this issue depicted Tarkin and Vader as bitter rivals... Yet in pretty much all other canon prior to this they have a mutual respect toward one another.

I wasn't really too happy with that either, Vader did have respect for some of the officers he got involved with.

relentless1
lol you can respect someone and still want to kill them;

ras al ghul and batman

kraven and spider man

rogues and flash

xavier and magneto

this is just a new wrinkle in the story between Tarkin and Vader; one that adds a lot to both characters if you ask me

darthbane77
Makes, would be cool of accurate,

Galan007
Originally posted by relentless1
lol you can respect someone and still want to kill them;

ras al ghul and batman

kraven and spider man

rogues and flash

xavier and magneto

this is just a new wrinkle in the story between Tarkin and Vader; one that adds a lot to both characters if you ask me Except there was no hint of respect here from either party. Tarkin treated Vader like a b*tch -- completely belittled and talked down to him. Same coin, Vader seemed to utterly loathe Tarkin.

This doesn't at all mesh with their previously established history wherein they share a great deal of mutual respect with one another, and certainly do not go around verbally berating each other... /shrug

relentless1
ok but this is the first time that Tarkin has had explicit control over Vader, theres bound to be growing pains there for sure; keep in mind theres like 18 years between this and ANH

DarthAnt66

Freedon Nadd
Creator or random poster?

DarthPlaguis12
Why show Tarkin n Vader be allies in most canon then suddenly be enemies

Just dumb.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.