Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Poll

Dangit.

I accidentally voted for JP.

I wanted to vote for Ledger. My bad.

Seriously, Ledger. Much better.

T6LWmD9YRpU

Phoenix delivered an amazing performance with the character he was given, but if we're talking about who is the better Clown Prince of Crime, it's definitely Ledger's Joker.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Dangit.

I accidentally voted for JP.

I wanted to vote for Ledger. My bad.

Seriously, Ledger. Much better.

How could you screw up something so simple, my simple-minded friend?

No love for Nicholson?

Originally posted by BrolyBlack
How could you screw up something so simple, my simple-minded friend?

At least I can peepee all by myself with no help! uhuh

Edit - In other polls systems not made with a mid-2000s VBulletin Board system, you can change your vote.

Ledger without a doubt for me.

He is the best representation of the Joker 'overall'.

Originally posted by Surtur
No love for Nicholson?

He should have been in the poll. Not to mention Hammill.

==

That said, Phoenix is the performance I enjoyed more. I saw more of what i look for in the Joker in Phoenix than I did in Ledger.

I guess they did not put Hamill in the poll because he was obviously the superior one.

https://i.imgur.com/gp0u1Ij.jpg

Anyone that isn't Leto's is a winner.

ledger
hamil
romero
nicholson
phoenix

Originally posted by dadudemon
At least I can peepee all by myself with no help! uhuh

Edit - In other polls systems not made with a mid-2000s VBulletin Board system, you can change your vote.

You need to be taken out back and beaten

Phoenix Joker isn't actually The Joker, it's one of the Joker's fantasies about where he came from. Ledger Joker was the real deal.

Phoenix did the better performance but it wasn't really the Joker. So by that measure it was Ledger (who I still think got massively overrated for the role simply because he died shortly after it)

Nicholson

Originally posted by Dr Will Hatch
Phoenix Joker isn't actually The Joker, it's one of the Joker's fantasies about where he came from. Ledger Joker was the real deal.

Originally posted by -Pr-
He should have been in the poll.

You don't think that... you know... Nicholson played himself, as usual?

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Nicholson



Hamill
Nicholson
Romero
Ledger
Not Leto


Aint seen "Joker" Yet.

Go and see it, then.

Ledger for me

I wait for the Crowds to thin out.

I hate sitting next to a Crazy Stilts Level Fan Boy.

I feel we haven't seen enough of Phoenix Joker because he was only really Joker in a small portion of the film so Ledger wins by default.

Originally posted by Flyattractor
I wait for the Crowds to thin out.

I hate sitting next to a Crazy Stilts Level Fan Boy.

Little Fly is scared of leaving his basement?

Originally posted by Flyattractor
I wait for the Crowds to thin out.

I hate sitting next to a Crazy Stilts Level Fan Boy.

They're not letting you leave, are they?

https://i.ibb.co/9yLFVJ6/flysux.png

That is funny. Especially coming from a Living in a Fantasy Troll Land like You do.

Originally posted by jaden_2.0
Phoenix did the better performance but it wasn't really the Joker. So by that measure it was Ledger (who I still think got massively overrated for the role simply because he died shortly after it) Essentially this (though I don't think Ledger was all that overrated, maybe he shouldn't have taken the Oscar but I don't remember who he was up against), and anyone who thinks Ledger's performance was better than Phoenix's was is delusional, btw.

When you consider Heath Ledger's actual personality and mannerisms... how he transformed into the joker like that bewilders me. He broke the character away from a slapstick gangster and to a much darker, psychological place.

Joaquin already had the foundations to be A joker imo.

I agree that The Dark Knight in general is not as good of a performance but Heath is the greater actor in my opinion.