Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Probably, yes.

Vader wins IMO.

Vader would probably rage out like we've never seen in this scenario. I'd go with him also.

Vader already raged out in ROTS when Palpatine told him Padme was dead and he couldn't even touch him with the Force; everything else in the room got crushed and Sidious just stood there smiling. The novel goes even further saying that Vader reached out to kill him with the Force but didn't have the strength to

Vader gets dusted

Originally posted by relentless1
Vader already raged out in ROTS when Palpatine told him Padme was dead and he couldn't even touch him with the Force; everything else in the room got crushed and Sidious just stood there smiling. The novel goes even further saying that Vader reached out to kill him with the Force but didn't have the strength to

Vader gets dusted


He was weakened at that point from his injuries.

Besides even pre-injuries is not his Prime according to Disney.

Not to mention that the novel is practically retconed by the comics where we see Vader tk slamming Palpatine into a wall right after he got off the operating table.

https://i.ibb.co/DzxWtRs/Darth-Vader-001-004.jpg https://i.ibb.co/vBprc5T/Darth-Vader-001-005.jpg https://i.ibb.co/JnkHXfy/Darth-Vader-001-006.jpg

^Vader is also trying and failing to Force Choke Sidious there. But yeah anyone who kills Padme in front of any form of Vader/Anakin is getting dusted imo

Yes if Sidious killed Padme in front of him during ROTJ he'd be in trouble for sure

That would actually show he is more powerful than Sidious. But just hasnt learned to actualise His full power.

IF that were to happen on some sort of What If...

At this rate disney's just going to have vader force possess sidious, and tell us that sidious was vader all along.