Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Discuss.

Luke.

Yeah, I'm leaning Luke as well. Obi-Wan has more training and is more masterful with the Force, but Luke's raw power and innate ability to instantly learn and adapt to his opponents makes him too much for Obi-Wan to handle. I'm curious to see arguments for Kenobi, though. I'm sure there's definitely an argument to be made either way.

gross

Luke one shots.

nothing on screen suggests that Luke could even tie Obi Wan shoes; Luke loses due to shitty choreography of the time

Kenobi curbstomps Luke.

Esb Luke held his own and scored a shot on Vader before getting stomped by him.

Aotc Kenobi just straight up got mauled my Dooku.

Vader >> Dooku

Esb Luke > AOTC Kenobi

Originally posted by Forschbewithu
Esb Luke held his own and scored a shot on Vader before getting stomped by him.

Aotc Kenobi just straight up got mauled my Dooku.

Vader >> Dooku

Esb Luke > AOTC Kenobi

context is key; Vader wasn't trying to harm Luke, he wanted him captured whole and once Vader took the kid gloves off and actually started trying Luke lost a hand so any comparisons in performance is rendered moot here

Bump.

GI is probably better than AOTC Kenobi so I go with Luke.