Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

I think the movie would have been much better to watch while EP VIII's damage was too big to fill.

But still things like Palpatine's revival, Kylo Ren's redemption and the last fight would have been much smoother.

Honestly, without massive retcons (or should I say, more massive retcons), I don't think episode 9 was really doable. TLJ left too much shit to work with coming in to the end of the trilogy imo.

TLJ did way too much damage to fix.

Originally posted by playa1258
TLJ did way too much damage to fix.

Finally, we agree on something one hundred percent.

Yes, Episode VIII was indeed the worst of them and did catastrophic damage.

IX, no matter how long it would be, would still be all about damage control.


---
I actually wish the OT was longer. There were some fine scenes which weren't included. Biggs Darklighter, Han thanking Luke for rescuing him from Jabba and so on...

https://tinyurl.com/5cfbfetn

If he got a master film maker like suder to help, then maybe!

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Finally, we agree on something one hundred percent.

Yes, Episode VIII was indeed the worst of them and did catastrophic damage.

IX, no matter how long it would be, would still be all about damage control.


---
I actually wish the OT was longer. There were some fine scenes which weren't included. Biggs Darklighter, Han thanking Luke for rescuing him from Jabba and so on...

https://tinyurl.com/5cfbfetn

But IX as a movie would have been smoother with more screen time.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Finally, we agree on something one hundred percent.

Yes, Episode VIII was indeed the worst of them and did catastrophic damage.

IX, no matter how long it would be, would still be all about damage control.


---
I actually wish the OT was longer. There were some fine scenes which weren't included. Biggs Darklighter, Han thanking Luke for rescuing him from Jabba and so on...

https://tinyurl.com/5cfbfetn

Wish we could get an unaltered extended trilogy

Originally posted by playa1258
TLJ did way too much damage to fix.

Couldn't they let someone to reedit TLJ to a new version?

Originally posted by Slowpoke
But IX as a movie would have been smoother with more screen time.

True.

Originally posted by steverules_2
Wish we could get an unaltered extended trilogy

Yeah... so do I...

Im guessing they would at least have explained Palpatines revival.

That in itself would have made a world of difference.

They could flesh out Kylos redemption. Give Lando more time to bring back an army with him. Show Finn actually discovering his force powers. Explain what was going on in that end fight...

So it definitely could have used more time, and could have been substantially improved as a film. But unfortunately the story, the trilogy and the character arcs would still suck.

It's funny --- Expanded Universe (Legends) did a perfect job explaining Palpatine's clones and even his "spirit form"...

Episode IX brings Palps back in the laziest way possible, not bothering to explain anything, really.

the only way the new star wars movies get any better, is for Rey to get penetrated in all holes by tentacles monsters

They need to make the ST non-canon.

Originally posted by MrMind
the only way the new star wars movies get any better, is for Rey to get penetrated in all holes by tentacles monsters



Release the Abrams Cut!!!! dur

https://i.ibb.co/ZzKSLRq/rey01.png

RELEASETHEJJCUT


hahahahaha

Damn Daisy got some bolt ons.

If they let JJ direct the whole series this wouldn't have happened.

JJ Abrams > Rian Johnson.

The characters all sucked, no amount of time would have saved it.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
If they let JJ direct the whole series this wouldn't have happened.



It still would have been a pointless repeat of the OT though.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
If they let JJ direct the whole series this wouldn't have happened.

JJ Abrams > Rian Johnson.


i have always thought that.. had brams directed the whole trilogy, it would've been a whole helluva lot better

There should've been alot more collab between JJ and Rian Johnson over Episode VIII. But of course they told Johnson do whatever the **** you want basically.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
It still would have been a pointless repeat of the OT though.


At least better than now, TLJ was a freaking mockery to all the SW fans and the franchise. WHY did they give Rian Johnson the director helm?

^ Because he showed promise to do a Star Wars movie from his previous works.

Which ones?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Which ones?

Go look them up.

Originally posted by Slowpoke
At least better than now, TLJ was a freaking mockery to all the SW fans and the franchise. WHY did they give Rian Johnson the director helm?


They shouldnt have gotten Abrams either tbh.

He was just the safe financial bet for Episode 7 to bank on nostalgia. But in terms of Vision that was a terrible idea to have him set up a trilogy, let alone do the entire trilogy.

Originally posted by Kazenji
Go look them up.

So, you can't name any


Thank you.

Originally posted by Silent Master
So, you can't name any


Thank you.


Looper was excellent.

Originally posted by Silent Master
So, you can't name any


Thank you.

And you can't use a search engine, Says alot for yourself.

Still can't name any?

Brick was good

He was not a bad director, but using him as SW, a super famous IP's movie trilogy is worse than using a bad director.


I have seen many bad directors ruining franchises, but TLJ is the only time that I see a competent director has no respect of the franchise and intended to mock it with the helm on.