Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

WHo wins?

Sidious is the most powerful sith lord at that time, and since Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon both lost to an apprentice of Sidious (Obi-Wan losing to Dooku, while Qui-Gon losing to Maul) I think Sidious will defeat the two jedi.

Agreed, Sidious is just too, rather ridiculously powerful so he would prevail.

Sidious; I stand by the prophecy.

I think Sidious too, **** prophecies though

You can't dismiss it though as much as a lot of people dislike it. It's fact.

If Vader is equal to Sidious, then the two JEdi wins but i really dunno about this one. They're both Jedi MAsters. If Mace is equal to Sidious, then these two woudl be equal to sidious since both of them are equal to mace.

Yes I can. Well not all the way. But I just take the OT for fact and the other stuff around is just amusement that may or may not have occured, thats just my view of it of course.

Palpy takes it

Wait, **** I misread, I have to change my vote, Qui Gon and AOTC Obi Wan, might take him in a light sabre battle.

what did you thought it was? how did you misread it?

Palpatine is a bastard. He wouldn't fight fair. Like halfway through the saber fight he'd force lightning them, or chuck giant debris or something.

Sidious would own... AOTC Kenobi is still mastering Soresu and his mastery of the force is still in its middle stages... Qui Gonn Jinn was good but his Ataru would be no match for Sidious... and his force power is nowhere near the level of Sidious... even together the Jedi would struggle.

Sidious would own the two... Quick jump down with QGJ Obi Wan will die a second later. We all saw how easy Sidious took down three Jedi Masters in ROTS... QGJ and Obi Wan are not even close to as powerful.

Originally posted by Fishy
Sidious would own the two... Quick jump down with QGJ Obi Wan will die a second later. We all saw how easy Sidious took down three Jedi Masters in ROTS... QGJ and Obi Wan are not even close to as powerful.

actully, i think they are about the same level, but i agree, sids side can take them out in less than 5 swings(and thats not even counting in his lightning)

QGJ might be, but Obi Wan is not near the level of a Master... Seriously he's a Padawan not god.

Originally posted by Fishy
QGJ might be, but Obi Wan is not near the level of a Master... Seriously he's a Padawan not god.

its aotc, not tpm, but im just playing the devils advocate here.

sids still crushes them

This is ridiculous, Maul killed them both, and during the years Obi wan dident change very much, he dident all of a sudden become asweome. He was just near close to mastering his style, but nah sids wins.

Originally posted by jollyjim311
its aotc, not tpm, but im just playing the devils advocate here.

sids still crushes them

Okay, still doesn't matter he might be a knight. But he still isn't on QGJ his level or on that of a council member. He would still get owned by Sidious. Even ROTS Obi wouldn't change this.

Originally posted by Fishy
Okay, still doesn't matter he might be a knight. But he still isn't on QGJ his level or on that of a council member. He would still get owned by Sidious. Even ROTS Obi wouldn't change this.

agreed, it might actually take sids like 7 swings for this though.

Originally posted by jollyjim311
agreed, it might actually take sids like 7 swings for this though.

Two swings and a bolt of lightning.

ok a quick hit agains obis saber, then he cuts back and decapitates him. in the mean time qui gon jumps to try to save obi and sids turns to him and frys him mid-jump.

good call fishy

they could barly take his trainy even they would know they are going to die in seconds