KMC Forums

 
  REGISTER HERE TO JOIN IN! - It's easy and it's free!
Already a member? Log-in!
 
 
Home » Star Wars » Star Wars: Literature & Expanded Universe » What If...


What If...
Started by: Stealth Moose

Forum Jump:
Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Pages (2): [1] 2 »   Last Thread   Next Thread
Author
Thread
Stealth Moose
Umbrella Elite

Registered: Apr 2011
Location: In Ur Raccoon City


 

What If...

1. What if Qui-Gon had lived to mentor Anakin Skywalker?

How do you believe this would change events and why?

2. If Sidious had retained the Empire and not fallen to Skywalker's family drama, how would the subsequent events have turned out? Do you think the stability of Sidious' Empire better than the factions which followed it?

3. How would the Republic have weathered post-OT events had Sidious never come to power? Especially the Vong?


__________________


Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 02:57 AM
Click here to Send Stealth Moose a Private Message Find more posts by Stealth Moose Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Lord Lucien
Lets all love Lain

Registered: Jul 2005
Location:


 

Truculent, get off Janus' account.


__________________
Recently Produced and Distributed Young but High-Ranking Political Figure of Royal Ancestry within the Modern American Town Affectionately Referred To as Bel-Air.

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:06 AM
Click here to Send Lord Lucien a Private Message Find more posts by Lord Lucien Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Stealth Moose
Umbrella Elite

Registered: Apr 2011
Location: In Ur Raccoon City


 

STFU, Canadian. You cannot defeat me.


__________________


Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:09 AM
Click here to Send Stealth Moose a Private Message Find more posts by Stealth Moose Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Lord Lucien
Lets all love Lain

Registered: Jul 2005
Location:


 

Aw--ohh...


__________________
Recently Produced and Distributed Young but High-Ranking Political Figure of Royal Ancestry within the Modern American Town Affectionately Referred To as Bel-Air.

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:11 AM
Click here to Send Lord Lucien a Private Message Find more posts by Lord Lucien Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
ares834
Senior Member

Registered: Apr 2009
Location: United States


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Truculent, get off Janus' account.



laughing





I was thinking the same thing.

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:12 AM
Click here to Send ares834 a Private Message Find more posts by ares834 Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Nephthys
The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

Registered: Dec 2007
Location: The End


 

1. Qui-Gon is the one character in the prequels who I actually like. He's also the wisest guy there is and would undoubtably steer Annie in the right direction. He'd be less f a wierd brother that Anakin would compete with and blame for his shortcomings and more of a surrogate dad, who'd actually not **** shit up.

2. There'd always be rebellion against him, bt it'd be less chaotic than the craziness of the Post-Endor stuff.

3. A proper Jedi Order would beat back the Vong imo.


__________________

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:15 AM
Click here to Send Nephthys a Private Message Find more posts by Nephthys Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
-kV-
[:::::{============)

Registered: Dec 2005
Location: Orion-Cygnus Arm


 

If Qui-Gon lived, Anakin may not have fallen. In which case, he may never have brought balance to the Force. The imbalance would have caused the entire galaxy to collapse, and obliterate.

So, Darth Maul ended up saving the galaxy.


__________________


BlackZero30x created this a-'Maize'-ing signature! =)

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:17 AM
Click here to Send -kV- a Private Message Find more posts by -kV- Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Lord Lucien
Lets all love Lain

Registered: Jul 2005
Location:


 

If Anakin really was the Chosen One, and had had proper tutelage under Jinn, wouldn't he have been in a more tenable position from which to confront the Sith?


__________________
Recently Produced and Distributed Young but High-Ranking Political Figure of Royal Ancestry within the Modern American Town Affectionately Referred To as Bel-Air.

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:23 AM
Click here to Send Lord Lucien a Private Message Find more posts by Lord Lucien Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
-kV-
[:::::{============)

Registered: Dec 2005
Location: Orion-Cygnus Arm


 

The inherent douchness in Anakin probably would have made him fall anyway.


__________________


BlackZero30x created this a-'Maize'-ing signature! =)

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:27 AM
Click here to Send -kV- a Private Message Find more posts by -kV- Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Stealth Moose
Umbrella Elite

Registered: Apr 2011
Location: In Ur Raccoon City


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Korto Vos
The inherent douchness in Anakin probably would have made him fall anyway.


THis.


__________________


Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:37 AM
Click here to Send Stealth Moose a Private Message Find more posts by Stealth Moose Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Zamp
The Blind Critic

Registered: Jun 2007
Location: Haven


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Korto Vos
The inherent douchness in Anakin probably would have made him fall anyway.

Disagree. From a narrative standpoint, the Fall is much more tragic if it could have been avoided. I believe that Jinn's emphasis on the moment, especially when compared with Kenobi's contentious past, would have benefited Skywalker considerably. (Have you read the books about Kenobi? He leaves the Jedi Order. He quits. And then he trains Darth Vader.)


__________________

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 02:41 PM
Click here to Send Zamp a Private Message Find more posts by Zamp Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
-kV-
[:::::{============)

Registered: Dec 2005
Location: Orion-Cygnus Arm


 

Just because a fall could have been avoided doesn't mean it's tragic. All falls can be avoided, for that matter. What makes it tragic is the character's intentions and personality beforehand that becomes twisted as a result of his/her actions and experiences.

The child who was optimistic, enthusiastic, and compassionate in TPM becomes unnecessarily cantakerous, fiery, unappreciative, creepy, and egotistic in AOTC. The movie fails to explain anything in the 10 years that caused Anakin to become a complete douche; Obi-Wan is shown to be a completely competent master. The movie fails to state that Anakin wouldn't have become like this under Jinn's tutelage.


__________________


BlackZero30x created this a-'Maize'-ing signature! =)

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 03:59 PM
Click here to Send -kV- a Private Message Find more posts by -kV- Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Stealth Moose
Umbrella Elite

Registered: Apr 2011
Location: In Ur Raccoon City


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Korto Vos
Just because a fall could have been avoided doesn't mean it's tragic. All falls can be avoided, for that matter. What makes it tragic is the character's intentions and personality beforehand that becomes twisted as a result of his/her actions and experiences.

The child who was optimistic, enthusiastic, and compassionate in TPM becomes unnecessarily cantakerous, fiery, unappreciative, creepy, and egotistic in AOTC. The movie fails to explain anything in the 10 years that caused Anakin to become a complete douche; Obi-Wan is shown to be a completely competent master. The movie fails to state that Anakin wouldn't have become like this under Jinn's tutelage.


You could say that Anakin, having known a true parent and having been a slave earlier in life who has unnatural talent, chafes at Kenobi's more orthodox approach. It's noted consistently that Anakin loves Kenobi, but does not know what goes on in his mind because he's so close-minded. This is a far cry from his mother whom he loved and shared thoughts and emotions with, and it may be the catalyst for why Anakin harbors thoughts that everyone is out to oppress him and the Jedi Order is (rightfully) inept and uncaring.

It doesn't justify youngling killing, choking Padme, and generally being a douche, but it can make his fall seem to be more destined, I suppose, based on his unusual predicament. Most Jedi are given to the Order before they can talk, so he's naturally got some baggage.

Qui-Gon himself was impulsive, restless, and unorthodox. Anakin might have trusted him more and been loyal to the Jedi Master as opposed to the Order, I suspect. Would he still have fallen? I'm not sure. I believe that Qui-Gon, with his suspicious, truth-ferretting nature, would have been an impediment to Sidious and ultimately removed. The tragedy would likely have been that Sidious, in his dark genius, would have framed the Republic/Jedi in the incident, thus gaining Anakin's unwavering support.

Que RotS, but with Obi-Wan not being as well versed in Anakin's battle style. Obi-Wan loses, OT is obsolete.


__________________


Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 06:36 PM
Click here to Send Stealth Moose a Private Message Find more posts by Stealth Moose Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
-kV-
[:::::{============)

Registered: Dec 2005
Location: Orion-Cygnus Arm


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Stealth Moose
You could say that Anakin, having known a true parent and having been a slave earlier in life who has unnatural talent, chafes at Kenobi's more orthodox approach. It's noted consistently that Anakin loves Kenobi, but does not know what goes on in his mind because he's so close-minded. This is a far cry from his mother whom he loved and shared thoughts and emotions with, and it may be the catalyst for why Anakin harbors thoughts that everyone is out to oppress him and the Jedi Order is (rightfully) inept and uncaring.

It doesn't justify youngling killing, choking Padme, and generally being a douche, but it can make his fall seem to be more destined, I suppose, based on his unusual predicament. Most Jedi are given to the Order before they can talk, so he's naturally got some baggage.

Qui-Gon himself was impulsive, restless, and unorthodox. Anakin might have trusted him more and been loyal to the Jedi Master as opposed to the Order, I suspect. Would he still have fallen? I'm not sure. I believe that Qui-Gon, with his suspicious, truth-ferretting nature, would have been an impediment to Sidious and ultimately removed. The tragedy would likely have been that Sidious, in his dark genius, would have framed the Republic/Jedi in the incident, thus gaining Anakin's unwavering support.

Que RotS, but with Obi-Wan not being as well versed in Anakin's battle style. Obi-Wan loses, OT is obsolete.


I'm just contending Zamp's statement that a fall is more tragic if it could be avoided.

Seriously though (which my first two posts in this thread were not), I have to moderately agree with you on your assessment of Jinn.

My only problem is the wretched way that ends up demonstrated on screen. I remember how in the 2003 Clone Wars cartoon, Anakin actually says to Obi-Wan, "And you are no Qui-Gon Jinn!" If that line was mentioned in AOTC or something similar, then the audience can understand that Anakin may not be so angst-y if Jinn was alive. But instead we are left with a really cheerful kid, though sad about leaving his mom, who wanted to become a Jedi more than anything else ending up as a complete "WTF" ten years later.

And it seems more like Obi-Wan acts the way he does because he has to parent Anakin's immature behavior rather than Anakin being so emotionally unstable because he can't appreciate Kenobi's orthodox approach.


__________________


BlackZero30x created this a-'Maize'-ing signature! =)

Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 07:36 PM
Click here to Send -kV- a Private Message Find more posts by -kV- Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Stealth Moose
Umbrella Elite

Registered: Apr 2011
Location: In Ur Raccoon City


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Korto Vos
And it seems more like Obi-Wan acts the way he does because he has to parent Anakin's immature behavior rather than Anakin being so emotionally unstable because he can't appreciate Kenobi's orthodox approach.


Obi-Wan himself had doubts and insecurity (Cloak of Deception) but was very outspoken and while not arrogant, he was oft corrected by Qui-Gon Jinn. I think he attempted to emulate the Qui-Gon's father figure-ness, but at the same time temper it with Mace and Yoda's approaches, which was questionable. Mace was emotionally dead to anyone who wasn't Depa, iirc, and while he was a good man, he was not a sympathetic one. Yoda himself had glaring faults, and while he was no doubt a good teacher with his pseudo-Socratic method, he shaped the Order which rotted from within.

I can't fault Obi-Wan for being a bad teacher though. I've taught youths who simply could not, would not accept wisdom if it was dropped on their heads, and as a teenager I was the same way for a long time. Experience can make someone more mild and patient for learning, but that takes time. Anakin Skywalker was already ahead of people his age thanks to his vast powers and his being singled out by the current DLotS. Had he simply just been a Jedi in a boring era, I doubt he would have fallen at all, he just would have been an insufferable douche until he reached his epiphany.. Sidious was the ultimate catalyst.


__________________


Old Post Aug 16th, 2011 07:53 PM
Click here to Send Stealth Moose a Private Message Find more posts by Stealth Moose Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Zamp
The Blind Critic

Registered: Jun 2007
Location: Haven


 

quote:

Just because a fall could have been avoided doesn't mean it's tragic. All falls can be avoided, for that matter. What makes it tragic is the character's intentions and personality beforehand that becomes twisted as a result of his/her actions and experiences.

I'm finding it very difficult to phrase this diplomatically so forgive me if I just lecture:

In literature, a tragic flaw is a character trait that ultimately leads to a character's downfall. Oftentimes this trait is one that would be positive in any other situation. The example through which I learned the concept is Chiuna Achebe's Things Fall Apart (intro to Lit ftw) where a strong, honorable family leader is utterly bewildered by a new world order (colonialism). The book talks about a lot of things, but the basic plot is that the main character would be a fantastic leader under the old ways, but that strength undermines his position after the Europeans show up.

Anakin is in a similar situation. He is strong-willed, loyal, and intensely uncomfortable with dishonesty. These are all traits that can be positive. However, his journey finds him in places where those are all liabilities. Thus, the basic criteria are fulfilled for a tragic flaw.

So, I believe that I have clarified my use of the term "tragic," with which you initially disagreed. It now falls to me to defend the idea that:
  1. Qui Gon Jinn would have done a better job than Kenobi
  2. The relationship between Jinn and Kenobi imparts some level of irony to Kenobi's failure
  3. The Star Wars saga is more compelling because of [a] and [b]

I obviously cannot prove conclusively that Jinn would have done a better job. However, I would like to point out that the series of YA books chronicling Obi Wan Kenobi's life as a padawan paints him in much the same light as Anakin. An impulsive, reckless padawan ignores the rules of the Order to do what he feels is right, ultimately resulting in his expulsion/departure from the order. Yeah, Kenobi quits being a Jedi for a little while. Crazy, right? Well, Jinn is able to guide one padawan through the darkness. [I also have a half formed point about the unifying versus the living Force, but I can't remember which one was Jinn's favorite.]

Jinn's experience and wisdom should be sufficient to allow him to retain the authority position that Kenobi relinquished the second he began thinking of Anakin as "brother." The novelization of RotS calls Kenobi "the perfect Jedi" but he has one attachment: Anakin. Jinn would have maintained a more traditional Master/Apprentice bond, simply because of the age gap.

So, in my mind at least, there are a few reasons to believe that Jinn was capable of doing a better job than Kenobi. Now to the ironic part: Kenobi was at least partially formed by Jinn's teaching. That is to say, parts of his personality and mentality were comprised of what he learned from Jinn. It is a bit ironic that where Jinn succeeded (specifically, keeping his padawan in the Jedi Order) Kenobi failed spectacularly. Of all the skills to pick up, that seems like one of the most important. "Hey this is the Chosen One. Make sure he's a Jedi. don't let him quit."

Last letter in the list:
Those are the reasons I think (a) and (b). In my mind, the tragic loss of Qui Gon Jinn is the only plotworthy element in TPM. Thus: (c).


Edit: didn't proofread this; it took forever to write. Forgive me if it is incoherent.


__________________

Old Post Aug 17th, 2011 02:26 AM
Click here to Send Zamp a Private Message Find more posts by Zamp Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Turr_Phennir
Restricted

Registered: Aug 2011
Location: Pennsylvania, United States

Account Restricted


 

no

Old Post Aug 17th, 2011 02:27 AM
Click here to Send Turr_Phennir a Private Message Find more posts by Turr_Phennir Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Nephthys
The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

Registered: Dec 2007
Location: The End


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Zampanů
I'm finding it very difficult to phrase this diplomatically so forgive me if I just lecture:

In literature, a tragic flaw is a character trait that ultimately leads to a character's downfall. Oftentimes this trait is one that would be positive in any other situation. The example through which I learned the concept is Chiuna Achebe's Things Fall Apart (intro to Lit ftw) where a strong, honorable family leader is utterly bewildered by a new world order (colonialism). The book talks about a lot of things, but the basic plot is that the main character would be a fantastic leader under the old ways, but that strength undermines his position after the Europeans show up.

Anakin is in a similar situation. He is strong-willed, loyal, and intensely uncomfortable with dishonesty. These are all traits that can be positive. However, his journey finds him in places where those are all liabilities. Thus, the basic criteria are fulfilled for a tragic flaw.

So, I believe that I have clarified my use of the term "tragic," with which you initially disagreed. It now falls to me to defend the idea that:
  1. Qui Gon Jinn would have done a better job than Kenobi
  2. The relationship between Jinn and Kenobi imparts some level of irony to Kenobi's failure
  3. The Star Wars saga is more compelling because of [a] and [b]

I obviously cannot prove conclusively that Jinn would have done a better job. However, I would like to point out that the series of YA books chronicling Obi Wan Kenobi's life as a padawan paints him in much the same light as Anakin. An impulsive, reckless padawan ignores the rules of the Order to do what he feels is right, ultimately resulting in his expulsion/departure from the order. Yeah, Kenobi quits being a Jedi for a little while. Crazy, right? Well, Jinn is able to guide one padawan through the darkness. [I also have a half formed point about the unifying versus the living Force, but I can't remember which one was Jinn's favorite.]

Jinn's experience and wisdom should be sufficient to allow him to retain the authority position that Kenobi relinquished the second he began thinking of Anakin as "brother." The novelization of RotS calls Kenobi "the perfect Jedi" but he has one attachment: Anakin. Jinn would have maintained a more traditional Master/Apprentice bond, simply because of the age gap.

So, in my mind at least, there are a few reasons to believe that Jinn was capable of doing a better job than Kenobi. Now to the ironic part: Kenobi was at least partially formed by Jinn's teaching. That is to say, parts of his personality and mentality were comprised of what he learned from Jinn. It is a bit ironic that where Jinn succeeded (specifically, keeping his padawan in the Jedi Order) Kenobi failed spectacularly. Of all the skills to pick up, that seems like one of the most important. "Hey this is the Chosen One. Make sure he's a Jedi. don't let him quit."

Last letter in the list:
Those are the reasons I think (a) and (b). In my mind, the tragic loss of Qui Gon Jinn is the only plotworthy element in TPM. Thus: (c).


Edit: didn't proofread this; it took forever to write. Forgive me if it is incoherent.


thumb up


__________________

Old Post Aug 17th, 2011 02:34 AM
Click here to Send Nephthys a Private Message Find more posts by Nephthys Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Zamp
The Blind Critic

Registered: Jun 2007
Location: Haven


 

not to be a juicebag, but no one asked you Gideon you inbred redneck teabagger


__________________

Old Post Aug 17th, 2011 02:34 AM
Click here to Send Zamp a Private Message Find more posts by Zamp Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
Turr_Phennir
Restricted

Registered: Aug 2011
Location: Pennsylvania, United States

Account Restricted


 

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Zampanů
not to be a juicebag, but no one asked you Gideon you inbred redneck teabagger


What if I told you that I'd prefer that to Gideon? no expression

Old Post Aug 17th, 2011 02:38 AM
Click here to Send Turr_Phennir a Private Message Find more posts by Turr_Phennir Edit/Delete Message Reply w/Quote Quick Quote
All times are UTC. The time now is 01:01 PM.
Pages (2): [1] 2 »   Last Thread   Next Thread

Email this Page
Subscribe to this Thread
   Post New Thread  Post A Reply

Forum Jump:
Search by user:
 

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are ON
[IMG] code is ON

Text-only version
 

< Contact Us - KillerMovies.com - Forum Archive - Forum Rules >


© Copyright 2000-2006, KillerMovies.com. All Rights Reserved.
Forum powered by: vBulletin, copyright ©2000-2006, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.