Canon Vader comics have a scene with kenobi where he seems to imply he gets more powerful with "each step further away from you" after he kills him on the death star. I'm 99% sure the pablo hidalgo quote specifically is saying that was vader's prime, up until that point.
I don't think there is anything in canon stating that Vader was "weaker" in RotJ. Granted, there was underlying conflict/good in him(which both Luke and Palpatine sensed), but I don't know that the "flickering light"(as Palpatine described it) within Vader would have gimped his power or whathaveyou.
__________________
"I am tired of Earth. These people.
I am tired of being caught in the tangle of their lives."
I think ROTJ was Vaders peak. No reason to believe Vaders powers just stopped growing, and being "conflicted" against Luke doesnt necessarily mean his power declined IMO.
Did you read Darth's post? Yes, it heavily implied. A force users abilities rely heavily on their state of mind. And if they are conflicted they tend not to fight nearly as well as they normally could.
As ares and DT mentioned: inner conflict can have a heavy impact on a character's overall power. So it really just depends if the conflict Vader was experiencing during RotJ was enough to hinder his abilities in such a way.
I will say that said conflict must have been buried pretty deep, as Vader was still willing to bring Luke before Palpatine, then defend Palpatine from Luke's strike, then go on to try and coax Luke towards the dark side -- even Jedi vs. Sith states that Vader was initially trying to turn Luke towards the dark side. It wasn't until Luke was dying right in front of him that Vader finally embraced the underlying good in himself. Prior to that, it didn't seem like Vader was at all prepared to walk away from the dark side/Palpatine.
Maybe the new comic series(which is set between ESB and RotJ) will shed some more light on that aspect of Vader's character.
__________________
"I am tired of Earth. These people.
I am tired of being caught in the tangle of their lives."
Vader was indeed conflicted as made clear by Starwars.com and evident from the movie.
This means there were cracks in Vader's surface of dark side emotions through which Luke was able to sense the good in Vader. Compassion for his son was weakening his hatred (eventually overcoming it later in the movie). Even though Vader was still using the dark side to fight, it's possible he couldn't do it in full capacity. How much was this affecting Vader's abilities is hard to quantifie though.
Last edited by Darthadi on May 30th, 2020 at 11:51 AM
Registered: Dec 2019
Location: Imperial Throne Room
IIRC the Disney Novels for ROTJ tell us that he was contempletating killing Luke, and had hatrid for him, I think due to jealousy but I can't remember.
But abilities wise, I'm sure he'd be fine as long as Luke isn't talking. So imo ROTJ is still peak Vader until Luke tells him to let go of his hate.
Registered: Dec 2019
Location: Imperial Throne Room
I'm 70% sure it's from Beware of the Dark Side. But yes I never said he wasn't conflicted, just that I don't think it hinders him unless it gets brought to the surface like when Luke talks to him before they go to meet the Emperor.
^ Sure it might have always been there to a small extent. Thats why Vader says - You were right about me - and Luke first senses that good in him in ESB, but it clearly wasnt effecting him too much yet.
Granted the underlying conflict/good was still there, but without Luke in the picture to coax it out of Vader, it don't think it would have been much of a hindrance to his overall abilities.
Make no mistake, Vader was still evil in that era.
__________________
"I am tired of Earth. These people.
I am tired of being caught in the tangle of their lives."
Last edited by Galan007 on May 31st, 2020 at 12:14 AM
Stuff like this makes me wonder if, when Vader stops Luke from striking down the emperor, he wasn't just doing it to protect his master. That a small part of him, maybe, was protecting Luke from going down the same path he had.
May 29th, 2020 06:15 PM
