Darkman gets my vote because that movie sucked and I have sympathy for him.
Plus, if he gets called a "freak" by Batman and Daredevil, he'll win. Then again, given he's fighting a blind man and a multibillionare who's seen less tail than probably half of the people on this forum because he spends all his time in a bat-infested cave, I don't think that'll happen.
In a fist to fist fight, considering Darkman cannot feel pain cause the doctors after his "accident" were forced to cut his nervous center rending him unable to feel pain, he'll be hella tough to beat down.
Also when he's enraged his body release adrenaline that gives him the strenght of 10 men.