1. Hal Jordan - Yes
2. Dr. Doom - Doom breaks Desaads will
3. Mr. Sinister - Eh, not sure, but will say yes
4. Captain America - No
5. Batman - No
6. Magneto - Yes
7. Lobo - No
8. Spider-Man - Yes
9. Norman Osborne - Yes
10. Sinestro - Yes
1. Hal Jordan- yes
2. Dr. Doom- Doom pulls him away from Darkseid to work for him
3. Mr. Sinister- Think Apocalypse broke his brain too much to be an issue
4. Captain America- Captain America does not break... Period.
5. Batman- Batman wouldn't be done through direct torture but if he gets to bat family definitely could break Batman's will
6. Magneto- Hmmm... depends is this utterly ruthless magneto or what? Magneto at his most ruthless does not break. But current and more commonly seen semi-softy for mutants Magneto does.
7. Lobo- LoL he calls whatever Desaad does a spa treatment... Unless he threatens the Space Dolphins then Lobo breaks whatever is holding him down even if it was Omega Sanction given physical form to break Desaad in half with his pinky.
8. Spider-Man- yes and easily Peter has never been the most stable character. Very prone to angst.
9. Norman Osborne- a$$hat crazy Norman or regular Norman. Regular breaks crazy one is too crazy
10. Sinestro- Yes...
1. Hal Jordan - Yes.
2. Dr. Doom - No. His sociopathic pride would have him die first.
3. Mr. Sinister - Yes.
4. Captain America - No.
5. Batman - Desaad would come close but Bats would pull through. He's psycholgically susceptible though.
6. Magneto - Yes.
7. Lobo - No. Nihilistic, he'd die first.
8. Spider-Man - Yes.
9. Norman Osborne - Yes.
10. Sinestro - Yes.
I dare say though that if he could keep them from dying and keep them totally conscious throughout, with the exception of Lobo (who's an immortal at home with the deepest pain, psychological or otherwise) they'd all break eventually.
__________________
Iboga chose not to fight, to allow himself to evolve. He had the wisdom to abandon the actions of war when he knew they would no longer serve him.
After a long time he could. In defense of Bats though, of the non-immortals here he probably has the greatest staying power.
He's endured more rough times than the rest, so he'd hold out the longest, though the level of his resistance will yoyo throughout given his issues i.e. he'll come close to breaking sooner but will continue to resist past the expected breaking point.
Basically, he'll suffer the most here. It's a testament to the guy he is that he's endurable because of his vulnerability. Remember he was already tortured for years by Desaad (the better part of 10 years IIRC) during Rock of Ages.
__________________
Iboga chose not to fight, to allow himself to evolve. He had the wisdom to abandon the actions of war when he knew they would no longer serve him.
Parker breaks first, followed by Norman.
Sinestro and Hal are fighters but give in after some time.
Cap, Bats and Magneto can hold out for very very long but eventually he will find a way to break them.
Sinister might not even feel physical or emotional pain. IRRC part of the reason he let Apoc mutate him was to get rid of this.
Doom and Lobo ain`t breaking.
The more he tortures Doom, the more hellbent Doom will become at making him pay for doing this to him; thus Desaad will only make Doom stronger emotionally by torturing him...
Cap doesn't break. Desaad could go at him for the next thousand years and still recieve a loogie to the face when asking Cap for info. Also ruthless Magneto does not break but standard Magneto does.
I don't know about that I've always felt that from the beginning before Cap began pulling meta level stuff despite being "peak human" was that he had an unbreakable will. I would think rather than breaking, his mind would just disconnect from pain and external stimuli first.
I have no dobut that all the guys on the list can block out pain during a fight and most of them can also ignore a session of cutting or electrocution or whatever. But when made a plaything in Desaad`s dungeons, deprieved of sensory input and sleep, exposed to drugs etc and never knowing when or what will happen next they will eventually break. Cap may take anything when he is fresh, but he will be reduced to a shell of his former self in time.
A shell yes but like I said I think he would be more likely to withdraw from all external stimuli and essentially lose connection with his body. Like a person whose body isn't doing anything but still retains mental capacity.