nate might have the tech avantage, but des has the better skill like u said...... nate has to find des to shoot them..... there not fighting in an open area.. there fighting in a area with lots of boxes and a wasteland with trees, basically a big jungle..... des just has to hide in the tree throw knives "dead nate"
and i also think desmond is a better climber than nate.....
Nate is a good fighter... dont get me wrong..... able to take down... armies, helicopters, tanks by himself.... thats freakin amazing,impressive, but people cant just fall back to the argument that drake has guns....... desmond has master skills from ezio.
battle 1- desmond beats the shit out of him.... 10/10 desmond
battle 2- nate could win with a lucky shot,but alot of places to hide, desmond jumps off a box kills him 7/10 desmond
battle 3- 50/50..... Desmond has better stealth skills.... and a few throwing knives would do the job yet nate has a sniper rifle..... one shot one kill
battle 4- Lucy beats the crap out of the uncharted chicks... she is a trained assassin
Did you only make this because both characters are voiced by Nolan North?
As for the fight, the simple fact is you gave Nate too much of a tech advantage to give it any kind of balance. I suppose Eagle vision can play a part in fight 3, and if it comes down to hand-to-hand, Nate's good for a typical brawler and all, but that's just the thing, whereas Desmond gained a lifetime's worth of training and showed how well he can use it at AC2's ending. So yeah, fight 1 goes to Desmond no contest.
Desmond is far, far more physically gifted. Nathan is pretty much mountain climber and that's about endurance and upper body strength. Desmond is a free runner. Speed and lower body strength(also balance).
Desmond takes scenario's 1 and 2 10/10. Scenario 3 is 5/10, because either one could spot the other at some random time. Desmond would stick out like a sore thumb in that white hoody. Nate wouldn't be much better off, but he's more liable to spot Desmond before he could get close with the sniper scope.
And 4 is almost spite. Desmond's ol' lady can whoop ass. Though speaking of ass...Chole wins hands down in that dept.
Man, this fight kinda makes me hope that Nate has to fight someone a lot like an assassin in UC3 as a boss at some point.