Revan vs Darth Malak/Darth Traya

Standard morals, equipment, etc. Fight begins 10m apart.

1. Darth Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya aboard the bridge of Revan's flagship

2. Darth Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya aboard the Star Forge

3. KotOR Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya on Lehon

4. KotOR Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya on the Star Forge

5. Reborn Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya on Dantooine

6. Reborn Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya on the Star Forge

7. SoR Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya in the Trayus Core

8. SoR Dark Revan vs Darth Malak and Darth Traya on the Star Forge, with Light Revan assisting Malak and Traya

Only Darth Malak and Darth Traya get the amp from the Star Forge. The Jedi bodies in the stasis caskets in KotOR are also present in the battles on the Star Forge.

1./3. Team
2./4./6./8. Who gets the SF Amp?
5./7. Revan

Only Malak and Traya get the SF amp.

Just changing it so that the Jedi bodies in the stasis caskets in KotOR also appear in all battles set on the Star Forge. However, they can be (potentially) used by anyone.

1, 2, and 4 team, assuming we take Malak's claim of surpassing Darth Revan by the time of KotOR. Revan wins the rest, with 5, 7, and 8 being stomps in his favor.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Only Malak and Traya get the SF amp.

5 being a stomp? How?

All of his showings as Reborn were on a DS nexus (which we could argue amped his DS powers, but eh) and after 3 years of being drugged and tortured, with little nourishment. I see him being one tier below Novel Vitiate off nexus and in full health, if not at the very bottom of "his" tier. Besides, taking into account how shitty KotOR made Malak seem in their fight (being just above him even with his SF amp and having fought through Lehon AND the SF before it) and Kreia feeling inferior to Mando Wars Revan, I'd say Revan Reborn has to be at least two tiers above them.

When his mask was returned to him, Revan seemed to become empowered beyond those negative effects, which Scourge noted. Although it's worth considering that Scourge also notes that it might have simply been the ease with which Revan destroyed Nyriss which caused Scourge to view him in that light.

Reven had a reprieve between Lehon and the Star Forge.

When did Kreia feel inferior to MW Revan?

The team takes all until SOR Revan.

You don't think Reborn Revan could take them on neutral ground?

1-4: Team.
5-8: Revan.

Round 8 is close.

Hard to say. I'm considering putting Malak with Vader, but still unsure if Kreia is Dooku level.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Hard to say. I'm considering putting Malak with Vader, but still unsure if Kreia is Dooku level.

We're going all the way nowww

Malak is certainly underrated, but Vader level? What is the reasoning for that?

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
We're going all the way nowww

Yeah I don't think I'd hold Malak at Vader level, maybe Dooku level or arguably slightly above; but not Vader level.

I'm referring to SF Malak, but note I consider it a permanent amp, even off nexus, so it's like a Valkorion power-boost rather than Dooku on Vjun.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Hard to say. I'm considering putting Malak with Vader, but still unsure if Kreia is Dooku level.

We're goin' all the way with this wank, huh? Why's Malak Vader-tier, lol?

Kreia's definitely closer to Vader than Dooku in Force, at least 😬

Still, when do you imagine Revan will be able to beat them both?

EDIT: Also, when do you think Kreia went to Malachor?