... with forty-five minutes of rest between each battle. How far does he make it?
1. Quinlin Vos
2. ROTS Obi-Wan
3. Asajj Ventress and Durge
4. CDarth Tyranus
5. Yoda
6. NJO Luke
7. Darth Maul and Darth Sidious
A little harder than Quinlan, but still in the bag.
3. Asajj Ventress and Durge
This might run him a little. Durge is a handful, and Asajj is no lightweight. He can take it, but he's gonna need a breather.
4. Darth Tyranus
He's a challenge for Revan. Granted Revan has greater Force powers, Tyranus is a saber master. He can take it, but not without combining effort, strategy, and his Force powers.
5. Yoda
This one is difficult. Revan would have to either win really fast, before Yoda gets warmed up, or after a really long fight, where Yoda can't sustain his Ataru any longer. I say Revan could take it, but he's gonna feel it in the morning.
6. NJO Luke
He loses.
7. Darth Maul and Darth Sidious
Might make it. With luck and everything I mentioned before, he could if he eliminates or effectively seperates Maul from Sidious.
45 isn't a lot of rest. A tired and weary Revan will likely fall to Yoda. But if he does beat Yoda, Sidious and Maul aren't that much bigger of a threat to him than Yoda alone.
Registered: Sep 2005
Location: Picking up some power converters.
I disagree that Maul and Sids aren't more of a threat than Yoda, but I need not debate it because we both know that even if Revan made it past Yoda, Revan would bear serious scars and die against the Sith relatively quickly.
1. Quinlan Vos: He defeats Vos after a relatively short duel.
2. Obi-Wan Kenobi: Revan overcomes Obi-Wan after a comparitively frustrating duel. The Soresu Master won't go down all that easily.
3. Ventress and Durge: These two would be a pain, but he'd take them, too. They'd be a beastly team, but he could likely incapacitate Durge with a few well-placed thrusts or Force powers, and Ventress would fall within a half-minute's worth of focused dueling. He could then proceed to hack apart Durge, and do whatever he wished with the living remains.
4. Lord Tyranus: Sith Lord against Sith Lord. To be honest, I don't think Revan is that much better of a duelist than Dooku. You can't really do much better than a swordsman who has mastered a form created for the purpose of dueling. Revan takes Dooku with a good deal of difficulty.
5. Master Yoda: Revan's advance end here. Arguably capable of defeating Revan even during the Sith's better days, Yoda takes out the Dark Lord. i doubt Revan would be devastatingly exhausted, considering that he would likely be able to engage himself in a healing trance, or meditation. But he would be feeling noticeable amounts of fatigue, and that won't bode well for him when he duels the most powerful being of an era.
6. Luke Skywalker: He won't make it here. Even in peak condition, Revan would fall to Luke. Forget about after he's engaged in combat against Tyranus and Yoda.
7. Darth Sidious and Darth Maul: He won't make it here. Although it would be possible for him to defeat the duo in prime condition, if he's fought past Luke, he's going to be on the brink of fatal exhaustion.
My final verdict? Darth Revan would fall at Master Yoda.
hmmmm I don't know, Revan was a very powerful sith lord. And the jedi of old tended to be better dualers. Though Yoda is great to wacth fight and might take it, I mean he literally bounces around. Skywalker won't stand a chance though. Sidious and Maul, well maybe. If maul concentrates on distracting revan enought to have Sidious fry him.
Well indeed he is powerful, I don't think he is all that uber. Hell he didn't really do much in the NJO except sit there. In the last few books he started to do crap, but the vong could still swamp him. I personally think the bouncing green man(aka Yoda) would of gone through all those vong with relative ease.
Sidious and Yoda are roughly on the same level so Maul would add some trouble. And Revan'd have to be good at fighting two opponents at once.
Please explain.
I say it goes like this:
Quinlin Vos: Quinlin attempts to put up a fight but all effort is in vain as Revan kills him with relative ease.
Obi-Wan: Puts up a bit more of a challenge and tries a few tricks, prolonging the duel, but nothing revan can't handle.
Durge and Asajj: He slices Durge up (all he has to do is beat Durge, not kill him, so) which takes some time since he has to fend of Asajj too but after Durge's gone he pwns Asajj.
Tyranus: Now he is a bit tired and Tyranus is a good opponent but after a whule he wins.
Revan: Even after facing all the other opponents Revan puts up a good fight but Yoda manages to pull this off, finishing Revan.
If only fighting worked in "levels" wouldn't it? Actually, Yoda had the advantage during the entire saber sequence, it wasn't until Sidious took the high ground that he began to gain the advantage.
Also, Maul is practically a nonfactor, he would get killed relatively fast and painlessly by someone his level. Also, Yoda's size can pose trouble, few people are ready to defend against the angles he attacks with. Is it slightly harder? Yes, but it's hardly anything significant.
Sidious wasn't winning till he had the high ground, but what makes you think Yoda had the advantage? it looked exactly even to me. And Sidious did gain the advantage when he gained the high ground. Whoch was a fair move. Maul might be small in power compared to Yoda and Sidious but enough that he and Sidious together would beat Yoda for sure.
Too bad we aren't talking about A > B, and B > C so A > C. This isn't discrete mathematics with lightsabers.
It's not like Revan hasn't fought multiple opponents before, or that someone like Maul would pose him a huge threat. Like I said, most individuals are unused to Yoda attacking at various angles and directions, that could cause Revan problems. Revan has the precog to block most conventional attacks.
And the evidence for Yoda winning the saber duel is in the script. Not to mention Sidious initially attempted to run.
Nov 16th, 2005 10:30 PM
http://darthglentract.tripod.com/index.html Go Jawa's!!
