The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
ROTS Obi-Wan (Form IV) vs. General Grievous
We all know Obi-Wan can beat Grievous using form III but can he beat him when using Ataru?
12:33 AM
Null ARC Avis The best, the elite. Registered: Aug 2005
wow nice thread. i think that he can not. He swiched for a reason. if he jumped GG would cut him to bits.
__________________
12:34 AM
The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
Just thought of the idea to and I agree with you 100% but I want to hear other people's opinions.
__________________
12:36 AM
Eminence Boss Registered: Jul 2005
You can't make speculatory threads like this and expect a reasonable answer. I could just as easily say 'Grievous with Force Lighting and 10 arms versus a Six-foot tall Dark Side Yoda'.
12:39 AM
The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
What do you mean speculation Obi-Wan has used form IV before.
__________________
12:41 AM
Null ARC Avis The best, the elite. Registered: Aug 2005
he used it when fighting maul, dooku, dooku in ROTS, and Anakin.
__________________
12:42 AM
The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
No he never used it against Dooku, correct me if I am wrong.
__________________
12:44 AM
Eminence Boss Registered: Jul 2005
The why not put TPM Obi-Wan instead of 'Obi-Wan with Ataru'?
12:44 AM
Null ARC Avis The best, the elite. Registered: Aug 2005
Youre wrong......lol
__________________
12:45 AM
Null ARC Avis The best, the elite. Registered: Aug 2005
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Darth Faunus The why not put TPM Obi-Wan instead of 'Obi-Wan with Ataru'?
__________________
12:45 AM
The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
Because TPM Obi-Wan would be destroyed by Grievous and because we have seen ROTS Obi-Wan use Ataru.
__________________
12:46 AM
Eminence Boss Registered: Jul 2005
Explain to me why a Soresu master would use Ataru. Obi-Wan doesn't use Ataru after TPM. Ever.
12:47 AM
The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
Actually if I remember correctly he used it against Anakin in ROTS.
__________________
12:50 AM
Eminence Boss Registered: Jul 2005
Well, giving ground and not doing so much as a single flip throughout the entire duel doesn't seem very characteristic of an Ataru-user, does it.
12:56 AM
The Creator A being beyond power Registered: Jul 2005
Well Obi-Wan wasn't that conservative in that duel and that is not very characteristic of a Soresu user is it.
__________________
12:59 AM
Janus Marius Plo Koon Rulez! Registered: Feb 2005
Uh, Soresu is not just how you swing your glowstick; it's a fighting philosophy. Obi-Wan was DEFENSIVE in his fight with Anakin. This is Soresu philosophy, not Ataru, which is OFFENSIVE.
01:37 AM
Nai Advocatus Diaboli Registered: May 2005
Well...going offensive into the fight with Grievous, Obi-Wan would have force pushed him first instead of fighting him.
__________________ "Dear God, what is it like in your funny little brains?"
01:46 AM
ESB -1138 Sonic Speed Registered: Jun 2005
quote: (post ) Originally posted by Darth Faunus Well, giving ground and not doing so much as a single flip throughout the entire duel doesn't seem very characteristic of an Ataru-user, does it.
__________________
03:51 AM
Eminence Boss Registered: Jul 2005
Yet he gave ground like nothing else. Nothing reminiscent of his TPM form.
05:35 AM
Janus Marius Plo Koon Rulez! Registered: Feb 2005
And spins and twists don't make you an Ataru practitioner, man. Did you not read what I wrote above, Jack? Uh, Soresu is not just how you swing your glowstick; it's a fighting philosophy. Obi-Wan was DEFENSIVE in his fight with Anakin. This is Soresu philosophy, not Ataru, which is OFFENSIVE.
05:58 AM
All times are UTC. The time now is 01:15 PM.
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threadsmay not post repliesmay not post attachmentsmay not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF vB code is ON Smilies are ON [IMG] code is ON
Text-only version
Nov 13th, 2005 12:33 AM
