So, this is not a conventional Versus fight (Darhk would win that pretty easily IMO). This is about which magical powerset people think is better overall.
Now, I am sure a lot of people will say Darhk, based off of initial gut reaction. And it's true that his magical powers make him an absolute beast in a physical encounter.
However, while John's magic might not be as tailored towards physical conflict (although he does know a few useful combat-related spells), I feel that he has shown a lot more versatility in what he can do with his spells.
So, it's basically combat mage vs utility/support mage. Which would you choose and why?
Personally, I am somewhat torn. Very few people could mess with you if you were Darhk, but I could probably find a lot more everyday use for John's skill set.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
DD for me; straight up more practical in fights.
He’s no sold things as mundane as fists/blades/bullets/arrows, to super speed attacks to science/energy attacks to nuclear powers.
He’s also immortal for the most part, which is a bonus. Even if we arent counting his assassin training, thats more than enough.
John isnt in that league; though he has some stuff of his own going on, its more esoteric, and comes w. a ton of baggage as he’s always in hock to someone/thing, in peril of losing his soul.
__________________
Last edited by riv6672 on Nov 23rd, 2018 at 05:28 PM
Well, the stuff with John's soul being in peril is less to do with his magical skills and more to do with poor life choices and constantly getting dragged into magical conflicts, like Manny did to him in his solo series. This version of John is slightly less dickish than his comic counterpart traditionally is, so he often gets roped into other people's messes because he can't say no (or says no initially, only to end up helping anyway), and ends up having to pay a price.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
He did it to the unicorn as well (though not before it got Gary's nipple), and would have done so to the shapeshifter if the team hadn't change their minds.
But yeah, I noticed, after looking in more detail, that the respect thread doesn't have some of his absolute latest feats from Legends, like the hell portal BFR, that weird golden binding leash thing he used on the fairy godmother, depowering the shapeshifter etc.
And those portals are pretty useful, yeah. Even though he has only used them against evil magical beings so far, I am willing to bet that hell portals don't discriminate much lol, so he can probably use it on others as well.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
Nothing you replied w. is serving to change my mind.
Like most mages JC works on a kind of barter system, getting this to use at such time in exchange for that, ad nauseum.
And this is a guy who mostly knows what he’s doing, still walking around w. things looking to collect, and or kill him. No one on this site’s lasting a day.
DD’s way more direct in how he’s sourced and what he can do.
And yeah, like Darth mentioned, JC can make shields...k. DD has has completely no sold (not survived, not managed to deflect) everything thrown at him magical or otherwise.
As for JC sending a FGM (and unicorn) to hell, that had context. The FGM was depowered after being defeated through a lot of luck, and the unicorn took a combined effort. So, lets not OVERsell the spell (of which we have no details re: how often it can be used in succession or what it takes to have at the ready, though JC has complained about having to keep it open, as opposed to DD’s abilities which we do know how he can use and that they are, basically, at will).
I dont think i need to ‘bash’ JC to uphold my point, and i wont. He has his strong points. They just arent enough for me to try and master his powerset when DD’s basically translates to invulnerability/strength/flight/TK...basic comic book character powers i understand, and already know where they come from.
__________________
Last edited by riv6672 on Nov 24th, 2018 at 02:31 AM
Well, wasn't really trying to change your mind. Just pointing out that the crap in John's life is more to do with just having a sucky life than anything else. The guy's life has been shit literally since the day he was born, as revealed in more detail during that bar scene where he went to try and prevent his own conception.
If you think Darhk is a better choice, that is totally fair enough. For me, personally, I could just really see myself using some of the more mundane spells John knows quite often. Like the minor tk spells (if you just need something out of reach, to open a door without getting up etc.), or the tracking spells (in case you lose something), or the direction spells (if you are lost) etc.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
Regarding the whole spell cost thing though. I don't think performing general feats take that much. I think it's particular/specific events/rituals that tend to get John into those situations.
Because John isn't exactly shy about flinging magic around. Hell, he used a spell to set Mick's foot on fire pretty much purely for shits and giggles, and used another spell to unlock and open his door for Sara because he was too lazy to get off the couch. I feel like if performing general magical feats had a notable cost, he wouldn't be so casual about it.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
Also, I kind of have a morbid curiosity about kill 6 in that vid. What even breaks there? You just hear a loud crunch and she collapses. Her neck snaps back, so maybe that? But then it could also be whiplash from having her back rapidly snapped... I am spending way too much thought on this.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
He also dropped a fire ball on Mick's foot like outta nowhere. So there is that in terms of offensive abilities.
And he was gonna send the shapeshifter to hell even though she's not a demonic being (that's the impression I got anyway), suggesting he can send anyone there.
Well, the fact that Gary almost got pulled into one with the unicorn suggests that humans can also get dragged along.
One issue with the portal spell, as with a lot of his spells though, is that is isn't particularly quick. It takes him a couple of seconds to say the incantation and make the hand gestures required to open one of them. Any opponent with fast, ranged attacks has a solid chance of dropping him before he can finish the spell.
I feel like he'd be more effective on a team, during a fight, than solo, as he would then have partners to potentially buy him time to get off some spells without being interrupted.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
Well, I don't mean that it takes super long, but it did take a few seconds in both instances:
IIRC, it took longer the first time with the unicorn, but that was probably because the spell was still new to him.
But still, a few seconds might not seem much in normal activities, but it can make a huge difference in the middle of a fight.
Edit: Though on rewatching that, I am betting that he did at least somewhat prep for the godmother, as his incantation is the shortest there. Assuming you can prep it for later release. Might just be a CW inconsistency too. It's not like that would be anything new.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
Last edited by TheVaultDweller on Nov 26th, 2018 at 03:06 PM
Well, he did show a bit. But, again, the spell in question is not exactly quick, and he needs to do a bit of ducking and dodging in between verses before he can finish it. From around 2:38 mark:
In comparison, Darhk can do the same with just a gesture.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.
KMC Community Forums
Nov 23rd, 2018 06:17 AM
