Only ring wraith that would have a chance is the Witch-King of Angmar, that is if the protective prophecy of only a non penis-wielder can kill him and his magical protection is done away with.
None of them seem particularly skilled on the basis of what you see in the film. Aragorn manages to fight 5 of them off while randomly swinging a sword in one hand and a stick with a flame on the end in the other.
So unless you're suggesting that Aragorn is a more skilled swordsman than Yoda (which is ridiculous) then Yoda would destroy them extremely quickly.
Irrelevant to the thread, but since this thread is basically dead.
I'd say that Aragorn has more skill with his sword than Yoda with sabre. Yoda has abilities granted to him by the Force that make him deadlier overall, the speed, precog, flipping about etc.
Make them equal where the fight is determined on swordsmanship alone, I'd say Aragorn would eviscerate Yoda in a matter of minutes, if not seconds.
Wrong. Yoda uses the force to compensate for age...Not lack of skill with a sabre...Some 800 years of training makes him far more skilled with a sabre than Aragorn with a sword. Just because he has to rely on the force more to use those abilities doesn't mean he is less skilled.
Realistically, centuries of training should make someone better than someone with only many decades, not taking into account raw talent and maxing out levels of skill. So yes.
From the movies though, Aragorn was far more skilled. Yoda's best attacked her while he was flipping/flyign about. Other than that, it was basic swings and blocks. Aragorn had tons of flair, even taking out one opponent while he blocked another with his off hand and dodged a third.
Same can be said for McLeod from Highlander, he should be better than Aragorn, but the fight choreography in the film isn't on par with LOTR.
that stems more from the type of fighting they did imo.
if you look at aragorns one on one fight with with lurtz you see that he fights in just as linear a form as yoda does. all the theatrics involved in fighting multiple people is just wasted movements against one person.
Gender: Male Location: This Forum, Behind The Sig.
as far as I remember the swords seem to be iron with a poison coating. I mean i dont remember very well cause it has been awhile since I have seen it.... But Yodas LS will cut through the swords. And if not Yoda is too fast for anyone other then a Jedi so he kills them all... I wont say the seconds but its less then a minute.
"Flair" doesn't equate to skill though. If all you need are basic swings and blocks to win then that's what you apply. You don't put in "flair" just for the sake of it.
Yoda would wipe the floor with ALL the ring wraiths AND Aragorn at the same time.
KMC Community Forums
Sep 4th, 2009 05:26 PM
