In all honesty, I'd say Luke takes this. While he may not have been great then, he held his own against Vader for a while and then beat him when he got into a rage after Vader threatened to try to turn Leia to the dark side. I just don't see how Ahsoka can measure up to Vader in skill, even when she is PMSing.
Ahsoka. She has been able to hold her own against Anakin and Obi Wan together (although obviousy they didn't intend to kill her), as well as survive against Grevious and Ventress multiple times.
But of course this is the Luke that was able to hold his own against Vader. So possibly a close match-up, but the main factor in Ahsoka winning is Luke's lack of experience.
It's pretty bad when Jedi Knight Luke is tying with a pip-squeak like Ahsoka.
__________________ Originally posted by Arhael Okay, look. Um, me feels no agenda to meeting and vacuum in leadership position, so me has composed 12 point plan for good happy success.
In Lightsaber experience yes, Ahsoka has more, but battle experience, Luke has more
Galactic Civil War - 0 BBY to 4 ABY
Clone Wars - 22bby to 19 bby
So Luke would have move battlefield experience by a year.
I just can't see Ahsoka winning, but it would be a cool matchup.
__________________ Every moment and every event of every man's life on earth plants something in his soul.
- Thomas Merton
Like I said, they didn't intend to kill her. Luke would be too slow for Ahsoka, who's had at least 10 years of proper jedi training, compared to what 4 years at the most? And i'm pretty sure Yoda didn't have a lightsaber to train Luke with...
True, but Vader has the Force unlike Grievous and Luke would need strong force shields to fight him. I do not think it is debatable that Vaders force powers are greater than Tanos.
I guess so.. but I'll just note that Grevious has recently learned a way of defending against force attacks, which is evident in TCW Season 5 episode 9.
Jan 13th, 2013 12:42 PM
