It'd be a harder time for Mace than Sidious had, as Mace prefers sabers and they did alright in that area, force being the larger problem, but still, Mace without a doubt wins.
This is an interesting matchup. I believe that Mace is personally above either brother individually. However, unlike with Sidious, Vaapad will not give him as much power to combat the brothers.
He also has only one lightsaber and does not possess Sidious's acrobatics, making it more difficult for him to fight the brothers head on. Could go either way I suppose.
Registered: Feb 2013
Location: Veniversum Vivus Vici.
Account Restricted
If this is Clone Wars Mace or RotS Mace, then he destroys both brothers, even quicker than Sidious did.
As Dark siders, the brothers won't be magically immune to Vapaad where Sidious wasn't; and the bleed-off from their power would power Mace sufficiently through the duel.
With speed that edged out Sidious' own and the knowledge and understanding of Shatterpoints, he would also kill the brothers much quicklier than Sidious did.
Add to the fact that whereas Sidious was playing with both brothers, the way a cat toys with mice - Mace would want to dispatch them as soon as possible, and would power and cut through them with his superior speed and skill, taking them both down in under a minute.
Mace Windu may not have the maneuverability Kenobi has with Jar'Kai, but he has way more formidable TK. There is no question in my mind that the all out goes to him. The question is really the sabers only.
I don't think a second lightsaber is needed either, Mace could keep Savage at bay with his lightsaber skills and Maul at bay with his force powers.
But a second lightsaber would help Mace, ALOT!
__________________ Every moment and every event of every man's life on earth plants something in his soul.
- Thomas Merton
You people are forgetting that with his effective use of Vaapad and Shatterpoint he actually beat Sidious, a much, much more powerful opponent.
Mace, by using these two powerful and unique abilities managed to defeat someone who is his superior in both skill with a lightsaber and Force power. These two brothers are below Mace in both categories. There's nothing to suggest he wouldn't he able to take this.
__________________
Last edited by Col. Valerian on Feb 18th, 2013 at 05:44 PM
People overhype these abilities. The gap between Mace and Sidious is not nearly as ginormous as people like to paint in sabers. Back when Dooku was in the order even with Vaapad and Shatterpoints he was able to match him.
Has Vaapad ever been shown to give a powerboost with two opponents? If so then yeah Mace dominates, if not this is a bit closer than you may think. I think Mace'll still win, but it will by no means be a stomp.
This is where A>B>C doesn't quite work and why it was essential to seperate Sidious vs the Brothers fight into the categories of Sabers, Force and All-Out.
Despite what Sidious did to them, both the Zabraks are actually powerful with force tk. Clearly neither of them are on Mace's level, but I highly doubt Mace will be rag dolling them around the way Sidious was. (Anyone's welcome to make the case that he would but I'm just not seeing it).
So it's really going to come down to Sabers. Imo Maul is tough enough on his own in that department. He held his own against Sidious (I know some people think Sidious was holding back blah blah).
But against Both of them, and Mace only using a single Saber? No I personally just don't see him winning at all.
He doesn't need to ragdoll them. All he has to do is push one of them away (likely Maul) and then overpower Savage. I think Mace can take down Savage in a good amount of time. And also keep in mind, Mace's swordsmanship is on the level of Tyranus. The same Tyranus who was able to off Kenobi in the midst of dueling skywalker.
Maul Brothers VS. Mace Windu
Feb 18th, 2013 07:16 AM
