Batman with full gear and gadgets, against Thor with normal street clothes? Ill go with Batman in the end, especially of this is in Gotham, but it would be a good fight.
Batman is really great in comics, but in near real life like what you get in live action movies, his suit has to be the stupidest thing that a person could wear to a fight. Exploitation is written all over him, from being able to pull his cape over his head and beating the hell out of him, to displacing the eye sockets on his cowl and beating the hell out of him. Anyways, Thor beats the hell out of him.
Maybe. Still think Thor wins despite the armor. Didn't really help him at all when he faced Bane. Thor is bigger and more experienced than Bane and from their respective fight scenes, seems a whole lot faster.
Batman wasnt really in his physical prime when he lost to Bane, here according to the OP he is. Dont get me wrong, I can see Thor winning fine, this is a very close match, with pretty even combat feats for both, but in the end Im giving a slight nod to Batman.
Pretty sure he dealt Ras fine at the end of BB, and this was after Batman had been through how many of his personal guard and been knocked unconscious an hour or so earlier.
IMO Batman wasn't in his prime in terms of skills when he fought Ra's, still not a master (compared to what he is supposed to be). He had "only" trained for 7 years, but wasn't really tested yet at that point.
He was worn out by the time of TDKR though, as said by the doctor.
This is a tough match to call. I think it depends on how much damage Batman's suit will be able to soak up, as I give the skill/strength/experience edge to Thor. I can see Batman pulling off some wins, but I see Thor taking the majority.
__________________ Never take life seriously. Nobody gets out alive anyway.