Batman's applicable feats (only from the cinematics - no gameplay mechanics):
In this Alternate Universe, SHIELD has sent in Captain America to take down the mysterious vigilante Batman. The Dark Knight is well informed the formidable super soldier is coming for him. Bruce also knows about Cap's abilities. Cap does not know much about Batman.
The fight will take place on Batman's turf, Gotham's city streets at night.
- Cap has his shield
- Batman has all equipment shown in cinematics and Baleman movies.
Can the rookie Dark Knight take down the Captain?
____________________________________________
The fight can only last for 30 minutes. If there is no winner, it is a tie.
Scenario I: Both on No-kill mode. Knock out or incapacitation.
Batman should win. Smashed through that concrete wall, has the utility belt, and boasts not only a far superior intellect, but equally superior martial arts skills.
Batman in the Arkham games fought evenly with Deathstroke and won. He also took hits from Bane and the Titan monsters not to mention finding a way to stop Solomun Grundy.
then a big screen Batman will finally be able to have a good fight with big screen Cap...hopefully... with Snyder directing though its a pretty good bet id say