Mistakes/Holes in The Lord of the Rings

You can discuss holes (mistakes) that you found in each and every Lord of the Rings films even the extended editions.

Just make sure you tell us the chapter (optional), Time (ex.2:34:08), part, and just anything else you need to include.

Happy Searching.

Seconds is asking a bit much but it sounds like a challenge 😄

Oh my! 😱

any1 going to contribute!?

i'll look right now........

In The Return of the King

Spoiler:
just as they destroy the ring

Spoiler:
werent able to walk as they were going up the mountain

To me that makes no sense...i dont know if that is much of a hole but you know.

Also in The Return of the King at 2:53:07 you see Aragorn being crowned king at Minas Tirith...Now how do you think that they went from Rivandel all the way over to minas tirith and not just him everyone including Frodo, Sam, Pippin, Merry.

am i on my own or what

<general spoilers in the post below... for those who still havent read the book or seen the film 😕>

Originally posted by theone0103
they before

Spoiler:
werent able to walk as they were going up the mountain

and when they were going out they were able to run...

Originally posted by theone0103
you see Aragorn being crowned king at Minas Tirith...Now how do you think that they went from Rivandel all the way over to minas tirith and not just him everyone including Frodo, Sam, Pippin, Merry.

Now that makes a lot more sence, but i still said that i wasn't sure if this was a mistake.....if they would have put more scenes in the movie explaining this that would have been a lot better...that brings me back to thinking that Lord of the Rings:The Return of the King could have been a lot more longer...

I'm fairly certain that Gollum would have been incinerated on his fall to the bottom of Mount Doom.

Nobody has found any mistakes in these 3 hour movies, come on...you have 9 hours to work with...(technically 9 hours and 17 minutes)

I did happened to notice, but it may be JUST ME, i must go back on slow mo on the part, but when gollum attacks Frodo and Sam as Sam is carrying Frodo up the mountain, and Sam and Gollum fight, you see Sam slash gollum on the stomach with his sword, and gollum is holding his stomach more on the left of it, like he was slashed on the left of his stomach, BUT when you see him fall into the lava, the slash is more on the right side then

is it just me? did anyone else notice that?

I think that Tolkien had developed temporary writer's block when the Hobbits reached Buckland and dwelt there with unnecessary detail such as their bathing which was merely pollyfiller until the story kickstarted again with the excursion to the Old Forest.

Originally posted by OrliNElijahsGrl
I did happened to notice, but it may be JUST ME, i must go back on slow mo on the part, but when gollum attacks Frodo and Sam as Sam is carrying Frodo up the mountain, and Sam and Gollum fight, you see Sam slash gollum on the stomach with his sword, and gollum is holding his stomach more on the left of it, like he was slashed on the left of his stomach, BUT when you see him fall into the lava, the slash is more on the right side then

is it just me? did anyone else notice that?

Do you have a time for that in length of the movie like 2:34:08 but the real time?