Replace Hulk in these fights!!

Ok, so we magically replace Hulk with Wolverine in each of Hulk's fights. Their opponents all fight as they did when they fought Hulk, i.e. if they traded blows with Hulk, they trade blows with Wolverine.

How far does Wolverine get, assuming his opponents all fight the way they do against Hulk? So they don't go intangible (if they can), or stay 2 miles away and spam energy blasts etc. Imagine their most famous fights with Hulk in your head, but now with Logan.

1. Captain America
2. Namor
3. Abomination
4. Thing
5. Rulk (not the latest hour of power version, but back when he could absorb powers; when Hulk was fighting him)
6. Thor (who isn't staying on the other side of the globe and spamming lightning strikes etc, but is fighting like usual, up close and personal. No, against Nul isn't normal).
7. WWH Sentry

I'd put Gladiator but....he's been stabbed.

Where does Logan stop?

He should really stop at Namor going by common sense of just their powerset but...it's Logan so...

I think he puts Abom down but Ben clobbers him. Yeah, he gets to 4, possibly 5.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
How far does Wolverine get, assuming his opponents all fight the way they do against Hulk?

So... basically... you want them all to bend over and receive numerous direct hits from adamantium claws, yes? Especially Sentry?

That's the point of this thread? vin

Well....I mean.....Hulk has some of the best fight records in comics.

I want to see what happens if someone similar (massive damage output, HF, no flight or energy attacks or superspeed) can do in his shoes.

Wolverine is too deadly tbh. You can even add Mongul, Kalibak, Damage, etc... and have them fight like they were portrayed in comics and he would still stomp and fsr easily than most Heralds. Wolverine is just that haxxed.

So Wolverine would be herald level iyo?

The big difference is that Hulk uses blunt force while Wolverine uses cutting/piercing, suspension of disbeliefe might let you buy that Cap can get pummeled by Hulk over like 2-3 pages but not really getting dismembered by Wolverine over the same length.

Wait...so he gets hit with the same punches and he gets the same hits that Hulk got in on them?
Because anytime Hulk punched any of them in the face would be a one shot for logan

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Wait...so he gets hit with the same punches and he gets the same hits that Hulk got in on them?
Because anytime Hulk punched any of them in the face would be a one shot for logan

Lots of CIS and PIS in Hulk's fights, I agree.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Wait...so he gets hit with the same punches and he gets the same hits that Hulk got in on them?
Because anytime Hulk punched any of them in the face would be a one shot for logan

You could replace them with any of the heros villains. Thor, Superman, Wonder Woman, Hulk etc... if they are fighting anywhere close to the way they fought any of the heros i mentioned above and they can be cut and doesnt possess a crazy healing factor, Wolverine is beating them.

Please stop mentioning other characters unless they have showings against the ones named here in canon admissible comics, please.

I get some of you are super salty, but please not here. I want to avoid the usual DC suspects in here, so let's make mine Marvel please.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Wait...so he gets hit with the same punches and he gets the same hits that Hulk got in on them?
Because anytime Hulk punched any of them in the face would be a one shot for logan

Precisely.

And Thing, fyi, got his ass handed to him by Logan numerous times. He's like the worst choice here.

Worst choice for a slugfest, I agree. But then, arguably, getting into a slugfest with Hulk is also the stupidest thing to do.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Worst choice for a slugfest, I agree. But then, arguably, getting into a slugfest with Hulk is also the stupidest thing to do.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
suspension of disbeliefe might let you buy that Cap can get pummeled by Hulk over like 2-3 pages but not really getting dismembered by Wolverine over the same length.

If characters don't fight smart against Wolverine they usually would or actually end up like in the What if... where Wolverine is a Hydra Agent.

Or in any other What if involving Wolverine, lol.

Those bubs get snikted.

Sounds like PIS, really. For the sake of plot, Cap can fight the Hulk for 2-3 pages etc.

But that's why it's a gauntlet. Surely there's a point where slugging it out will stop being effective?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Ok, so we magically replace Hulk with Wolverine in each of Hulk's fights. Their opponents all fight as they did when they fought Hulk, i.e. if they traded blows with Hulk, they trade blows with Wolverine.

How far does Wolverine get, assuming his opponents all fight the way they do against Hulk? So they don't go intangible (if they can), or stay 2 miles away and spam energy blasts etc. Imagine their most famous fights with Hulk in your head, but now with Logan.

1. Captain America
2. Namor
3. Abomination
4. Thing
5. Rulk (not the latest hour of power version, but back when he could absorb powers; when Hulk was fighting him)
6. Thor (who isn't staying on the other side of the globe and spamming lightning strikes etc, but is fighting like usual, up close and personal. No, against Nul isn't normal).
7. WWH Sentry

I'd put Gladiator but....he's been stabbed.

Where does Logan stop?

your order is weird...thing should be 2, Namor 3, Abom 4. He shouldnt beat Namor...but he potentially could, wont get past Abom but makes him works for it and has no chance against Rulk etc

Even in a pure slugfest?

And Thing was where he was just based on the sheer number of fights he's had with Hulk. But sure we could bump things around.

I assume he would have no chance against Thor and WWH Sentry either then? Assuming they all fight as they do against Hulk.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Even in a pure slugfest?

And Thing was where he was just based on the sheer number of fights he's had with Hulk. But sure we could bump things around.

I assume he would have no chance against Thor and WWH Sentry either then? Assuming they all fight as they do against Hulk.

wait...so his claws are sheathed?