superman kills valkyrie with ease (although shes hot, i dont see any reason why he should, anyways...) diana battles hulk quite well as she did against DD. Aquaman would have fun in the water. Then it bcoms 3 on 2.
Diana takes on thor, clark beats hulk till he refuses to emerge again and kills banner. Then it bcoms 3 on 1. And am sure we all know what happens next..
Asgard has a new King:superman
And A New Queen:diana
And The King Of The Asgardian Seas: Aquaman.
That's assuming they pair off the way you want. I could easily claim a scenario where Thor attacks with an AOE that stuns Superman and WW and kills Aquaman right off the bat. Then Hulk and Valkyrie tag team Diana while Thor occupies Superman. WW might manage to kill Valkyrie but she dies herself. Then it's Thor & Hulk vs. Superman and this is where it gets interesting.
Realistically: Thor, Hulk and Superman should be the last ones standing... and at this point its hard to figure out who wins. I'm giving Superman a slight majority due to speed but the Revengers can snag a few victories on their own.
Tbh I wouldnt fancy Thors chances against JL Superman without Stormbreaker.
We know he can pack a lot of power into 1 Lightning punch/attack, but its not as clear how powerful his spamming is. Certainly doesnt seem Nuke level. And Superman can likely take a few full powered lightning punches anyway.
So Thor pretty much has to rely on his durability, which is a lot to ask.
He needs Stormbreaker so every hit of his that lands is going to mean serious serious trouble for Supes.
You have to remember that the Kryptonian ship's lasers hurt Superman pretty badly, and Thor's lightning has way better feats than that laser.
Anyway, not saying Thor can take out Superman. I don't think he has enough oomph to take out Superman with a single hit. But multiple lightning strikes or amped punches should hurt Superman. At the very least it should keep Superman occupied. After all, we've never seen Superman tank anyone with as much destructive output as Thor.
The facts show he lost. I know to trolls like yourself who think Superman solos this and that in their own minds can’t be swayed by actual facts. You sound like a Trumper.