Lord Lucien
Lets all love Lain
Originally posted by quanchi112
Unblockable death out of a wand because it sure killed Harry Potter and dumbledore, amiright ? Who has the guy killed that impressed you ? Go ahead name somebody.
Uh, Avada Kedavra
did kill Dumbledore, genius. From Snape.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Wrong, we also argue implied power we don't accept this death spell kills anyone and everyone from alternate worlds just because it killed a few humans.
So then how do you argue it at all? It's all supposition and opinion when you start crossing characters and entities from
fictional universes. Seriously, how can we possibly, and accurately, measure LotR magic vs. Sauron's magic? Don't pussyfoot around this question. Answer it.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Gandalf did defeat him not at his best his best was gandalf the white. That's easily more impressive than any of Voldemort's kills.
Fascinating, Gandalf went hand-to-hand with a Balrog and took him several days at the cost of his life. You think Voldemort would engage in fisticuffs? He has a wand that can literally manipulate the physical universe. With no inter-universe barriers, he can literally douse the Balrog with water and apparate away.
Originally posted by quanchi112
You calling someone else slow is juicefully ironic. No, Voldemort would not. His death spells can't even kill and slaughter teenagers. It's weak by comparison.
Can you not read? I didn't call you slow; I called you dumb.
And it's weak in comparison to... what exactly? A mace? Don't make me laugh. An 11-year old boy levitated a club out of a troll's hands. The most powerful Dark wizard who ever lived can levitate a mace out of Sauron's hands, and Sauron has no way to deflect the spell.
Or do you think that the magic that prevented Harry's death applies to Sauron? Do you honestly believe that Sauron's mother died protecting him and so is imbued with the same magical protection that saved Harry? Do you honestly believe that Sauron is a Horcrux that will protect him from a Killing Curse just like it did Harry? Do you honestly believe that Sauron is in possession of the Elder Wand and it recognizes him as his rightful master? Or are you just so dense that you don't realize that creating barriers between fictional universes to inhibit your chosen side's leads to a debate that is composed of pure opinion, and is thus useless?
Originally posted by quanchi112
See this is why I will always beat someone like you in a debate. You are so emotional you seek to insult someone who disagrees with you. Keep it together I don't need your internet emotions affecting me.
If you need to tell me this it means I
am having an affect. Try toughening your skin and growing a pair you quasi-stoic sissy.
Originally posted by quanchi112
We also go by portrayal not some warped logic that these death spells are instant death to anyone and everyone from any other movie. Please use some common sense you are embarrassing yourself.
"Go by portrayal". I know that's what we do, I've been doing it this whole time. Sauron is
portrayed doing nothing combative outside using a melee weapon augmented by the Ring's power. Voldemort is portrayed (as are his minions and little children) to be able teleport, levitate objects, vanish solid matter, create solid matter, manipulate the physics of solid matter, torture with a word, mind-rape with a word, kill with a word, create infernos, stun, explode, and cut things with a flick of their wrist. And Sauron has... a mace.
Or have you been trying to argue that Sauron's alchemical and telepathic abilities are somehow indicative of technical prowess, invulnerability, and super speed. Well so far, Fellowship of the Ring showed he's capable of swinging a mace at non-magical, non-teleporting, non-one hit killer, having his hand (the one in closest proximity to the nigh-indestructible Ring) cut off by a sword, and we've seen his penchant for slowly reaching towards downed enemies with sharp blades in their hands. That last one also shows us his lack of foresight, reflexes, and combative stratagem.
Originally posted by quanchi112
I never said it cancels it out Sauron is simply too powerful to fall down to this.by your logic any wizard in lotr could beat him because all he did was swing a mace. You simply don't grasp what you watch and need feats otherwise you;re simply lost on character portrayals and implied power.
No, I'm open to them. But I also recognize that if we're to have a discussion about magical beings from completely separate and unrelated universes, we can't be placing limitations on their abilities simply because we "think that's how it should happen," or "this is what I feel is implied." That's why in every Star Wars vs. Harry Potter thread, the Force can't block magic, and magic can't block the Force. Same principle applies here: Sauron's body can deflect Harry Potter magic, and Voldemort can't deflect Sauron's magic. If we start doing that then we have everyone opining about what they think blocks this spell, or this Force attack, or this... whatever magical offensive weapon Sauron has (and doesn't seem to ever use).
No barriers.