i know this was long ago but i cant stand while lies are left to stink up the truth. one there is no way in hell that valdy could kill the witch king why well here when he said no man could kill him t wasnet that no male could kill him he meant no mortal the only reason he died is because the knife that the hobbit used to stab his leg was enchanted with ancient powerful magic that was strong enough to break the immortality curse that the witch king had on him which led to his death and there you go avadra kadavra would not do anything to him his curse protects him from such a spell he cannot be killed unless you have a holy and very powerful type of attack which is something that voldemort dosent have
Ill put in my 2 cents. Frankly, saying the WK can't be killed by Voldy is incorrect. Saying there is a decent CHANCE Voldy can kill him is in the right, however. Either way, the Black Voice (that scream) puts people on the ground or cowering. And with how high pitched it is, I am half inclined to say theres a possibility of busting eardrums.
Regardless, Voldy will not necessarily know of his weakness to fire (I also think it was just the robes, FYI) and therefore there is no base support to say that Voldy will spam fire spells. More likely he will Avada Kedavra (he uses it all the time, even when it didnt work the first time. Repeat and hope for a different outcome) which I am of the opinion it wont affect the undead.
Its a tossup as to whether or not Voldy decides to run away or uses a spell that can hurt the WK in time. Once the WK is within swinging range of Voldy, Voldy goes down faster than a penny ho.
I would point out that dementors do that to people, as well: make the cower in fear. They also have high-pitched scream. Voldy does whatevs around them and even commands them.
Someone made the argument that Voldy uses fiendfyre quite often (RJ?). In versus threads, unless the OP states otherwise, CIS and PIS is off. Both characters will come out swinging with their best to win.
If he uses AK, imo, the fight is over in an instant as it magically kills the person. It removes the soul.
How is the WK supposed to kill a cloud of smoke that can cast spells?
IMO, it is not a toss-up. There is not contest. The WK is just big. That's his only advantage in any versus fight. Voldy wins 10/10 times and with ease. This, imo, is a spite thread.
Yeah, I really hate how the WK has very few movie feats, he seemed like he would be an awesome character if elaborated on (granted, Tolkien himself never really did, but they were sub villains)
Anyways, I would say that the WK has no soul to sever, being dead already.
I haven't seen much dementor stuff, granted I have only seen a couple (like, 3 or 4) of the films. Never really cared enough to watch them.
Thing is, Voldy has to sleep right? Eat? WK doesn't
I know its spite, it really can't be anything other when it involves the WK. He has to much "implied" power and not enough "exposed" power.
I know, thats pretty much what I said. But the fact that he is the primary antagonist of the HP book series means he has some serious idiocy on his side by requirements of the plot.
The WK is a sub-villain that, while powerful in his own right, is ment to challenge the protagonists enough that they feel they will surely die, before someone takes him out and gives the heroes hope that they will win.
In the part of my mind that I normally reside in, WK wins.
In the part of my mind that I use with debates, Voldemort wins. However sadly.
KMC Community Forums
Jul 23rd, 2011 09:36 PM
