KMC Forums - Can the Master Sword cut through Sauron's ring ?

Home » Movie Genres » Foreign Cinema » Can the Master Sword cut through Sauron's ring ?

Can the Master Sword do it ? You do not have permission to vote on this poll.
Succeeds	10	52.63%
Failure	9	47.37%
Total:	19 votes	100%

[Edit Poll (moderators only)]

Can the Master Sword cut through Sauron's ring ?
Started by: quanchi112

Forum Jump:

Pages (21): « First ... « 5 6 [7] 8 9 » ... Last »

Last Thread Next Thread

Author

Thread

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
So something she stated about the franchise, that wasn't in that particular medium, is counted as a fact? Something which is never objected to?

Her word only applies to books not movies. Nothing I said is contradicted. Get over it.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:10 AM

Click here to Send quanchi112 a Private Message

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

So he's straight in the films?

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:12 AM

Click here to Send BloodRain a Private Message

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
So he's straight in the films?

It isn't addressed so we don't know.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:14 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

Then it's fair to say you can't contest the idea of the flames destroying one?

More than enough to prove the point.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:20 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
Then it's fair to say you can't contest the idea of the flames destroying one?

More than enough to prove the point.

I can say her opinion is only relevant to the books not the movies.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:26 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

You can, but ya just said you don't know as to Albus. So can't say for sure over this.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:30 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
You can, but ya just said you don't know as to Albus. So can't say for sure over this.

I said we don't know. It as never addressed.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:32 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

Exactly, so you that's your stance on Albus and the flames.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:33 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
Exactly, so you that's your stance on Albus and the flames.

My point is Rowling's word doesn't mean shit as far as the movies are concerned. This confirms it. Thanks for conceding.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:37 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
Then it's fair to say you can't contest the idea of the flames destroying one?

More than enough to prove the point.

Simple redirection.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:39 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
Simple redirection.

My statement was that Rowling's word only applies to the books so your point is moot. As always.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:40 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

You just have the 'we don't know' post a min ago.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:42 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
You just have the 'we don't know' post a min ago.

The whole we don't know rests on a director tackling the issue. Rowling's opinion only applies to the books. If it didn't we would already have the answer.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:54 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

Yes, but as with Albus in the films, you dont know either way.

As said, still works to my point that magical + physical destruction is what's needed. Whether it's 3, 3 and a half or 4 methods.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 01:58 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
Yes, but as with Albus in the films, you dont know either way.

As said, still works to my point that magical + physical destruction is what's needed. Whether it's 3, 3 and a half or 4 methods.

Point is Rowling doesn't determine what they put into the films.

What are you talking about ?

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 02:07 AM

BloodRain
Knight of Retribution

Gender: Male
Location: Midcyru

Point was that you can't say yay or nay to it's canon status.

The methods to destroying a horcrux.

__________________

"Gonna need more chloroform..."

"If you look down on us, judge us, condemn us... then you shall fear us!"

Mar 6th, 2014 11:09 AM

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by BloodRain
Point was that you can't say yay or nay to it's canon status.

The methods to destroying a horcrux.

Only canon to the books not the films. That is the point. smile

They are different.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 01:55 PM

God Cloth Seiya
Senior Member

Gender: Unspecified
Location: United States

quote: (post)
Originally posted by quanchi112
Do you realize who I am ?

Guy222

A double account, someone bias, a troll, an idiot. Ive only known you for 2 days and I already know this much about you.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 02:43 PM

Click here to Send God Cloth Seiya a Private Message

quanchi112
Disney

Gender: Male
Location: Best company on the planet

quote: (post)
Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Guy222

A double account, someone bias, a troll, an idiot. Ive only known you for 2 days and I already know this much about you.

For some reason I doubt the validity of your words of only knowing me for two days. Guy222 lives in Missouri. I live in Ohio.

__________________

Mar 6th, 2014 03:20 PM