there are three episodes of a suited vader...why would Anakin instantly create a new lightsaber in 6 hours just to get a red blade?...why ruin the dramatic end of the movie to show more killing ater 1.5 hrs of killing to satisfy a fanboy wet dream?...why show Vader killing when they didn't even show Anakin (unsuited vader) killing (as in death blow) any jedi through the whole movie?...
Gender: Unspecified Location: Hunting Big Bad with Dean
No, but it could be interpreted as at least a little time has passed between Vader first coming out of surgery and his time on the deck of the ship looking at the partially constructed Death Star. They could have had a line where Sideous tells him there's rumors of stray Jedi alive in the galaxy and he lights up the saber and leaves the room to go hunt them down or something.
I loved the music during the killing of the Jedi (Anakin's betrayel) which gave you an emotional feeling, but did I feel upset? no! They had it coming...like someone from Star Wars would say...It was their destiny!
__________________
"The greatest hero is the one who learns to face his fears and overconquers it!"
Gender: Unspecified Location: Hunting Big Bad with Dean
I loved that music too Cascador. It put the whole thing in a very somber setting that I felt was appropriate. I was sad to see what happened to the Jedi... especially being turned on by their own troops.
I'm not saying they deserved it, but they shouldn't haven given up their principles to fight in the war, maybe they would have see more of the truth then and maybe it would have been more clear that they were manipulated. Anakin also had it coming what happened to him...But again I'm not saying he deserved it.
__________________
"The greatest hero is the one who learns to face his fears and overconquers it!"
That is true...it would have been intelligent for Palps to lead vader into the OT, something like. "We have recieved word that jedi have escaped...blach blah blah in some cheesy dialogue" and have Vader leave to begin hunteng them down. BUT...it still doesnt involve a suited Vader killing jedi with a red saber.
Cascador is right. It was the Order's fault. I don't balme the kids, but if the Order had actually used its brain muscles they could have figured this whole thing out and save a lot of lives, including thier own lives. THis is a fauulure of the leadership and the philosophy of the jedi...not a six year old with a training saber.
Could have come from star wars: "oh look! someone just gave us a 10 year old fully trained and equipped army magically at the onset of a war!"
"ok...lets just take it and assume its ok, even though we know a corrupted jedi orderd it"
The order was weak, corrupt, decrepit and a danger to the Republic. (though not as great a danger as Palps was) They were the one hope for the Republic and they failed. Its war...atrocities are commited and people die, even innocents. AND! without presenting EIII as the apacolypse, the post-apocalyptic grunge industrial imperialism of the OT doesnt makes sense! (and we like post-apocalyptic grunge industrial imperialism very much...STAR DESTROYERS!)
And anakin deserved what happened to him...i believe in accepting consequences for your actions.
Gender: Male Location: Picking up some power converters.
Yeah, Vader leaves the room, then realizes he ignited his saber for no reason. He apologises to his right flank stormtrooper and then turns his light saber off. The only reason for Vader's igniting would be to battle, which would either be a really cool scene, or a scene that they just kind of added on when a battle scene wasn't needed. If they could have put the scene in the right spot it would have been cool, but I like the last fight being Anakin and Obi Wan, it is good as is.
I think it's sad because almost all the Jedi dont realize they've been betrayed by Anakin (e.g. the Temple massecre). I felt bad for Plo Koon because if you watch carefully, right before he gets shot down, he sticks his hand infront of his face in a reflexive action. I didn't feel that bad for Ki-Adi-Mundi, because he died like a warrior, killing some of the Clone Marines. Aayla I was disgusted with because she didnt do anything then appeared to fall down. Likewise with Stass Allie.
Lucas probably also played that sad, slow music for you to feel bad for the Jedi.
__________________
"Today was good. Today was fun. Tomorrow is another one." -Dr. Seuss
I felt bad for Adi-Mundi because of his facial expression... Plo Koon, I really didn't notice anything, probably because I've only seen it once, and that was when it was in theatres. Aayla, didn't really feel anything because she just fell down and got blasted up.
I really don't understand when people say "they had it coming."
__________________ Recently Produced and Distributed Young but High-Ranking Political Figure of Royal Ancestry within the Modern American Town Affectionately Referred To as Bel-Air.
KMC Community Forums
Mar 21st, 2006 10:54 PM
