Personally, I always assumed that slug fests are compromised of individuals taking turns punching each other.
In that case, Majestic edges out the second assuming he unleashes CBR style punches. However, that's assuming diminishing effect aren't play. In comics, multiple punches are far less damaging then one haymaker usually. One recent example that comes to mind is Superman vs. Orion.
I always say slugfests like hockey fights and they are all about punches thrown not you punch, wait I punch wait that's so wank sauce.
Light speed reflexs and planet moving strength wouldn't need a TON of punches to win vs Thor which is why number 2 is all Maj but the other two imo favor thor.
I'd really like to see a scan of a barrage of blows putting down a peer in strength down. Because I see this kind of logic used very often and yet most of the time, from what I've seen, speed blitzes are treated like light jabs in comparison to a real punch.
I simply don't think that on average, a barrage is going to do anything more to Thor that one haymaker could not. It's just now how comics work in my experience. I'm assuming there are exceptions (At least I hope there are) but often I see it being treated like the rule.
Are you really going to go there, Thor get's 2 out of 3 and you want to fight about the 3rd? Thor is relatively slow to speedsters thats how it is, I mean Thor in a slugfest nothing exotic is going to be a punching doll for super fast punches compared to his hits and u want to argue that?
This isn't even about Thor. I don't care if he wins the second fight or not.
This is a fundamental flaw that I find in the way people think based on the evidence that I've seen.
Why are people assuming Thor will be a standing still statue while Majestic hits him with full on haymakers instead of super speed punches that are treated as far less damaging and akin jabs? What comics exist that actually support the idea that this is how it works?
I can see the logic behind it, that's probably how things would work in real life. But that's now how comics work.
KMC Community Forums
Jul 15th, 2013 11:32 PM
