quote: (post)

Originally posted by Khellendros
In the alternate timeline they didn't say. They've fought two other times as well. Once, it was fairly even, but it was in a city and the fight got stopped before they could really go at it. The second time, they were on the Carrier.

Though the Carrier is large enough to fool Jack's body into thinking it's a city and keeping him from getting sick, he doesn't seem to have access to his niftier powers, just the strength, agility and durability. Midnighter, being controlled by Bendix, won.