KMC Forums - Spidey Sig Contest Part 3 [WOO!]

Home » Comic Book Forums » Spider-Man » Spidey Sig Contest Part 3 [WOO!]

Spidey Sig Contest Part 3 [WOO!]
Started by: Spideys Sister

Forum Jump:

Pages (11): « First ... « 6 7 [8] 9 10 » ... Last »

Last Thread Next Thread

Author

Thread

Spideys Sister
Official Spidey Fangirl

Gender: Female
Location: That place with the stuff... Yeah,

Yes.

__________________
Because

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:02 AM

Click here to Send Spideys Sister a Private Message

Evil SeeD
Black Shadow

Gender: Male
Location: Black Web of Hell

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Silverstein
you got that score because its an old sig.

but here's how i rate it

your sig is average, its nothing special, certainly not near 9.5/10. I dont wnt to sound harsh or, uncalled for, but There's no beauty in your sig, and there's nothing that makes me say "oh, that looks really good and/or hard to make". On the other hand you can have a sig that is simply a picture or so, but there's nothing really special to be admired there. there's certainly no originality in the presentation of your sig, the placement is simply fill in the blank spots. thats why i say it reflects your sig accurately.

Your speaking all of this to HS6 now .. not to me.. I didnt make it.. he did.. and I think he did a fine job. My sig. will never change... Because I ABSOLUTELY love it.. oh and.. your opinion matters as much as a cow eating grass... ummm... 0.. wink

__________________

I am the evil Seed...The seed that went Wrong... The seed that spread horror...The seed that was Never meant to be......

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:10 AM

Click here to Send Evil SeeD a Private Message

Spideys Sister
Official Spidey Fangirl

Gender: Female
Location: That place with the stuff... Yeah,

Even if I drew one for you like I drew mine? confused

...

__________________
Because

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:11 AM

Evil SeeD
Black Shadow

Gender: Male
Location: Black Web of Hell

hahahha.. If you drew me a sig Sister I would put it up for a few weeks.. But I would eventually put my original back up... smile

__________________

I am the evil Seed...The seed that went Wrong... The seed that spread horror...The seed that was Never meant to be......

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:13 AM

xNIXSONx
PSN: IAMTHECAVALRY

Gender: Male
Location: Canada

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
Your speaking all of this to HS6 now .. not to me.. I didnt make it.. he did.. and I think he did a fine job. My sig. will never change... Because I ABSOLUTELY love it.. oh and.. your opinion matters as much as a cow eating grass... ummm... 0..

very well, so be it. I hope he can take my criticism...

but since your the person using the sig, it must mean something. Its like saying your shirt sucks, regardless of you having made the shirt yourself or buying it.

__________________

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:14 AM

Click here to Send xNIXSONx a Private Message

Spideys Sister
Official Spidey Fangirl

Gender: Female
Location: That place with the stuff... Yeah,

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
hahahha.. If you drew me a sig Sister I would put it up for a few weeks.. But I would eventually put my original back up...

I have mixed feelings. Happy you would use it but upset thatit would be soon forgotten... but hey that's what happens to the stuff I learn at school. big grin

__________________
Because

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:16 AM

Evil SeeD
Black Shadow

Gender: Male
Location: Black Web of Hell

Sad

well it's ok of you to say that i spose.. cause .. i mean... your sig. is PHENOMENAL

the way you cut and paste the same picture over.. zooming in and out on certain things.. GOSH!.. I can't get enough of how gosh darn ORIGINAL it is.. how DID you do IT?

__________________

I am the evil Seed...The seed that went Wrong... The seed that spread horror...The seed that was Never meant to be......

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:17 AM

Evil SeeD
Black Shadow

Gender: Male
Location: Black Web of Hell

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Spideys Sister
I have mixed feelings. Happy you would use it but upset thatit would be soon forgotten... but hey that's what happens to the stuff I learn at school.

hahahhahaha.... Thats the way I feel about my sig. It will never be soon forgotten...

And if you don't want your drawings forgotten make a thread named sisters spidey art gallery.. . .. $20.00 entrance fee!!! smile

__________________

I am the evil Seed...The seed that went Wrong... The seed that spread horror...The seed that was Never meant to be......

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:19 AM

Barker
Thorin Fan Club President

Gender: Male
Location: Barkdonald's Inc. OMFGPlulz: dunt

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
Sad

well it's ok of you to say that i spose.. cause .. i mean... your sig. is PHENOMENAL

the way you cut and paste the same picture over.. zooming in and out on certain things.. GOSH!.. I can't get enough of how gosh darn ORIGINAL it is.. how DID you do IT?

It's better than yours. I'd bet even H.S. would say so.

Your sig looks like nothing that couldn't be done in paint. If you like it, that's your Pancake. Just don't try to bring others down by saying yours is the greatest. I could whip up something just like it in a minute or two. If this sig Contest were in the hands of actual experienced Signature Makers, such as Lana, the Sig forum Mod, you'd be out of the running, no contest.

__________________

please respond to my PM Thorin

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:23 AM

Click here to Send Barker a Private Message

xNIXSONx
PSN: IAMTHECAVALRY

Gender: Male
Location: Canada

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
Sad

well it's ok of you to say that i spose.. cause .. i mean... your sig. is PHENOMENAL

the way you cut and paste the same picture over.. zooming in and out on certain things.. GOSH!.. I can't get enough of how gosh darn ORIGINAL it is.. how DID you do IT?

if you mean my current one right now. oh its not that hard to make lol.

Simply find a picture worth admiring. and crop some of the other ones, and lay it on top of a background pic, to resemble a comicbook page. Ive never seen anyone else do this so, it might just be unique. i have a sig gallery if you want to check out the rest wink

some take a lot of time and effort while others can be slapped together.

__________________

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:23 AM

Spideys Sister
Official Spidey Fangirl

Gender: Female
Location: That place with the stuff... Yeah,

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
hahahhahaha.... Thats the way I feel about my sig. It will never be soon forgotten...

And if you don't want your drawings forgotten make a thread named sisters spidey art gallery.. . .. $20.00 entrance fee!!!

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
Sad

well it's ok of you to say that i spose.. cause .. i mean... your sig. is PHENOMENAL

the way you cut and paste the same picture over.. zooming in and out on certain things.. GOSH!.. I can't get enough of how gosh darn ORIGINAL it is.. how DID you do IT?

Who says "gosh?" Even with sarcasim?

gosh....

__________________
Because

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:27 AM

Evil SeeD
Black Shadow

Gender: Male
Location: Black Web of Hell

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Barker
It's better than yours. I'd bet even H.S. would say so.

Your sig looks like nothing that couldn't be done in paint. If you like it, that's your Pancake. Just don't try to bring others down by saying yours is the greatest. I could whip up something just like it in a minute or two. If this sig Contest were in the hands of actual experienced Signature Makers, such as Lana, the Sig forum Mod, you'd be out of the running, no contest.

HAHAHA!

I never said mine was the best by any means.. .. I just said that I love it.. and I will never change it.
stick out tongue

And I was defending the very easy to see meaning..

Please stay out of this Bud.. YOu have no idea what your talking about.... lol

__________________

I am the evil Seed...The seed that went Wrong... The seed that spread horror...The seed that was Never meant to be......

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:27 AM

Evil SeeD
Black Shadow

Gender: Male
Location: Black Web of Hell

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Spideys Sister
Who says "gosh?" Even with sarcasim?

gosh....

I do ...

__________________

I am the evil Seed...The seed that went Wrong... The seed that spread horror...The seed that was Never meant to be......

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:28 AM

Spideys Sister
Official Spidey Fangirl

Gender: Female
Location: That place with the stuff... Yeah,

quote: (post)
Originally posted by Evil SeeD
I do ...

I'm going to say I don't know you even though you're one of the very few who can make me laugh out loud for real....

I don't know you... no expression

__________________
Because

Aug 22nd, 2006 02:29 AM

chase el
Man in Red Short Shorts

Gender: Male
Location: United States

we should all stop fighting

fo real

anyways... doc

did i win? lol

__________________

"They are good people, Kal-el... They wish to be."

Aug 22nd, 2006 04:04 AM

Click here to Send chase el a Private Message

Digi
Forum Leader

Gender: Unspecified
Location:

Moderator

Scores:

In general, it seemed like there was a lot of copy/pasting from Spidey posters and wallpapers. That's fine, but not enough was done to make the pics seem original.

Silverstein, Amity, and Chase el seemed the clear favorites to me. The prudent-yet-subtle transparency with the camera is what got Silverstein the highest mark.

And yeah, I judge kinda harsh....I've been told the same thing in 'rate my sig' threads. But it's nothing personal to anyone, I'm just calling it like I see it.

Theones2: 5/10
Evil SeeD: 6/10 - I assumed he entered the red one he's wearing currently...I couldn't find one that he posted.
Bocaj: 6.5/10
Silverstein: 8.5/10
Gannon: 5.5/10
amity75: 8/10
Barker: 5.8/10
Chase el: 8/10
SpideysSister: 7/10

__________________