Gender: Female Location: Giving dirty Mr Sparrow a sponge ba
*having a brain meltdown with all this depth lol*.
I dont think..she is making them follow this path Will's destiny is there and always has been IMO and Jak's and Liz's. Jack and Will go to her at their own choice and she has no part in that choice. so the outcome was bound to happen anyway (if that makes sense)
Here in the hut she doesnt actually bend anything..everything just plays out naturally..she just says will has a destiny doesn't tell him anything about it..they then decide to go looking for the Dutchman and as she throws her crab claws down she says it again.
Last edited by LovelyOne on Nov 2nd, 2006 at 01:40 AM
Technically, only Jack is going there on his own choice. Will is only going because Tia can possibly help them on his quest to save Liz. And his destiny may not have always been there...although I do wonder at his incredible luck.
Gender: Female Location: at the second star to the right
Jack's luck comes from being the hero. He and Indiana Jones should get together seriously, because I think their kid would be immortal. Just slightly clumsy and a little too knowledgable about history. Man, my freshman year in college I took ancient history because I thought my professor would be like Indiana Jones. That's like wanting to take navigation thinking the professor will be like Jack.
Jack has no more luck than any classic hero. Hell, I think he has as much luck as Harry Potter.
On the DMC website, the game says that Jack's hat might be responsible for his super natural luck. That's a little too like Indiana Jones for my taste, but whose to say the game isn't revealing an important clue?
After all, the monkey throws Jack's hat into the water. The Kracken ingests it, Jack winds up on the cannibal island and is captured. He runs into Will again, which though at the moment seems like a lucky thing, but is it?
After all, it's because of his encounter with Will that he winds up eventually crossing paths with Elizabeth again, which leads to his untimely demise.
Come to think of it, after he looses the hat, his pretenatural method of making decisions that are of no harm to anyone seems to be lost. Though his choice to trade Will to Davy Jones prolonged his life, it worked to his deteriment when Will reappears and exposes his ill-fated dealings to Elizabeth, unlucky in that his dealings seem to motivate her to chose Will instead of him at the end of DMC and in that this is what motivates her to chain him to the mast.
His hat returns to him at the end of DMC, and as luck would have it, Tia Dalma has revived Barbossa to help the crew rescue him from the sands of Puragtory.
As you can't dismiss things like the compass, the cannibal island scene, or even the dog, there was a reason why the writers had the monkey throw Jack's hat into the ocean.
Gender: Female Location: at the second star to the right
All I'm saying is that those kinds of coincidences don't happen all that often to real people. True, Jack is often also unlucky. He is somewhat of a clutz and he is usually captured and sometimes beaten at his own game once in a while, but he's a movie hero. Think of all the movies where the hero is dodging bullets and you just know that in real life, an entire round probably would have hit him and killed him.
Gender: Female Location: Giving dirty Mr Sparrow a sponge ba
Liz is also weraring his misssing hat..or something that symbolises it..and its weird how in the last scene she doesnt wear it anymore and Jack gets it back
Liz and Jack forever and ever man. Totally OT, but I wonder how Will is going to react when he finds out what Liz did to Jack. I wonder if he will be mad, or understand, or be happy, or what...
The hat could be supernatural, or it could have something important attached to it. *shrug*
Also, I rather viewed the lost hat as a slow stripping away of Jack's character, leaving him bare to the bones. It was interesting to see what he turned out to be like when he had nothing left.
It also made Norrington an even more interesting foil, since he too was stripped of everything, and yet the two men made two completely different choices.
Then you add Will into the mixture, and his reactions to losing everything will probably be more shocking (given that his character has always seemed so steady, it WOULD have been surprising to see him become so dark. We just cheated. ) than what Norrington did.
The three men are really fascinating to watch. TnT did a fantastic job of making all three of them so similar, yet also different enough to still be interesting.
Gender: Female Location: In purgatory having kinky hallucina
Re: Re: T&T on the love triangle.
Completely agree, they are falling apart, and its hard to rebuild a relationship like this. So there is No way on earth that their relationship is going to work out.
KMC Community Forums
Nov 2nd, 2006 01:37 AM
of course not!
