He defeated them in the classic days when Sue (along with her teammates) wasn't close to where they are now. Back then Sue use to pass out when people like Gladiator or Hulk punched her shield with high force. Now her force field can withstand hit from World War Hulk, Celestials, and Galactus himself. Do you not see the power difference here? An argument can be made for beating Ben (even though I disagree with this as well) but the others? No!!!!
Panther has grown as well, he didn't have half the tech mentioned earlier when he beat them and that's cannon. Has Sue gotten faster? More durable? Able to see invisibility herself? More willing to kill her friend? If the answer is no, then none of this applies. Again, like I said to another poster yesterday, you all act like someone said BP would win by ripping the shields apart. No, sir, all the other conditions apply.
I have no problem with you saying she would win, if you actually make the argument. Saying her shields are stronger than before means absolutely nothing.
I can tell by the above response to Carver you're just in these BP/FF threads because you're upset that i called you rude and mediocre. You arent really debating, just blowing off everyone's points, in order to be...rude and mediocre.
Thank you for proving me right.