Even in Disney Canon Yoda is still of the opinion that Dooku was the Jedi's strongest student. Not Mace.
Confirmed in "Star Wars Everything you Need to Know"- [SPOILER - highlight to read]: part of the Journey to the Force Awakens series, so nothing Quan would be interested in purchasing, given he's Faking being TFA's no.1 fan .
Not saying Dooku > Mace, but just saying that part of Dooku's history with the Jedi is still Canon.
Anyway Vader's clearly stomped in the poll.
Last edited by Darth Thor on Nov 26th, 2015 at 11:33 AM
Registered: May 2007
Location: Best company on the planet
Opinion based isn't factual information. Yoda also thought he could beat Palpatine and he was dead wrong. Opinions aren't facts. Yoda's brilliance saw the entire Jedi order crushed and burned to the ground. Facts matter.
I have my two Ren shirts, tickets, and Kylo Ren action figure. You're not on my level.
I'll attempt to find the scans. I just need to know the context of the scene. Galen was able to contend with Sidious for a time before the build up of energy killed him while Sidious came out relatively unscathed. A similar situation could be going on regarding Talzin vs Sidious and Dooku meaning her being more powerful then Sidious would be questionable.
Aside from that I find it strange that Talzin didn't really employ her powers against Mace in their fight. I'm going to go back and rewatch that episode to get some context for that fight. Perhaps Talzin was hampered in some way.
Talzin and Maul vs Sidious and Dooku made Talzin believe they could not win the battle ( which makes sense given Dooku is more powerful then Maul ) and caused her to send Maul away.
Talzin then briefly held her own against the combined attack of Dooku and Sidious before being cut down by Grievous.
So she's a Sidious level force/magic user.
She was disarmed by Sidious rather easily it seems. Granted this isn't necessarily a bad showing as sword masters have fallen to Sidious in seconds. It just doesn't give us a tangible scope of her abilities in force augmentation and her overall skill.
This actually further supports the idea that Mace is not on par with Sidious without an amp as he only managed to stalemate Talzin while Sidious was able to disarm her. Granted their were circumstantial factors in her fight against Sidious.
Registered: Feb 2015
Location: Heavens of Mystic
The Birth Place
Yea. Only objection is that Talzin is equal to Sidious. They were on Dathomir which amps her more than any other character. The area she was in was said to be the Heart of Her Power so yea. My only problem.
Registered: Feb 2015
Location: Heavens of Mystic
The Birth Place
It was said it was the heart of her power so at her most powerful and in the EU she and the other nightsisters are stronger on Dathomir. Also quotes from Ventress in Dark Disciple also back this up. You'll also find here that we will say Talzin has her Dathomir feats because she performs more powerful feats on Dathomir.
Nov 26th, 2015 05:49 AM
.
