Any Given Sunday Review
by "Walter Frith" (wfrith AT cgocable DOT net)December 26th, 1999
'Any Given Sunday' (1999)
A movie review by Walter Frith
[email protected]
Member of the 'Online Film Critics Society'
http://www.ofcs.org
A couple of years ago, my favourite director, Oliver Stone, and the world's greatest actor, Al Pacino, were going to get together and make a movie about Panamanian general Manuel Noriega. The project was shelved but it's not like Stone and Pacino don't have a past. Stone wrote one of Pacino's best parts, 1983's 'Scarface', directed by Brian DePalma. So when I heard that my favourite actor and favourite director were gearing up to make a movie about one of my favourite sports, pro football, it filled me with great anticipation but the final cut is a muddled and badly edited slice of pure Americana that uses its camera like an untamed animal, and in a running time of nearly three hours, there could easily have been an hour cut from the final product. 'Any Given Sunday' also stereotypes the very nature of pro athletes, based on their bad behaviour and seduction by the big time.
The best movie ever made about the gridiron is still 1979's 'North Dallas Forty' which showed the intimacies of the business, the sport, the players and the effects of the game in a more calculating way than anything put forward by 'Any Given Sunday'. Al Pacino stars as coach Tony D'Amato of the pro football team the Miami Sharks. The Sharks are fighting to make the playoffs and for the sake of profit, the prospect of a new stadium and overall prestige. The team's unqualified owner (Cameron Diaz) makes a mockery of something she doesn't understand...the bond between players and coaches. She's a Cornell University educated business woman whose father put her in charge of the team after his death through the conditions of his will and doesn't know how to balance the tactics of her coaches and her board of directors.
D'Amato's loyalty to the 39-year old washed up quarterback named Jack "Cap" Rooney (Dennis Quaid) is blind. D'Amato refuses to accept the fact that Rooney is washed up and can't mold the new flashy third string quarterback Willie Beaman (Jamie Foxx) into his style of player. Beaman likes changing the plays sent in by the coach, often vomits in the huddle before executing a play and makes the cover of every major magazine and is more concerned with celebrity than with the concept of being a team player. This frustrates two of his most important team mates (LL Cool J and real former NFL player Lawrence Taylor) and the team is thrown into chaos with in fighting among the players. This film makes a very debatable point. Can you hold the coach of a team responsible for the actions of his players and the quality of his team's performance? Yes and no. A coach needs to communicate with his players but it's difficult when you have a hands on owner who also tries to run the show and the debate in pro sports in perhaps hotter than any other form of human interaction.
Other notable characters are the team's head doctor (James Woods) and the secondary intern waiting to take his place (Matthew Modine). Woods' character goes along with each player's every desire...despite the fact that their play could kill them based on an overdose of drugs or another hit which could be tragic or fatal. He ignores the sacred oath doctors take for the health of their patients while Modine's character is a by the book physician. Ann-Margret is the mother of Diaz and misses her late husband and can't relate to her daughter as being the team's leader from the business end of things. Lauren Holly is Rooney's materialistic wife and Charlton Heston is football's commissioner who says that Diaz's character would "Probably eat her own young if she could".
'Any Given Sunday', a heavy handed film about male bonding looks more like a beer commercial in many spots rather than the actual game itself. There are slow motion, hard hitting and musically dominated scenes of action on the field and not enough quiet moments of reflection for the audience or any of the film's characters.
Oliver Stone has been plagued in recent years with big budget overkill contained within his films. I would like to see a studio give him a total of about 5 to 6 million dollars and force him to make a film about academics rather than technical flashes of grainy black and white, metaphors drawn from other films, in your face shocks of fast editing and camera spins and the return to great film making techniques like 'Platoon' and 'Salvador' which gave Stone his status as a household name and only 'JFK' and perhaps 'Natural Born Killers' saves Stone from being a non factor in the 90's. Perhaps Stone can take a lesson from his past in order to know where he's going in the next decade....and century!
OUT OF 5 > * * *
Visit FILM FOLLOW-UP by Walter Frith
http://www.cgocable.net/~wfrith/movies.htm
-----------------------------------------------------------------
* * * * * - a must see
* * * * 1/2 - don't miss it
* * * * - an excellent film
* * * 1/2 - a marginal recommendation
* * * - can't quite recommend it
* * 1/2 - don't recommend it
* * - avoid it
* 1/2 - avoid it seriously
* - avoid it AT ALL COSTS
1/2 - see it at your own risk
zero - may be hazardous to your health
Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.
