City of Angels Review
by "Luke Buckmaster" (bucky AT alphalink DOT com DOT au)June 11th, 1998
REVIEW: City of Angels
By Luke Buckmaster ([email protected])
>From 0 stars (bomb), to 5 stars (a masterpiece):
3 and a half stars
--------------------------------------------------
Wim Wenders' 1988 film Wings of Desire was a brilliant and poetic examination of the human heart - taken from the perspective of angels who roam the earth. It enchanted us into feeling, understanding and almost believing these MIB look a like's through the way Wenders avoided common cliché's and Hollywood surroundings. Now, the 90's update version City of Angels is based on the former film in basic themes only. And although this new rendition has lost most of the power of Wings of Desire, it surprising contains a lot of its emotional impact.
Amongst other angels, Seth (Nicholas Cage) roams the streets of the city of angels, Los Angeles. He can only see in black and white, cannot feel pain or hunger, and has a useful skill of reading peoples thoughts.
Whilst Seth is welcoming a hospital patient to the after life, he notices the beautiful doctor Maggie (Meg Ryan) desperately trying to save the mans life. He soon becomes infatuated with her, and eventually comes to her, appearing as a clueless civilian.
Maggie's fascination with Seth grows until she begins to sense something abnormal, something unique about him. She consults a close friend: "I got this jolt that... something bigger is out there. Something bigger than me, bigger than you. Does that sound crazy?"
Just as Seth feels that he is doomed to remain at arms length to Maggie for the rest of her life, he speaks to a former-angel hospital patient (Dennis Franz, in a role very similar to one played by Columbo's Peter Falk in Wings of Desire), who explains to him how to "delve" into a human form. So (as the film is keen for us to believe) the relationship between this couple depends on one question: is Seth willing to sacrifice eternal life for a mere mortal?"
The answer to that question is, naturally, no mystery. But it doesn't have to be - with quotes like "I would rather have had one breath of her hair, one kiss from her mouth, one touch of her hand, than eternity without it," City of Angels is a tear jerking "chick flick" that gives a powerful, lasting impact.
But surprisingly, the most impressive aspect of director Brad Silberling's (who has only Casper under his belt) creation is not its writing nor acting, but rather the stunning cinematography by Australian John Seale (The English Patient, Rain Man). The visual impact of City of Angels is so dazzling that it gives the big screen an angelic, gorgeous radiance that no amount of Mr. Sheen's could possibly deliver.
Don't get me wrong: the dialogue is sumptuously gentle to inhale, and the sweetened performances from Nicholas Cage and Meg Ryan are a triumph in themselves. But boiled down, City of Angels is sometimes just good-looking Hollywood claptrap - and that is why it doesn't convincingly impersonate Wings of Desire. But it does, as I mentioned before, have an emotional depth that gets through to the viewer on multiple levels.
I would have loved to see this film more tightly based on Wim Wenders' and Peter Handke's original screenplay for Wings of Desire. Although this obviously did not happen, City of Angels is far from a slip-up, and Wenders himself was pleased with the final result. He was quoted in the film's promotional material, saying: "It was moving, beautifully crafted, there was some amazing imagery and an astonishing story. I had never seen anything like it, well, except for that one German film maybe, with the subtitles. What's its name again?"
Review © copyright Luke Buckmaster
--------------------------------------------------
Email [email protected] to subscribe to the newsletter (Unless, of course, you already have)
--------------------------------------------------
Sites syndicating my reviews:
MovieZone: http://moviezone.alphalink.com.au
Mostly Movies: http://welcome.to/mostlymovies
Imdb: http://us.imdb.com/M/reviews_by?Luke+Buckmaster
--------------------------------------------------
[email protected]
"How ironic - my crusade against television has come to an end so formulaic it could have spewed from the power book of the laziest Hollywood hack." --Sideshow Bob
-------------------------------------------
Movie Zone
http://moviezone.alphalink.com.au
-------------------------------------------
Subscribe to my movie reviews mailing list! Simply reply to this email with the subject as "Subscribe:newsletter"
-------------------------------------------
Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.
