The Count of Monte Cristo Review
by Dennis Schwartz (ozus AT sover DOT net)February 11th, 2002
COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO, THE (director: Kevin Reynolds; screenwriters: Jay Wolpert/based on the novel by Alexandre Dumas; cinematographer: Andrew Dunn; editors: Stephen Semel and Chris Womack; music: Edward Shearmur; cast: Jim Caviezel (Edmond Dantès), Guy Pearce (Fernand de Mondego), Richard Harris (Abbé Faria), Dagmara Dominczyk (Mercédès), Luis Guzman (Jacopo), James Frain (Villefort), Henry Cavill (Albert), Albie Woodington (Danglar), Michael Wincott (Dorléac, Warden), Alex Norton (Napoleon); Runtime: 110; Touchstone Pictures and Spyglass Entertainment; 2002)
Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz
"The Count of Monte Cristo," directed by Kevin Reynolds (Waterworld), is a sumptuously photographed swashbuckler adventure story about the dangers of living in early-19th-century Marseilles. This is one of many versions of this often filmed novel. Screenwriter Jay Wolpert adapts it to the screen from Alexandre Dumas' classic, a good book for school-age children to read. This film is a playful adaption of the book, as it is charged with good clean fun and action. It's fine if viewed as an old-fashioned escapist film, as it's one of the few adventure stories made today without special effects and computer graphics taking over the screen. For the book lovers, they should at least be pleased that most of the major themes from the novel remain intact: innocence, adultery, true love, betrayal, deception, suicide, many duels, and most of all revenge. What the film can't duplicate from the book, is its more literate dialogue, style and interpretation of revenge. If you want to capture the feel of what Dumas was driving at in its complete depth, read the book. But if you want to see an abbreviated version of the book that still gives you some flavor of what the book is trying to say about revenge, then that's what you'll get here.
The simple plot develops after a naive and handsome seaman, Edmond Dantès (Jim Caviezel), the son of a clerk, brings his sick captain for medical help to the Isle of Elba in 1814, where Napolean is a British prisoner. His childhood aristocratic friend Fernand de Mondego (Guy Pearce) sees Napolean give him a letter to deliver and when they safely reach Marseilles he conspires with the hateful first-mate Danglars (Albie Woodington) to turn Edmund over to the authorities for treason. He does this betrayal in order to jealously take away Edmund's fiancée from him, the lovely commoner Mercédès (Dagmara Dominczyk). Fernand is a mean-spirited villain who has no problem arranging this false arrest with the ambitious local magistrate in post-Napoleonic France, Villefort (Frain). This lands the unfortunate Edmund in a hellish island dungeon in the infamous prison called Château d'If, under the charge of a cruel warden (Wincott) who annually whips him.
Mercédès and Fernand are told that he was executed, so after a month she marries the cold-hearted aristocrat. She also that year has a son, Albert. One day, after spending 13 years in this hellhole, Abbé Faria (Richard Harris) digs into Edmund's dungeon cell while trying to escape. He is a soldier-priest and is the prototypical wise man, who acts to give the poor soul teaching lessons in book and oral knowledge, hope, fighting skills, love of God, philosophy, and also a plan to escape (Don't ask how the priest got all those teaching books used for the lessons into the prison!).
Taking advantage of the priest's accidental death the vengeful Edmund escapes, only to swim to the next island where there are pirates waiting for him. One of whom, Jacopo (Luis Guzman), is about to be executed by them for stealing from them. Edmund is forced to have a knife fight with him as a means of pirate justice to see who should live. He manages to win; but, instead of killing his opponent, he connives to work out a deal where they both live as pirates; thusly, Jacopo becomes his loyal second for life -- someone to always watch his back.
The two close friends strike out on their own, come across a great treasure under the sea with the map the priest gave Edmund so he can use the money to forget about revenge and do good in the world. They go back to France with tremendous wealth and Edmund now takes on the bogus identity of the mysterious Count of Monte Cristo, and carefully plots his revenge against all those who wronged him.
If you are not that demanding of a film that ends with a too neat resolution to its theme of revenge, it could be a fairly enjoyable experience. One of those innocent adventure pics where the good guy was really too good and the host of baddies couldn't have been more rotten. It's a guilty-pleasure treat.
Guy Pearce, the most heavy-handed villain, hams it up and begs the audience to hiss at him. As for the hero, at last, he comes to believe that justice can be had in lieu of revenge. But this is just not quite what Dumas was trying to get at in his writing. The film fails to make Edmund into a man of shadings, and instead makes Edmund into a typical action hero. The book was much more subtle than that. In the 1934 film version with Robert Donat, a better version than this work though still not as good as the book, more emphasis was placed on our hero finding what were the villain's flaws and using that against him. But it is still only in the book itself where you see how the villains practically do themselves in, as Edmund exacts his revenge in a more intelligent and penetrating way.
REVIEWED ON 2/12/2002 GRADE: C +
Dennis Schwartz: "Ozus' World Movie Reviews"
http://www.sover.net/~ozus
[email protected]
© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED DENNIS SCHWARTZ
More on 'The Count of Monte Cristo'...
Originally posted in the rec.arts.movies.reviews newsgroup. Copyright belongs to original author unless otherwise stated. We take no responsibilities nor do we endorse the contents of this review.
