What what WHAT?!

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Ahnold
Okay, a bit of a melodramatic title. Still... gets the job done big grin

I read an interview with PJ a few years back and he said something along the lines of "We can't keep Sauron as just a fiery eye". This was AFTER FOTR, by the way. So what gives? Why didn't we see Sauron in all his horrific glory?

Suzuka
because in the books he doens't have a body yet.........wasn't he just an eye? why can't i remember?!?! grr, help stick out tongue

fini
he was JUST AN EYE for freaking sake, ,he didn't have his body back yet, so i dont know what the fuss is all about.

sauron
JUST an eye??? that was one powerful eye, and i think they were going to have sauron appear but there was an outcry against it,

i wonder if it hurt when a bird flew into his eye, or if he could be defeated by a GIANT can of mace

fini
yeah yeah but an eye all together.
NOwhere in the book did sauron appear physically. and if PJ had put him in then would have been going wayyyyyyyyyyyy too far with the movie/book changing plots.

Exa

sauron
ive said before the flashlight eye thing was to show that sauron was looking RIGHT at frodo, RIGHT EXACTLY ON HIM and yoiu cant just change that for one minute of a movie, big flaming eyes have a tendency of not changing

Kitoky
I think that PJ was talking about how they had to show Sauron in his horrific form in the prologue so everyone knows that he's just not a fiery eye.

Exa
I loved how he looked in the prologue... love awww his armour is really cool.

sauron
i like the sound of his boots as he walks, or the shadow of him looking down on the men, and when his head just appears at the corner of the screen

Kitoky
Pimpin' helmet of his

sauron
exactly, i would love to see him in that armour but in like a tophat

Kitoky
Sir Ian McKellen's pimpin' hat?

Ahnold
Fair points, guys. I'm just repeating what PJ said, just to remind y'all. But we saw the witchking in FOTR... why not Sauron in the prologue?

sauron
we did see sauron in the prologue

Ahnold
I meant his face...

Kitoky
Sauron he means that he was just saying that since the Witch King was in FotR, why not Sauron, so they put Sauron in. And since we only see the all powerful Witch King in his greatest glory in the 3rd film so yeah....

Kitoky
We can't see his face, because no one knows what Sauron looks like underneath armor.

Ahnold
That's cos no one bothered to show us his face, isn't it... And I actually meant that in FOTR, we see the witchking's FACE {when Frodo slips on the ring}, so why not Sauron's FACE?

Kitoky
Again no one knows what Sauron's face looks like you see. tolkien never really gave us that certain picture.

sauron
even in the silmarillion when sauron is unclad we still learn nothing really important of his appearance

Kitoky
Nope, not at all.

ATM4eternity
waht is sauron, is he a super evil man, or some kinda dark evil species

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.