Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

1 Yuuzhan Vong

vs

1 Mandalorian

vs

1 Imperial Guard

vs

1 Magnaguard


Fight on Hypori.

Time to decide who the ultimate Muggle fighting force is. If needed some of these could get some upgrades since I know Magnaguards vary in terms of effectiveness based on their model and Vong have Slayers and shit. I don't know much about the Vong so if a standard Warrior is no good we'll bump it up to a Slayer or something.

Until then though, standard versions and standard equipment.

I think I'll side with the Mandalorian, at least in this scenario.

I think the Mando's do have an advantage as the ones with primary ranged weapons, but I think the IG at least is better trained and more skilled.

I'm pretty sure everyone, save for the Mando is strictly melee only. Guard/Magna have electrostaffs and Vong have that weird staff thing...

Unless the Vong also have ranged weaponry.

But the Mando has the advantage with having range equipment, which means he can easily stay out of range of the Guard/Magna electrostaffs and take them down. So then it's just the Mando vs Vong and that's the same way, unless the Vong has a ranged weapon.

The Mandalorian won't do too well in CQC; they're not incompetent, easily on-par in terms of fighting skill, it's just their lack of devotion to armed CQC combat that holds them back. That's why I see the Mandalorian doing the smart thing and staying in the background, picking off targets stealthily, and bombarding anything that attacks them directly.

I kinda want to side with the Vong; much more unorthodox tactics and weaponry that the others aren't trained to combat. Then again, I'm not sure how capable Vong grunts are.

Also, a Vong Slayer would stomp any of the competition.

A Mandalorian is fairly well suited to taking out Vong, though. AFAIK they aren't trained to deflect or avoid projectile weaponry the way Jedi are.

There's actually a source that talks about how IG-88 would have absolutely massacred the Vong because of the type of weaponry he employed. He's obviously a special case, but you get the gist.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
I kinda want to side with the Vong; much more unorthodox tactics and weaponry that the others aren't trained to combat. Then again, I'm not sure how capable Vong grunts are.

Also, a Vong Slayer would stomp any of the competition.

Hmm. I'm not sure of either. Wookie said that a Slayer has never actually beaten a Jedi so I was a bit unimpressed.

Personally I think it's probably IG > Vong > MG > Mando, but the Mando makes up for that with his equipment and ranged advantage. Maybe this is just me, but I think the Magnaguards were portrayed as much more potent than the Mando's were in TCW.

The Vong's chances are likely based on how well it's armor and weapons would hold up to their opponents.

That's because the Slayers never fought any pleb Jedi; they only faced the best.

Also, isn't their armor resistant to blasters and lightsabers?

The Vong have beatles that can short out blasters and stuff, but assuming the Mando takes the high ground and uses ranged weapons he can probably win. The Vong warrior can probably kill everyone else, if its a Slayer than he might give the Mando a bit more trouble but if the Mando keeps his distance he might have a chance

Originally posted by NewGuy01
That's because the Slayers never fought any pleb Jedi; they only faced the best.

Also, isn't their armor resistant to blasters and lightsabers?

Yeah. How's it do against electricity? 2 of these fighters have electrostaves.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
I'm pretty sure everyone, save for the Mando is strictly melee only. Guard/Magna have electrostaffs and Vong have that weird staff thing...

Unless the Vong also have ranged weaponry.

Vong have thud bugs and it's variants (thrown living weapons, which home in on targets to an extent), plus amphistaffs can be thrown as spears.


I think Imperial Guard have blasters. They're primarily melee, but Kir Kanos was good enough to shoot a pilot in the cockpit of a passing fighter.

Originally posted by Q99
Vong have thud bugs and it's variants (thrown living weapons, which home in on targets to an extent), plus amphistaffs can be thrown as spears.


I think Imperial Guard have blasters. They're primarily melee, but Kir Kanos was good enough to shoot a pilot in the cockpit of a passing fighter.

Wrong Guard being used here, the Imperial Guard are Vitiate's Guard. The Royal Guards are Palpatine.

The Imperial Guard, in their appearance of Revan, used electrostaffs and that's it...wait...ok yes, they did use blasters too now that I read it.

Although tbh, I feel Imperial Guard and the Mando aren't that far off in terms of ability.

I mean Vitiate's Guard only goes underwent months of brutal training and pulled from slaves to troopers. Yeah they can take on Jedi, but so can Mandos and considering that their training isn't so extensive, I feel that with the Mando and his training, it shouldn't be that far apart.

Plus Vitiate's Guard seem to have a serious god complex, in Revan, they charged straight into a hail of blasterfire and just got mowed down.

Although I'm not saying that the IGs are stupid, but that bit was just so.....yeah.

I'm kinda looking at it like this personally, not including the Vong, cause I don't know much about em.

MG > Mando = IG

As far as melee combat wise, that's where I see it.

Overall though?

Mando > IG = MG

Because of the range equipment the Mando would have.

Ok, then I don't know these guys, and it sounds like they're kinda not gonna win anyway.

I'll bet on the Yuuzhan warrior. They've got good gear and good skill.

Though they will focus on the Magnaguard first when they should focus on the Mando...

Originally posted by Q99
Ok, then I don't know these guys, and it sounds like they're kinda not gonna win anyway.

I'll bet on the Yuuzhan warrior. They've got good gear and good skill.

Though they will focus on the Magnaguard first when they should focus on the Mando...

Don't get me wrong, Vitiate's Guard is skilled and they could take the win in melee against the Mando if playing their cards right.

But the MG just is superior melee wise judging from the evidence really, plus their durability.

So melee, I could see it coming down between the MG and Vong.

With range, I could see the Mando taking it while the other 3 go at one another in melee.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
I kinda want to side with the Vong; much more unorthodox tactics and weaponry that the others aren't trained to combat. Then again, I'm not sure how capable Vong grunts are.


Warriors are pretty darn badass themselves. They have strong armor (saber-resistant), their amphistaff works as both a rigid weapon and as a flexible whip and as a snake. A comic notes, "thudbugs will fly back to the thrower's hand if they miss. They almost never miss."


They don't serve as the grunts, btw, they have a sub-species for that.


Originally posted by ILS
A Mandalorian is fairly well suited to taking out Vong, though. AFAIK they aren't trained to deflect or avoid projectile weaponry the way Jedi are.


Not deflect, yea, but they are fast and do have good armor.

The flamethrower would be dangerous.

On the flip side, flying around makes them an obvious and easy thudbug target, and a Mando's not going to dodge that either.

Originally posted by Q99
Warriors are pretty darn badass themselves. They have strong armor (saber-resistant), their amphistaff works as both a rigid weapon and as a flexible whip and as a snake. A comic notes, "thudbugs will fly back to the thrower's hand if they miss. They almost never miss."


They don't serve as the grunts, btw, they have a sub-species for that.





Not deflect, yea, but they are fast and do have good armor.

The flamethrower would be dangerous.

On the flip side, flying around makes them an obvious and easy thudbug target, and a Mando's not going to dodge that either.

Hmm...I'd probably learn a tad more to the Vong then with the Thudbug.

Actually I just looked up some info, yeah the Thudbugs are pretty impressive and I don't see a Mando avoiding them or being able to react to something moving at 93 mph or at least enough to avoid every time anyway. The armor could probably disperse some damage taken, but still.

Although Mando's aren't shabby with blasters either. Tbh now I see it coming down to more of a who shoots first type of thing rage wise between the Mando and Vong.

Also just one thing....exactly what kind of Mando are we speaking of?....Because a Mandalorian can be pretty much any species.



I mean I know people go for immediate, human Mando. But just curious Neph, a different species Mando could make for interesting.

Yeah it's the swtor IG. Not sure how the Magnaguards are so obviously better though. The Imperial Guard is described as so good that "the mightiest of Sith have laid down their lightsabers and surrendered to the inevitable death offered by a guardsmans electrostaff." And even the Dark Council fear them. Even Darth Nyriss knew she couldn't take them.

A noteworthy member of them has killed six Jedi and over two dozen Sith Lords. I'm not sure if even Fett has as good of a record, though he was a bit handicapped on availability.

Originally posted by Nephthys
1 Yuuzhan Vong

vs

1 Mandalorian

vs

1 Imperial Guard

vs

1 Magnaguard


Fight on Hypori.

Time to decide who the ultimate Muggle fighting force is. If needed some of these could get some upgrades since I know Magnaguards vary in terms of effectiveness based on their model and Vong have Slayers and shit. I don't know much about the Vong so if a standard Warrior is no good we'll bump it up to a Slayer or something.

Until then though, standard versions and standard equipment.

Mando wipe them out !
Pure skill win via fatality.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yeah it's the swtor IG. Not sure how the Magnaguards are so obviously better though. The Imperial Guard is described as so good that "the mightiest of Sith have laid down their lightsabers and surrendered to the inevitable death offered by a guardsmans electrostaff." And even the Dark Council fear them. Even Darth Nyriss knew she couldn't take them.

A noteworthy member of them has killed six Jedi and over two dozen Sith Lords. I'm not sure if even Fett has as good of a record, though he was a bit handicapped on availability.

By information, they are just better really and by showings.

One quote doesn't make someone better than someone else. It's nice that Sith Lords will lay down their sabers and surrender to a Guard and it's nice that the DC fear the whole Guard...

But that isn't the end all be all tbh, gotta look at more than just 1 mere quote. If we went by just 1 quote on everything, then we could just pick whatever quote we wanted for anyone and not really get anywhere.

Also Jango killed about the same number of Jedi with just a rock, some sand, his whipcord and his bare hands.

Well the swtor codex says that they're "The ultimate non-Force sensitive fighters in the Empire", which included the Mandalorians. And that they're "unmatched in martial skill".

Fett is also one of the best Mando's ever. Lassicar was a standard guardsman. Also those were Jedi of unknown rank and skill, whereas Sith Lords are all high level.

Said Jedi though before, were wrecking the group of Mandos that Jango was with, so they aren't featless unlike what is said about the Guardsmen killing Jedi and Sith Lords.

Yeah the Guard are the ultimate Non-Force Sensitives in the Empire, that's great and everything but...that's kinda a given considering where they stand in the Empire. Plus the Mandos aren't really apart of the Empire, they are just allies. So saying the Guard are the best in Non-Force Sensitives in the Empire doesn't mean they are better then the Mandos, when said Mandos aren't apart of the Empire government.


Also yes they are unmatched in martial skill, but it's questionable weither the unmatched skill means them as apart of the Empire or as a whole.

If it's as a whole then fine, but this just goes back to the point of the Mando having the range advantage to aid him.

Also a title doesn't make one all powerful, having the title Sith Lord doesn't mean squat if they don't have anything to show for it, the same with having the rank of a Jedi Master.

I just feel the Magnaguard being superior via showings and what they have. Plus their durability is better than a Guardsmen.