Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

In an actual non prep non BFR non who's better at science fight. Fight starts on a rooftop in Midtown Manhattan.

http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120605101815/avengersalliance/images/7/72/Mr._Fantastic_Marvel_XP.png

http://i.annihil.us/u/prod/marvel/i/mg/2/00/53710b14a320b.png

Parker.

Reed just can't take a punch, despite his powers.

It should be Reed, right? But I'm not sure of his history of showings in physical confrontations.

he has some good showings and some not great showings. if he gets caught by surprise he can be pretty vulnerable to having his lights punched out. can't see spidey doing it though, especially if reed is going all out as in a forum match. webbing won't work since he's pliable enough to escape any amount of it. reed should take it most of the time though either using physical power or suffocation.

Originally posted by Digi
It should be Reed, right? But I'm not sure of his history of showings in physical confrontations.
This is what i was thinking. Am very curious.

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lp7n15MOmf1qidrtmo1_500.png

They forgot, "Sensational" , "Friendly neighborhood" and "Superior"

one kick doesn't a battle win....reed's fought namor and ben, not to mention the hulk, and while hulk has made him look bad a couple times, reed usually holds his own against bricks. he's also done very well in h2h against doom on a couple occasions. i'd still take reed for a solid majority in this one.

Originally posted by JayDaDon
They forgot, "Sensational" , "Friendly neighborhood" and "Superior"

Reed wouldn't have lived through that beating then.

Originally posted by leonidas
one kick doesn't a battle win....reed's fought namor and ben, not to mention the hulk, and while hulk has made him look bad a couple times, reed usually holds his own against bricks. he's also done very well in h2h against doom on a couple occasions. i'd still take reed for a solid majority in this one.

One kick to the damn throat. Reed has consistently been hurt by low metas. His durability against piercing attacks is unrivaled, but when it comes to blunt force... even DD can give him a run for his money (Infinity War, billy club throw to his throat is the best example).

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11114/111148699/3669005-0507723588-MTU10.jpg

There are more.

umm, reed said "oww...." if at the outset of the battle reed took the form of some amorphous blob for example, or even a ball, or if he 'armored up' as he has done on the past, there isn't much chance spidey could harm him. if he retains his human shape, his head has been vulnerable at times, no doubt. but no pis and a reed looking to get physical? spidey should win too many of these at all imo.

Originally posted by leonidas
spidey should win too many of these at all imo.

Yes, he should. Like 9/10. Agreed

convinced me.

^^^you wrote about Reed and bricks and thats true, but Spidey's not really a brick. I was actuslly going to use Namor, for the heck, but like you said, Reed has a good track record. Spidey's a little different, powers wise. Thought this'd be more fun.

While in theory Red has ways to counter Spidey, in practice Peter has always done well against Reed and in general is far, far more effective in a physical fight than Reed is.

I mean Reed's powers are great, but if you compare their record (including against each other) Spider-Man comes put far on top.

I guess so. Kind of hard to believe, but, the precedent is there...

Kfish, I kind of disagree.

Their fights never really finish. You don't very often see Reed and Spidey throw down. It's just Spidey hitting him once or twice and that being it.

Reed doesnt want any more of that.

Seriously though, valid point on your part. But still, you'd think Reed would be shown to get a couple of licks in.

http://s5d4.turboimagehost.com/t1/22814285_pwnt.jpg

^She Hulk also hit Sue in the face.

Sick durability feat for Sue.

Well, Sue has to be really tough... imagine the pounding she takes from Reed, on those rare occasions he's not busy in his lab shocklaugh

I'd have dumped him for Namor ages ago.