Silver Surfer -Vs- G.L Hal

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



Supermex
Who wins?
No Prep..
No B.F.R..
Pre Darksied War..






Silver Surfer


Vs


G.L Hal




Both are in standard form no added gimicks to there own classic powerset..

yaadaveyaa
the amount of spite in this is not very fun

surfer 10/10

NoctisOwen
Originally posted by yaadaveyaa
the amount of spite in this is not very fun

surfer 10/10
the amount of marvel wanking is getting out of hand

abhilegend
Split.

CosmicComet
I would say Hal's best feats are pretty easily better.

He's also a very important character to DC (hence more regular appearances and thus more chances for feats) whereas in Marvel, Surfer is little more than a mildly popular bit player.

Objectively, you have to give it to Hal.

carver9
Surfer stomps. He hold every single advantage.

Zack M
Hal is pure will. He stomps.

Delta1938
Originally posted by carver9
Surfer stomps. He hold every single advantage.

This isn't hypocritical of you at ALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL. shifty

t0sh
Thor defeats both of them.

Dampyre
Hal ends up just like Kyle did.

Zack M
Originally posted by Dampyre
Hal ends up just like Kyle did.

How so?

tkitna
Surfer wins

Zack M
Originally posted by tkitna
Surfer wins

I thought you didn't read current stuff. How does Surfer stop Hal? Hal just owned Sinestro (With Parallax) and owned Zero Hour Parallax. That's waaaay above Surfer.

carver9
Originally posted by carver9
Surfer stomps. He hold every single advantage.

Zack M
Originally posted by Zack M
How so?

abhilegend
Originally posted by Dampyre
Hal ends up just like Kyle did.
Kyle was a rookie. Hal isn't.

One Krona buster and its over.

Zack M
Originally posted by abhilegend
Kyle was a rookie. Hal isn't.

One Krona buster and its over.

It's kind of fun to see both Hal and Kyle evolve past Surfer. Kyle (White Lantern) and Hal (God of Will). Surfer is out of his league in this one.

"Id"
Originally posted by Zack M
I thought you didn't read current stuff. How does Surfer stop Hal? Hal just owned Sinestro (With Parallax) and owned Zero Hour Parallax. That's waaaay above Surfer.

Rules say this is Pre Darksied War. Those feats are not valid in the topic.

Zack M
Originally posted by "Id"
Rules say this is Pre Darksied War. Those feats are not valid in the topic.

Wasn't he changing pre- Darkseid war, anyway? It's not like Hal doesn't have crazy feats (Krona buster).

psycho gundam
Originally posted by Zack M
It's kind of fun to see both Hal and Kyle evolve past Surfer. Kyle (White Lantern) and Hal (God of Will). Surfer is out of his league in this one. One day you're going to slip up and copy/paste the whole email of executive copy and we'll all see where they tell you to post it "or else"

Supermex
Originally posted by psycho gundam
One day you're going to slip up and copy/paste the whole email of executive copy and we'll all see where they tell you to post it "or else"





lol

Surtur
Originally posted by abhilegend
Kyle was a rookie. Hal isn't.

One Krona buster and its over.

I could have sworn I've seen you argue that GL's in general are above Surfer.

abhilegend
Yes, with proper training and experience.

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by carver9
Surfer stomps. He hold every single advantage.
So did Krona, tbh.

Surtur
Originally posted by abhilegend
Yes, with proper training and experience.

So this version of Hal doesn't have those things?

DarkSaint85
Originally posted by Surtur
So this version of Hal doesn't have those things?

Pre-Darkseid War is when Hal did his Krona buster, against a foe who was able to control his energy and siphon it off - and was ALSO immune to GL attacks.

leonidas
hal could absolutely win this. one average i'd take ss though.

Zack M
Originally posted by Surtur
I could have sworn I've seen you argue that GL's in general are above Surfer.

The higher end ones, yeah. Hal, currently is far above Surfer, but he has had a ton of experience. Kyle is a beast of his own. Hal is like a Goku. wink

Galan007
Hal.

Supermex
If Hal currently has God like powers why would i make a fight with Silver Surfer then??

Classic standard G.L Hal vs Classic standard Silver Surfer is what we have here..

So DC currently has G.L Hal above High Herald i take it?

"Id"
Originally posted by Zack M
Wasn't he changing pre- Darkseid war, anyway? It's not like Hal doesn't have crazy feats (Krona buster).
Yes he does have the Krona Feats and so on.

But my point addresses the claims where he fought Parallax and Sinestrollax. Those are not valid.

He was changing post Darksied War.

And thats after he started using the Gaunlet.

The topic asks Hal as a GL and as quoted "Both are in standard form no added gimicks to there own classic powerset.."

That makes Gauntlet and his Energy form not applicable.

Galan007
thumb up

The Gauntlet is what initiated the change, and converted Hal into an will-based energy being... Though that change was obviously specific to Hal, which is also REALLY strange. I hope that aspect of the story gets fleshed-out a bit more.

Zack M
Even Hal with the Gauntlet was pretty beastly.

Galan007
Very beastly. That's what he used to beat that alternate Parallax, remember. thumb up

MightyKalEl
Hal.

krisblaze
Does anybody remember that retard Star325 who used to post?

Genii96
Surfer wins

Surtur
Originally posted by Zack M
The higher end ones, yeah. Hal, currently is far above Surfer, but he has had a ton of experience. Kyle is a beast of his own. Hal is like a Goku. wink

This is why it is weird to see abi say this is a split.

Surtur
Originally posted by krisblaze
Does anybody remember that retard Star325 who used to post?

Yes, he was very entertaining.

abhilegend
Originally posted by Surtur
This is why it is weird to see abi say this is a split.
I give some benefit of doubt to Surfer.

t0sh
The Silver Surfer stomps this chump.

Zack M
Maybe if Hal was a kid.

Surtur
Originally posted by Zack M
Maybe if Hal was a kid.

Not a kid, but he sure likes dating them.

Zing!

MrMind
hal 6/10

quanchi112
Surfer, 10/10.

Zack M
Originally posted by MrMind
hal 6/10

xJLxKing
I give the edge to Hal. His recent showings are pretty amazing

Philosophía
Hal 7/10, at least.

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.