Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.

Discuss.

Obviously not.

No. He himself says he is no longer Sith, his philosophy no longer matches the Sith, and iirc, he was stated to have forsaken Sith teachings after Ziost. So no, he's not Sith.

Are Americans tired of winning?

Nope

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Obviously not.

Not in my opinion, no.

Yes

No but he still loses to Palpatine.

No, he is not.

@Azronger please elaborate, i'm guessing this is what the thread is made for.

Originally posted by The Merchant
No but he still loses to Palpatine.

Among other things, yes.

Interesting that a person's Sidious vs Valk agenda is likely the biggest predictor of how they'll answer this question.

@DMB: Both Merchant and I think Sidious beats him but that he's not a Sith.

DMB knows that I have ROTS Sids > Valk and Skillz has Valk below prime Sids, so pretty sure that's not what he meant.

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
@DMB: Both Merchant and I think Sidious beats him but that he's not a Sith.
I said it's a predictor of a general trend, not that there aren't exceptions to the rules.

No. He completely left the Sith Order and it's teachings. He's stated to be a "Sith Entity," which implies he is still a Sith. However, it could also just be referring to the fact he was born a Pureblood Sith. It's a stretch, but makes more sense than it meaning he's still part of the Sith Order in any way

I guess not

Originally posted by Azronger
Yes

He isn't exactly what would be called a typical Lord, but this post is better than any other this thread has seen.

He's a Sith entity without a specific rank.

He's not a Sith Lord, but he's still a Sith.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
I said it's a predictor of a general trend, not that there aren't exceptions to the rules.

Neither Skillz or Sinious subscribe to it the idea that Valkorian > Sidious so I don't think that it being a general indicator is entirely accurate either.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Among other things, yes.
raisins please sir, don't be toothless

Originally posted by slayne
Discuss.
Here: https://comicvine.gamespot.com/profile/s_w_legend/blog/tenebrae-slave-to-hunger-and-false-sith/131155/